Who Owns The Robot?: Four Ethical and Socio-technical Questions about Wellbeing Robots in the Real World through Community Engagement

Minja Axelsson, Jiaee Cheong, Rune Nyrup, Hatice Gunes · 2025

Read Who Owns The Robot?: Four Ethical and Socio-technical Questions about Wellbeing Robots in the Real World through Community Engagement by Minja Axelsson, Jiaee Cheong, Rune Nyrup, Hatice Gunes (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02624.txt.

Introduction

Minja Axelsson and three co-authors wrote a 2025 paper on wellbeing robots. These are machines meant to coach healthier habits. Real-world use raises ethical and social questions. Lab studies often skip those questions.

The team ran workshops with three groups. Such groups are usually left out of robot design. They were science festival visitors, women computer scientists, and humanities researchers. A co-design canvas structured the ethical debate. Thematic analysis then grouped the results. Four questions emerged. Is the robot safe, and how could anyone tell? Who is it built for, and with whom? Who owns the robot and its data? And why a robot at all? The authors offer those questions as a working framework.

Catalog record

CREATORMinja Axelsson, Jiaee Cheong, Rune Nyrup, Hatice Gunes
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02624

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Who Owns The Robot?: Four Ethical and Socio-technical Questions about Wellbeing Robots in the Real World through Community Engagement Minja Axelsson, Jiaee Cheong, Rune Nyrup, Hatice Gunes Abstract Recent studies indicated that robotic coaches can play a crucial role in promoting wellbeing. However, the real-world deployment of wellbeing robots raises numerous ethical and socio-technical questions and concerns. To explore these questions, we undertake a community-centered investigation to examine three different communities’ perspectives on the ethical questions related to using robotic wellbeing coaches in real-world environments. We frame our work as an anticipatory ethical investigation, which we undertake to better inform the development of robotic technologies with communities’ opinions, with the ultimate goal of aligning robot development with public interest. In our study, we conducted interviews and workshops with three communities who are under-represented in robotics development: 1) members of the public at a science festival, 2) women computer scientists at a conference, and 3) humanities researchers interested in history and philosophy of science. In the workshops, we collected qualitative data by using the Social Robot Co-Design Canvas on Ethics, which participants filled in individually. We used this tool as it is designed to investigate ethical issues of robots with multiple stakeholders. We analysed the collected qualitative data with Thematic Analysis, informed by notes we took during the workshops. Through our analysis, we identify four themes regarding key ethical and socio-technical questions about the real-world use of wellbeing robots. We group participants’ insights and discussions around these broad thematic questions, discuss them in light of state-of-the-art literature, and highlight areas for future investigation. Finally, we provide the four questions as a broad framework that roboticists can and should use during robotic development and deployment, in order to reflect on the ethics and socio-technical dimensions of their robotic applications, and to engage in dialogue with communities of robot users. The four questions are: 1) Is the robot safe and how can we know that?, 2) Who is the robot built for and with?, 3) Who owns the robot and the data?, and 4) Why a robot?. Keywords: Robot Ethics, AI Ethics, Human-Robot Interaction, Community-centred Research, Wellbeing, Socio-technical Research, Robot Design, Socially Assistive Robotics 1 Introduction Robotic wellbeing coaches have been recently investigated as means to maintain and improve participants’ wellbeing through various wellbeing practices ( Spitale and Gunes 2022 ), such as positive psychology ( Spitale et al. 2023a ; Jeong et al. 2020 ; Jeong et al. 2023 ; Axelsson et al. 2025 ) and mindfulness ( Bodala et al. 2020 ; Axelsson et al. 2023 ; Matheus et al. 2025 ). Robots for wellbeing are typically socially interactive, embodied, and apply types of Artificial Intelligence (AI) to engage in interactions with users ( Mahdi et al. 2022 ). Such robots form part of and are themselves complex socio-technical systems, i.e., systems in which technology and society interact ( Whitworth and Ahmad 2014 ). Researchers’ reasoning behind creating such wellbeing robots and using them in the