Hierarchical assembly impedes the inference of stellar mass growth histories for individual galaxies 2026 Hierarchical assembly impedes the inference of stellar mass growth histories for individual galaxies – 10
R. K. Cochrane · 2025
Read Hierarchical assembly impedes the inference of stellar mass growth histories for individual galaxies 2026 Hierarchical assembly impedes the inference of stellar mass growth histories for individual galaxies – 10 by R. K. Cochrane (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02700.txt.
Introduction
R. K. Cochrane wrote a 2025 solo astronomy paper warning that galaxy growth histories inferred from stellar ages can be badly biased. Some massive quiet galaxies seen early in cosmic history seem to hold many old stars, which has been read as a challenge to standard cosmology.
Such readings assume every star formed inside the observed galaxy. In hierarchical models, massive galaxies instead assemble through mergers of smaller ones, importing old stars made elsewhere. Using the TNG100 simulation, Cochrane measures the resulting bias across galaxy masses, redshifts, and lookback times. Inferred early masses can overshoot by more than tenfold in bad cases. The bias grows with halo mass and with distance from the observation epoch. Correction formulas are provided for fairer comparison with dark matter halo counts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | R. K. Cochrane |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02700
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hierarchical assembly impedes the inference of stellar mass growth histories for individual galaxies 2026 Hierarchical assembly impedes the inference of stellar mass growth histories for individual galaxies – 10 R. K. Cochrane Abstract Some massive, quiescent galaxies at z > 3 z>3 appear to contain considerable numbers of old stars (forming at z > 7 z>7 ). Works inferring the star formation histories of at least one such galaxy observed with JWST have suggested that the assembly of so much stellar mass so early may challenge the well-established Cold Dark Matter (CDM) cosmological framework, or else indicate extraordinarily high past star formation efficiencies. However, these studies implicitly assume that all the stars in place at the epoch of observation assembled in-situ, i.e. in a single galaxy. In hierarchical models like CDM, massive galaxies assemble following successive mergers of smaller galaxies. Thus, inferences of the growth of stellar mass using the ages of stars within a descendant massive galaxy will be biased. In this paper, I use the TNG100 simulation to quantify this bias across a range of descendant galaxy masses and redshifts, for inferences made for different past epochs. I demonstrate that the assumption of in-situ stellar mass assembly can lead to significant biases in inferred stellar mass histories, with historic (i.e. looking back from the epoch of observation) stellar masses overestimated by over an order of magnitude in some cases. The bias increases with increasing halo mass, for inferences made further from the epoch of observation, and with decreasing descendant galaxy redshift. I derive corrections that can be applied to inferred stellar mass histories for more robust comparisons with dark matter halo mass functions at high redshift. 1 Introduction Contemporary studies of galaxy formation are built upon the foundations of the cold dark matter (CDM) cosmological framework ( Peebles 1982 ; Blumenthal et al. 1984 ; Davis et al. 1985 ) . In hierarchical models like CDM, the assembly of structure proceeds via the aggregation of smaller structures ( Peebles & Yu 1970 ) , with peaks in the density field of dark matter after recombination evolving under gravity into dark matter halos with a distribution of masses ( Press & Schechter 1974 ; Peacock & Heavens 1990 ; Bond et al. 1991 ; Bower 1991 ) . Gas cools radiatively to form galaxies in the cores of massive halos ( White & Rees 1978 ) . Following mergers of dark matter halos, the rates of which can be calculated analytically for halos of different masses ( Lacey & Cole 1993 ; Lacey & Cole 1994 , e.g.) , their constituent galaxies eventually merge under dynamical friction, building more massive galaxies. The early formation times inferred from observations of some massive galaxies ( Brinchmann & Ellis 2000 ; Glazebrook et al. 2004 ; van der Wel et al. 2005 ; Bundy et al. 2006 , e.g.) have, in the past, been invoked as a