The oldest Milky Way stars: New constraints on the age of the Universe and the Hubble constant
Elena Tomasetti ,, Cristina Chiappini, Samir Nepal, Michele Moresco, Carmela Lardo, Andrea Cimatti, Friedrich Anders, Anna B. A. Queiroz, Guilherme Limberg · 2025
Read The oldest Milky Way stars: New constraints on the age of the Universe and the Hubble constant by Elena Tomasetti ,, Cristina Chiappini, Samir Nepal, Michele Moresco, Carmela Lardo, Andrea Cimatti, Friedrich Anders, Anna B. A. Queiroz, Guilherme Limberg (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02692.txt.
Introduction
Elena Tomasetti and eight co-authors wrote a 2025 astronomy paper using the oldest Milky Way stars as cosmic clocks. Robust ages for individual stars, measured without assuming a cosmology, can set a floor on the age of the universe and a ceiling on its expansion rate.
Starting from a Gaia-based catalogue, the team selects thousands of old, precisely dated stars near the main sequence turn-off, then applies strict quality cuts. A final sample of about one hundred sixty trustworthy stars remains, the largest of its kind. Their ages peak near thirteen and a half billion years. Allowing a short formation delay gives a lower bound on the universe's age close to the standard value. No star's age forces an older universe beyond the stated limits, and ages below thirteen billion years clash with the data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Elena Tomasetti ,, Cristina Chiappini, Samir Nepal, Michele Moresco, Carmela Lardo, Andrea Cimatti, Friedrich Anders, Anna B. A. Queiroz, Guilherme Limberg |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02692
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The oldest Milky Way stars: New constraints on the age of the Universe and the Hubble constant Elena Tomasetti ,, Cristina Chiappini, Samir Nepal, Michele Moresco, Carmela Lardo, Andrea Cimatti, Friedrich Anders, Anna B. A. Queiroz, Guilherme Limberg Abstract Aims. In this work, we exploit the most robust, old, and cosmology–independent age estimates of individual stars from Gaia DR3 to place a lower bound on the age of the Universe, t U t_{U} . These constraints can be used as an anchor point for any cosmological model, providing an upper limit to the Hubble constant H 0 H_{0} . Methods. We consider the stellar age catalog of Nepal et al. 2024 , selecting 3,000 of the oldest and most robustly measured main sequence turn-off (MSTO) and subgiant branch (SGB) stars, with ages older than 12.5 Gyr and associated uncertainty below 1 Gyr. Stellar ages are derived via isochrone fitting using the Bayesian code StarHorse , spanning the uniform range 0 – 20 Gyr, not considering any cosmological prior knowledge on t U t_{U} . Applying a conservative cut in the Kiel diagram, strict quality cuts on both stellar parameters and posterior probability distribution shapes, and filtering out potential contaminants, we isolate a final sample of 160 bona-fide stars, representing the most numerous sample of precise and reliable MSTO and SGB stars ages available to date. Results. The age distribution of the final sample peaks at 13.6 ± 1.0 (stat) ± 1.3 (syst) 13.6\pm 1.0\,\text{(stat)}\pm 1.3\,\text{(syst)} Gyr. Assuming a maximum formation redshift for these stars of z f = 20 z_{f}=20 , corresponding to a formation delay of ∼ \sim 0.2 Gyr, we obtain a lower bound on t U t_{U} of t U ≥ 13.8 ± 1.0 (stat) ± 1.3 (syst) \mathrm{t_{U}\geq 13.8\pm 1.0\,\text{(stat)}\pm 1.3\,\text{(syst)}} Gyr. Considering the 10 t h 10^{th} percentile of the posterior probability distributions of the individual stars, we find that, at 90% CL, 70 stars favour t U > 13 t_{U}>13 Gyr, while none exceeds 14.1 Gyr. An oldest age younger than 13 Gyr for this sample is incompatible with the data, even considering the full systematic error budget. Conclusions. This work presents the first statistically significant use of individual stellar ages as cosmic clocks, opening a new, independent approach for cosmological studies. While this analysis represents already a significant step forward, future Gaia data releases will enable even larger and more precise stellar samples, further strengthening these constraints. 