How two-dimensional are planet–disc interactions? I. Locally isothermal discs 2025 How two-dimensional are planet–disc interactions? I. Locally isothermal discs – D

Amelia J. Cordwell, Alexandros Ziampras, Joshua J. Brown, Roman R. Rafikov · 2025

Read How two-dimensional are planet–disc interactions? I. Locally isothermal discs 2025 How two-dimensional are planet–disc interactions? I. Locally isothermal discs – D by Amelia J. Cordwell, Alexandros Ziampras, Joshua J. Brown, Roman R. Rafikov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04282.txt.

Introduction

Amelia J Cordwell and three co-authors test how faithfully flat simulations capture planets carving gaps in gas discs in a 2025 astrophysics paper. Young planets orbit inside discs of gas and dust, and their gravity opens gaps and twists flows. Real discs are three-dimensional, but most studies flatten them for speed. A fudge factor called a smoothing length softens the planet's gravity in flat models, with rival values proposed for different purposes.

The team re-derived the flat flow equations and ran large suites of both flat and full simulations for comparison. A Bessel-type potential, a formula built from special functions, matched best. Even so, total torque scaling stayed off, and gap-based planet masses may be underestimated twofold.

Catalog record

CREATORAmelia J. Cordwell, Alexandros Ziampras, Joshua J. Brown, Roman R. Rafikov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE107 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04282