challenge to CDM (see Renzini 2006 , for a review) . Historically, semi-analytic models struggled to match both local luminosity functions and the observed number densities of massive galaxies at z>1 ( Baugh et al. 1998 ; Baugh et al. 2005 ; Kauffmann et al. 1999a ; Kauffmann et al. 1999b , e.g.) . ‘Downsizing’, i.e. the most massive galaxies forming earliest and the luminosities of the brightest objects decreasing towards low redshift ( Cowie et al. 1996 ) , at first appeared in tension with the hierarchical nature of CDM. Observational data were later shown to be explicable within the CDM paradigm using more sophisticated models for baryonic physics, in particular by invoking AGN feedback and modelling its impact on star formation efficiency at different epochs ( Croton et al. 2005 ; Lucia et al. 2006 ; Bower et al. 2006 ) . As outlined by Bower et al. 2006 , for a given halo mass, the ratio of gas cooling time to free-fall time is lower at higher redshift. Black holes are also less massive at higher redshift. For these two reasons, AGN feedback is less effective for high mass halos at high-redshift, enabling more rapid stellar mass growth; at lower redshifts (particularly at z\lesssim 1 ), AGN feedback suppresses cooling flows and prevents the growth of the most massive galaxies. The sensitivity and spectral coverage of JWST has enabled deep, rest-frame optical spectra (importantly, constraining the Balmer break) to be obtained for tens of massive quiescent galaxy candidates at z\gtrsim 3 ( Carnall et al. 2023a ; Carnall et al. 2023b ; Carnall et al. 2024 ; de Graaff et al. 2024 ; Glazebrook et al. 2024 ; Nanayakkara et al. 2024 ) . This enables physical characterisation of fainter and older quiescent galaxies than was possible with ground-based facilities. Some of these studies have again suggested that observations of high-redshift massive galaxies challenge hierarchical models. Glazebrook et al. 2024 presented observations of a previously-identified quiescent candidate ( Schreiber et al. 2018 , ZF-UDS-7329;) with JWST NIRSpec’s PRISM disperser ( R=50-350 from \lambda=0.6-5.0\,\mu\rm{m} , with increasing resolution at longer wavelengths). Fitting the spectrum and photometry with the FAST++ Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) fitting code ( Kriek et al. 2018 ) , they derived a stellar mass of \log_{10}(M_{\star}/\rm{M_{\odot}})=11.26^{+0.03}_{-0.16} for this z=3.205 source. Crucially, the fit suggested a very early formation time, with half of the stellar mass formed by 1.52\pm 0.16\,\rm{Gyr} prior to the epoch of observation, i.e. by z\sim 10 . Glazebrook et al. 2024 concluded that such early formation of such a massive galaxy might threaten \Lambda\rm{CDM} . Re-observing the same source at higher spectral resolution, Carnall et al. 2024 fitted the new spectrum and drew broadly consistent conclusions: a stellar mass of \log_{10}(M_{\star}/\rm{M_{\odot}})=11.14\pm 0.03 , with 50\% of the z=3.205 stellar mass formed by z=10.4^{+4.0}_{-2.2} . They derived M_{\star} vs z by integrating the fitted star formation history, then compared this stellar assembly history to the stellar mass expected for the most massive halo within the appropriate observed volume, given different assumptions for star formation efficiencies (see Lovell et al. 2023 , for details) . From this comparison, Carnall et al. 2024 concluded that the stellar mass inferred for this galaxy at z\sim 7-9 requires extremely efficient ( 100\% ) conversion of baryons into stars. de Graaff et al. 2024 derived a similar formation time for a source at even higher redshift ( z=4.9 ), but cautioned that the inferred formation time is degenerate with metallicity. Turner et al. 2025 also highlighted the dependence of inferred formation time on the prior assumption on the form of the star formation history (SFH). Refitting the spectrum of ZF-UDS-7329 obtained by Glazebrook et al. 2024 , they showed that a flat SFH prior yielded a formation time consistent with that derived by Glazebrook et al. 2024 , but that assuming a rising SFH prior decreased this to z\sim 8 . Hence, some of the apparent tension with \Lambda\rm{CDM} could be eased by different fitting assumptions. One source of uncertainty that has not been examined in these studies is how hierarchical assembly naturally poses a challenge for stellar mass assembly history inference. A perfect SED fitting code would yield ages of all stars within a galaxy at the time of observation. However, since