Quantum Vacuum energy as the origin of Gravity
André LeClair · 2025
Read Quantum Vacuum energy as the origin of Gravity by André LeClair (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02636.txt.
Introduction
André LeClair wrote a 2025 solo theoretical physics paper proposing that quantum vacuum energy is the origin of gravity. The argument builds a gravitational analogue of the Casimir effect, where vacuum fluctuations create measurable forces between plates.
From that starting point, Einstein's equations are shown to emerge in their Friedmann form, the equations governing cosmic expansion. Newton's constant then becomes environmental, set by the total mass-energy and size of the universe rather than fixed forever. That view reframes the entropy formulas for de Sitter space and black holes. Using a proposed vacuum energy formula tied to the lightest particle's mass, gravity weakens at high energies and the usual big bang singularity is avoided. The author also links the model to the Hubble tension debate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | André LeClair |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02636
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum Vacuum energy as the origin of Gravity André LeClair Abstract We explore the idea that quantum vacuum energy ρ vac {\rho_{\rm vac}} as computed in flat Minkowski space is at the origin of Gravity as a theoretical exercise. We formulate a gravitational version of the electromagnetic Casimir effect, and provide an argument for how gravity can arise from ρ vac {\rho_{\rm vac}} by showing how Einstein’s field equations emerge in the form of Friedmann’s equations. This leads to the idea that Newton’s constant G N G_{N} is environmental, namely it depends on the total mass-energy of the Universe M ∞ {{\rm M}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} and its size R ∞ {{\rm R}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} , with G N = c 2 R ∞ / 2 M ∞ G_{N}=c^{2}{{\rm R}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}/2{{\rm M}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} . This leads to a new interpretation of the Gibbons-Hawking entropy of de Sitter space, and also the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy for black holes, wherein the quantum information “bits” are simply quantized massless particles at the horizon with wavelength λ = 2 π R ∞ \lambda=2\pi{{\rm R}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} . We assume a recently proposed and well-motivated formula for ρ vac ∼ m z 4 / 𝔤 {\rho_{\rm vac}}\sim m_{\rm z}^{4}/\mathfrak{g} , where m z m_{\rm z} is the mass of the lightest particle, and 𝔤 \mathfrak{g} is a marginally irrelevant coupling. This leads to an effective, induced RG flow for Newton’s constant G N G_{N} as a function of an energy scale, which indicates that G N G_{N} decreases at higher energies until it reaches a Landau pole at a minimal value of the cosmological scale factor a ( t ) > a min a(t)>a_{\rm min} , thus avoiding the usual geometric singularity at a = 0 a=0 . The solution to the scale factor satisfies an interesting symmetry between the far past and far future due to a ( t ) = a ( − t + 2 t min ) a(t)=a(-t+2t_{\rm min}) , where a ( t min ) = a min a(t_{\rm min})=a_{\rm min} . We propose that this energy scale dependent G N G_{N} can explain the Hubble tension and we thereby constrain the coupling constant 𝔤 \mathfrak{g} and its renormalization group parameters. For the Λ CDM \Lambda{\rm CDM} model we estimate a min ≈ e − 1 / b ^ a_{\rm min}\approx e^{-1/\widehat{b}} where b ^ ≈ 0.02 \widehat{b}\approx 0.02 based on the Hubble tension data. I Introduction Gravity remains the least understood of the fundamental forces, in spite of the discoveries of General Relativity (GR) and Quantum Mechanics (QM) over 100 years ago, this year being recognized as the 100-th anniversary of a complete theory of QM due to Schrödinger and Heisenberg, although the birth of QM goes back to Planck’s black body studies at finite temperature. Classical singularities at the center of black holes and at the time of the Big Bang have not yet been understood and resolved in classical GR. Many physicists expect that such singularities will be resolved by a theory of quantum gravity, but it’s fair to say that a complete theory of quantum gravity has not been forthcoming, although string theory offers some promise. For these reasons it is worthwhile to pursue new ideas on the origin or emergence of Gravity itself, especially if such ideas suggest that perhaps Gravity doesn’t need to be quantized in the first place. Such a theory should be able to explain the value of Newton’s constant G_{N} itself. In this article we explore the question ‘‘Can Quantum vacuum energy be the origin of Gravity?” 