real-world is creating accessible, low-barrier mental wellbeing support ( Scoglio et al. 2019 ; Axelsson et al. 2021a ). However, as robotic technologies are currently rarely used outside of the lab, research on the ethical implications of their real-world use is limited. In concurrence, there has been a proliferation of research focusing on human-centred ethical AI ( van Berkel et al. 2022 ; Loi et al. 2019 ; Capel and Brereton 2023 ). Existing works have relied on the definition of ethical AI as “AI that seeks accountability regarding fundamental human values and rights, and advocates for more transparent design of AI” ( Capel and Brereton 2023 ). This includes work in the robotics field, in which various human-centred design processes have engaged prospective users and other stakeholders in examining the ethics of robotic applications ( Axelsson et al. 2022 ; Ostrowski et al. 2022 ; Ostrowski 2023 ). However, to date, there is still a lack of research conducted on what and how robots and the related real-world ethical considerations are thought of by under-represented communities. Particularly, members of the public, women computer scientists, and researchers from the humanities who have had limited involvement in the ethical evaluation of robotic technologies. This is due to various structural barriers and biases ( Züger and Asghari 2023 ; Hall and Ellis 2023 ; Chun and Elkins 2023 ), in computer science, AI and robotics in particular. To further understand these communities’ perspectives and to improve inclusivity in the evaluation of ethics, this work presents three community-based workshops, where participants (n=22) reflected on the ethical issues related to robotic wellbeing coaching. In the workshops, participants were introduced to robotic wellbeing coaches (either through a live demo or video recordings), and used the Social Robot Co-Design Ethics canvas ( Axelsson et al. 2021b ) to reflect on ethical issues, filling their own canvases and also engaging in discussions related to the topic with the researcher(s) and each other. This work presents participants’ reflections as detailed on the canvases, groups these discussions into four broad ethical and socio-technical questions generated through Thematic Analysis, discusses these thematic questions’ relationship to existing literature, and identifies future research directions. Finally, the questions are presented as a tool for roboticists to interrogate and discuss the ethics of robotic applications during robot design and deployment, in conversation with robot users. 2 Background and Related Work Prospective users have highlighted advantages of using robots for wellbeing, such as lack of judgement and accessibility in comparison to human coaches ( Axelsson et al. 2021a ; Axelsson et al. 2022 ), and professional coaches have highlighted advantages such as reliability, consistency and uniformity in comparison with human coaches ( Axelsson et al. 2022 ). In comparison with non-embodied AI (i.e., mobile apps and computer interfaces), prospective users have highlighted the physical presence of a robot as an advantage. This advantage is supported by Sayis and Gunes 2024 , who found that in comparison with a voice assistant (i.e., a smart speaker), a wellbeing robot elicited more self-disclosure from participants during a wellbeing exercise, and generated positive changes in mood, whereas the voice assistant did not. While these investigations provide a rationale for the potential use of embodied robots to promote wellbeing as an alternative to existing solutions, the investigation of ethical dimensions of robotic wellbeing coaches are still limited. Axelsson et al. 2022 detailed design and ethical recommendations for robotic wellbeing coaches, based on qualitative results obtained from three user-centred studies. Spitale et al. 2024a further investigated the appropriateness of LLM-generated language for a robotic coach via a workshop held with study participants, identifying issues related to ethics and bias in LLMs. However, community engagement about ethical and societal questions if these robots were to be deployed is limited. Moreover, we find that an anticipatory approach towards robotic wellbeing coaching ethics is lacking within the field. Rather than reacting to harms after they occur, anticipatory ethics call for proactive reflection emphasising the identification of potential risks, power imbalances, and unintended consequences early in the design and development process ( Barnett and Diakopoulos 2022 ; Brey 2017 ). Within the scope of our work, this entails deliberating on the future implications ( Barnett and Diakopoulos 2022 ; Rakova

Read the complete text