1 Introduction Figure 1 : Age distribution (left), Kiel diagram (center), and age-metallicity coverage (right) for each step of the selection process, before visual inspection. In the central panel, PARSEC isochrones at different ages and metallicities are shown in grey, and at the bottom left, the average error in \mathit{log(g)} and \mathit{T_{eff}} for the full sample is shown. The peak at 19 Gyr visible in the histogram is due to contaminants, as explained in Sect. 3.1 and Appendix A.1 . Although the \Lambda CDM model is widely successful in modern cosmology in describing several observables, recent high-precision measurements from key probes have highlighted discrepancies between early- and late-Universe constraints. One of the critical parameters is the local expansion rate of the Universe (the Hubble constant, H_{0} ) that shows a tension of 4-5 \sigma when measured from different probes ( Abdalla et al. 2022 ; Kamionkowski & Riess 2023 , Cepheids and SNe as opposed to CMB, see, e.g.,) ; this could hint to new physics or hidden systematics in the data, emphasising the need for complementary methods to trace the Universe’s expansion history and uncover the source of this tension. The absolute ages of the oldest objects at z=0 are critical in cosmology, as they can set a lower bound on the current age of the Universe ( Krauss & Chaboyer 2003 , t_{U} ,) . Assuming a cosmological model, this lower limit on t_{U} can be translated into an upper limit on the Hubble constant ( H_{0} ). In particular, considering the two primary independent measurements that originated the ”Hubble tension”, H_{0} = 67.4 \pm 0.5 km/s/Mpc ( Planck Collaboration et al. 2020 ) and H_{0} = 73.04 \pm 1.04 km/s/Mpc ( Riess et al. 2022 ) , these correspond (in a flat \Lambda CDM model with \Omega_{m} = 0.3) to \mathit{t_{U}} =14.0\pm 0.1 Gyr and t_{U} =12.9\pm 0.2 Gyr, respectively. Therefore, measuring t_{U} with an accuracy of about 10% can provide independent and crucial insights into this subject. In recent years, interest has been growing in the use of stellar ages as promising cosmological probes ( O’Malley et al. 2017 ; Jimenez et al. 2019 ; Valcin et al. 2020 ; Valcin et al. 2021 ; Di Valentino et al. 2021 ; Boylan-Kolchin & Weisz 2021 ; Moresco et al. 2022 ; Vagnozzi et al. 2022 ; Tomasetti et al. 2025 ; Valcin et al. 2025 ) , independent of the standard ones and of any cosmological model. Various methods and types of objects have been employed for this purpose, most notably isochrone fitting, applied to globular clusters (GCs) and individual stars ( Valcin et al. 2025 , e.g.) , as well as full-spectrum fitting for GCs ( Tomasetti et al. 2025 ) and techniques based on white dwarf cooling sequences and nucleochronometry (see Cimatti & Moresco 2023 , for a collection of different approaches) . Thanks to the tremendous increase in the quality and statistics of the data for field stars in the Gaia era, very high precision is currently achievable in measuring age. Accuracy, on the other hand, represents a persistent challenge due to the presence of systematic uncertainties ( Soderblom 2010 ; Valcin et al. 2021 ; Joyce et al. 2023 ) , mainly arising from stellar models’ dependencies, typically dominating over the internal precision of each method. Moreover, the previously mentioned studies generally relied on small samples (a few tens of old GCs or a handful of single stars) as precise age estimates were available for a few objects, limiting the statistical robustness of the resulting cosmological inferences. Nowadays, precise age determinations can be obtained for main-sequence turnoff (MSTO) and subgiant branch (SGB) stars, via isochrone fitting, thanks to the very high-quality data and stellar parameters obtained with cutting-edge facilities like the ESA Gaia ( Gaia Collaboration et al. 2016 ) . In this paper, we take advantage of the high-quality age measurements obtained in Nepal et al. 2024 for a sample of about 200’000 MSTO and SGB stars, with extremely precise parallaxes ( < 1%) and extinction uncertainties ( < 0.2 mag). Extending the methodology adopted in 31 , where stellar ages were constrained by a cosmological prior of 13.73 Gyr, the ages adopted here were derived without any such upper bound, spanning the full range of the isochrone models (0.025–20 Gyr). This unprecedented dataset enables us to use stellar age dating as a cosmological probe, for the first time, with both high statistical power and internal homogeneity, while also enabling a detailed assessment of the systematic uncertainties affecting age measurements. In Sect. 2 we present the dataset and the method used to derive ages, in Sect. 3 the selection of the optimal age sample, together with the analysis of the systematic effects.