1 1 1 This article was initially intended simply as a theoretical exercise in the form of an essay to address this question, but we found it can lead to a fruitful new perspective on Gravity more generally, and it is not without some predictions, if the basic ideas continue to hold. This perspective is based on the idea that perhaps we can learn more about the foundations of Gravity by considering the cosmological far future, in contrast to the far past where much less is understood, in particular the origin of the Big Bang and possibly inflation. The late Universe is dominated by so-called Dark Energy, thus one should first attempt to understand the full implications of this in a Universe where Dark Energy is its sole component. By assumption, we will equate Dark Energy with the quantum vacuum energy density {\rho_{\rm vac}} computed in quantum field theory (QFT) in flat local Minkowski space, defined as \langle 0|T_{\mu\nu}|0\rangle={\rho_{\rm vac}}\,\eta_{\mu\nu} (1) with the convention \{\eta_{\mu\nu}\}={\rm diag}\{1,-1,-1,-1\} where the Vacuum |0\rangle is the ground state for all quantized fields, excluding gravity. The gravitational implications of the quantum field theoretic properties of {\rho_{\rm vac}} will be then explored. The first observations of Gravity were of course at the surface of the Earth which is manifested as a constant acceleration g for all matter regardless of mass or specific material. Newton later understood g to be “environmental” rather than fundamental, namely g=G_{N}M_{E}/R_{E}^{2} , where M_{E},R_{E} are the mass and radius of the Earth. In Newton’s universal theory of Gravity, G_{N} is considered a new fundamental constant of Nature, and this view was adopted by Einstein in his formulation of General Relativity. 2 2 2 Throughout this paper, G_{N}=6.67\cdot 10^{-11}{\rm m^{3}}/{\rm kg\,s^{2}} is Newton’s constant as measured today. We keep the fundamental constants \hbar and c explicit in order to make certain conceptual points and to provide some numbers with units. “Natural” units based on the Planck length \ell_{p} can be deceptive and are not so natural for this article. In contrast, below we will argue that G_{N} is also environmental, namely G_{N}=\dfrac{c^{4}}{2}\dfrac{{{\rm R}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}}{{{\rm E}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}}=\dfrac{c^{2}}{2}\dfrac{{{\rm R}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}}{{{\rm M}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}} (2) where {{\rm E}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}={{\rm M}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}c^{2} is the total energy in the Vacuum for the entire Universe and {{\rm R}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} is a measure of its size. These quantities will be defined more precisely below. 3 3 3 The subscripts ∞ refer to the far future. All of the QM involved is incorporated into {\rho_{\rm vac}} and thus {{\rm M}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} , since {{\rm M}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}}c^{2}={\rho_{\rm vac}}\,\tfrac{4}{3}\pi{{\rm R}^{3}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} , and {{\rm R}_{\scriptscriptstyle\infty}} could be viewed as a kind of infra-red cutoff. Based on the above remarks, what will be central to our exercise is the quantity {\rho_{\rm vac}} . For purposes of illustration, consider a Universe which only consists of a single harmonic oscillator with ground state energy E_{0}=\hbar\omega/2 , in addition to an imagined observer. Since classical mechanics in unaffected by shifts of the potential energy by an arbitrary constant, E_{0} is not measurable in classical physics. If all that exists is the harmonic oscillator in empty space, then E_{0} also cannot be measured in a single experiment based on QM. There are two known ways to measure E_{0} . First, one can couple the harmonic oscillator to a generic heat bath at temperature T . Then one can in principle infer E_{0} from the high temperature behavior of the partition function or its logarithm which is the free energy. It’s important that this is based on the free energy and not its derivatives, and thus it is not invariant under shifts of the potential energy. The second manner to measure E_{0} is to