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

How two-dimensional are planet–disc interactions? I. Locally isothermal discs 2025 How two-dimensional are planet–disc interactions? I. Locally isothermal discs – D Amelia J. Cordwell, Alexandros Ziampras, Joshua J. Brown, Roman R. Rafikov Abstract Planet–disc interactions, despite being fundamentally three-dimensional, are often studied in the two-dimensional ‘thin-disk’ approximation. The overall morphology of planet–disc interactions has ben shown to be similar in both 2D and 3D simulations, however, the ability of a 2D simulation to quantitatively match 3D results depends strongly on how the potential of the planet is handled. Typically, the 2D planetary potential is smoothed out using some ‘smoothing length’, a free parameter, for which different values have been proposed, depending on the particular aspect of the interaction of interest. In this paper, we re-derive 2D Navier–Stokes in detail for planet–disc interactions to find better ways to represent the 2D gravitational force. We perform a large suite of 2D and 3D simulations to test these force prescriptions. We identify the parts of the interaction that are fundamentally 3D, and test how well our new force prescriptions, as well as traditional smoothed potentials, are able to match 3D simulations. Overall, we find that the optimal way to represent the planetary potential is the ‘Bessel-type potential’, but that even in this case 2D simulations are unable to reproduce the correct scaling of the total torque with background gradients, and are at best able match the one-sided Lindblad torque and gap widths to level of 10 per cent. We find that analysis of observed gap structures based on standard 2D simulations may systematically underestimate planetary masses by a factor of two, and discuss the impacts of 3D effects on observations of velocity kinks. 1 Introduction Figure 1: Gravitational potential (a) and acceleration (b) for the different types of planetary potential considered in this paper, shown in units GM_{\mathrm{p}}=1 . \Phi_{\mathrm{K}} is the standard Keplerian potential, \Phi_{2} (Equation 1 ) and \Phi_{4} (Equation 26 ) are the second and fourth order smoothed potentials using a smoothing length of r_{s}=bH with b=0.7 . \Phi_{\mathrm{B}} is the Bessel-type potential (Equation 25 ). All potentials were calculated for a reference disc with a constant scale height of H=0.05R_{p} . All potentials converge to \Phi_{\mathrm{K}} far from the planet, however near the planet there are significant differences, especially, in acceleration. Planets have significant and complex interactions with their natal environment of protoplanetary discs including accretion, migration and gap formation ( Paardekooper et al. 2022 , for a recent review, see) . They are one of the causes for rings and gaps seen in dust emission in protoplanetary discs ( Andrews 2020 ) , and the waves excited by planet–disc interactions can be observed in their kinematic signatures ( Pinte et al. 2023 ; Teague et al. 2025 , e.g.) . While the planet–disc interaction is inherently a three-dimensional (3D) process, a two-dimensional (2D) approximation is often used to simplify the complex interaction in both numerical and analytical studies. In the 2D approximation one operates with the 2D fluid equations formulated for the vertically averaged velocities in the plane of the disc (ignoring the velocity perpendicular to the disc plane) and the surface density of the disc \Sigma (instead of the volumetric gas density \rho ). Formal derivation of such 2D equations from their full 3D analogues in a disc without a planet has been provided in the past assuming the disc to be in a vertical hydrostatic equilibrium ( Hunter 1972 ; Churilov & Shukhman 1981 ; Goldreich et al. 1986 ; Ostriker et al. 1992 ; Fridman & Khoruzhii 1996 ) . Such a projection of the 3D equations onto two dimensions typically results in a non-trivial modification of the pressure-density relation. In the planet-disc context the 2D-3D correspondence has been justified in part because the majority of the angular momentum, arising from interactions with planets on non-inclined orbits, is carried in ‘2D waves’, i.e. waves with no vertical velocity ( Takeuchi & Miyama 1998 ) . In addition, the width of the horseshoe co-orbital region is near invariant with altitude above the midplane in vertically isothermal discs ( Fung et al. 2015 ; Masset & Benítez-Llambay 2016 ) . Moreover, gaps carved by planets are qualitatively similar in 2D and 3D simulations ( Fung & Chiang 2016 ) . When transitioning from 3D to 2D in the planet-disc case, one needs to worry about the vertical averaging of the gravitational force exerted by the planet on the disc. In numerical work, this averaging is often implemented approximately, by resorting to some form of the smoothed gravitational potential. Smoothing over some characteristic length r_{\mathrm{s}} was introduced initially ( D’Angelo et al. 2002 , e.g.) to deal with the numerical singularity of the standard Keplerian gravitational potential, \Phi_{\mathrm{K}}\equiv-GM_{p}/|\mathbf{R-R_{\mathrm{p}}}| at \mathbf{R}=\mathbf{R_{p}} , but later its use was extended to mimic the effect of vertical averaging of the planetary gravity in 2D simulations. The specific form of the smoothed potential varies, in particular Dong et al. 2011a proposed several forms of the potential which differ in terms of the rate at which they converge to \Phi_{\mathrm{K}} far from the planet. In numerical applications, the most often used is the second order smoothed potential, \displaystyle\Phi_{2}\equiv-\,\frac{GM_{\mathrm{p}}}{\sqrt{|\mathbf{R}-\mathbf{R_{\mathrm{p}}}|^{2}+r_{\mathrm{s}}^{2}}}, (1) although other forms (e.g. \Phi_{4} , see Cimerman & Rafikov 2021 , and equation ( 26 ) and Figure 1 ) are occasionally used as well. The smoothing length r_{\mathrm{s}} is often written as a fraction of the local scale height r_{\mathrm{s}}=bH . The choice of r_{\mathrm{s}} affects various aspects of the disc-planet coupling, and its value is usually selected based on the requirement that the 2D results match a particular metric in a full 3D calculation. For example, using the standard Keplerian gravitational potential with minimal softening only to avoid numerical singularities in a 2D simulation leads to a one-sided torque excited by the planet that is twice as large as that in an equivalent 3D simulation ( Miyoshi et al. 1999 ) . To make the value (and overall structure) of the excited torque in 2D simulations similar to 3D, Müller et al. 2012 suggested using b=0.7 with the \Phi_{2} potential, although other analyses using the same metric ( Masset 2002 ; Fung et al. 2015 , e.g.) found slightly different optimal smoothing lengths. If instead of one-sided torque one uses as a metric the total (or migration) torque applied to the planet, then an optimal value of b=0.4 may be more appropriate ( Paardekooper et al. 2010 ; Paardekooper et al. 2011 ) . However, Tanaka & Okada 2024 showed that no value of b in \Phi_{2} is capable of reproducing the scaling of the migration torque obtained in 3D with the background gradients of temperature and surface density in the disc. Yet another metric of 2D-3D correspondence can be formulated by considering the shape of the structures forming in the disc around the planet. For example, Fung & Chiang 2016 found that using b=0.5 provides an optimal match to the shape of the gaps carved by the planet in a disc. Smoothed potentials different from \Phi_{2} or \Phi_{4} are also possible. Recently, Brown & Ogilvie 2024 suggested that yet another form of the potential ( \Phi_{\mathrm{B},H_{\mathrm{p}}} ) would more effectively capture

Read the complete text