Limit Analysis Approach for Optimal Reinforcement Design of Masonry Structures: the Weak Reinforcement Concept
Aguinaldo Fraddosio, Celeste Lasorella, Mario Daniele Piccioni, Elio Sacco · 2025
Read Limit Analysis Approach for Optimal Reinforcement Design of Masonry Structures: the Weak Reinforcement Concept by Aguinaldo Fraddosio, Celeste Lasorella, Mario Daniele Piccioni, Elio Sacco (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02559.txt.
Introduction
Aguinaldo Fraddosio and three co-authors wrote a 2025 paper on reinforcing old masonry. The work aims to keep historic walls safe without changing how they act. Strong modern fixes can fight the old structure. They can also harm heritage value.
Their weak reinforcement concept comes from limit analysis. That method estimates collapse loads. A new computational framework measures how tensile reinforcements raise capacity. Cracks can still open, as they did before. Rocking motion and settlement adaptation stay possible. Forces passed to supporting parts stay limited. Example designs cover a trilithon facing seismic loads and an arch under a point load. Settlement behaviour is checked by minimising total potential energy. The strategy pairs safety with conservation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aguinaldo Fraddosio, Celeste Lasorella, Mario Daniele Piccioni, Elio Sacco |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02559
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Limit Analysis Approach for Optimal Reinforcement Design of Masonry Structures: the Weak Reinforcement Concept Aguinaldo Fraddosio, Celeste Lasorella, Mario Daniele Piccioni, Elio Sacco Abstract In this paper, first the non-standard limit analysis 2D problem for reinforced masonry structures is suitably reformulated, giving a innovative computational framework for the evaluation of the strengthening effects of tensile reinforcements. This framework is used for designing optimized reinforcements for masonry structures aimed at improving the structural capacity, but without substantial changes in the typical behavior of masonry structural systems, since the reinforcement layout leaves the possibility of cracks opening. Therefore, both rocking motions and adaptation to support settlements remain allowed, and the transmission of too high forces to the unreinforced structural elements supporting the reinforced one is prevented. This way, a new strengthening strategy, called "weak reinforcement" approach is obtained. This strategy pursues the challenging goal of combining structural safety and conservation for architectural heritage: indeed, not only the historical masonry is preserved as much as possible, but also the original special "masonry-like" behavior. The design, in principle, of optimized strengthening intervention through the weak reinforcement approach is exemplified through the application to a trilithon under seismic loads and to an arch under a concentrated load. The capacity of the structure to adapt to support settlements is investigated through a suitable procedure for minimizing the total potential energy of the system. 1 Introduction Masonry structures represent the architectural heritage of numerous countries and encapsulate centuries of historical, cultural, and technical knowledge. From ancient aqueducts and Romanesque churches to Renaissance palaces and early industrial buildings, masonry has served as the main construction material due to its widespread availability, durability, and high compressive strength. However, the structural behavior of masonry is inherently governed by its low tensile strength and brittle nature, which requires special consideration in both structural analysis and design Drysdale1999 , Hendry2004 , Como2016 . Masonry structures have been conceived (or must be designed) to carry external loads — typically gravity loads — primarily through compressive stresses Heyman1997 ; this is made possible by the geometric configuration of the structure. As such, these structures can be vulnerable to foundation settlements Portioli2016 , Tralli2020 , Iannuzzo2025 , long-term deformations Ferretti2006 , Cecchi2012 , Sánchez-Beitia2017 , and seismic actions Tomazevic1999 , Asteris2014 , Lagomarsino2021 . The history test has shown that masonry structures can also exhibit a surprising capacity against the latter load conditions, unjustifiable through conventional structural analysis techniques, due to the ability to adapt through crack opening and activation of rocking behavior. However, beyond certain load intensities, this adaptation capacity may be insufficient and consequently collapse may occur. Since preserving masonry structures is of paramount importance, often strengthening interventions are unavoidable to ensure a suitable capacity to withstand both static and dynamic expected external loads. Anyway, the more recent guidelines on structural restoration of architectural heritage ICOMOS2024 not only insist on the principle of minimum intervention, but also highlight that one of the goal of the conservation is that of preserving the technical values of the construction, relative to the structural concepts, the construction techniques and the materials. Moreover, it is clearly stated that the strict application of seismic codes can lead to drastic and often unnecessary measures, and that in the strengthening of historical structures, it may be acceptable not to fully enforce the structural requirements conventionally prescribed by standards oriented to modern structures (concept of the structural improvement, opposed to the concept of structural retrofitting). These criteria have to be carefully respected for avoiding irreversible damage of the architectural heritage. A broad spectrum of reinforcement techniques has been employed, ranging from time-tested traditional methods to more advanced and recent solutions. Conventional interventions, such as the use of steel ties, buttresses, and jack arches, remain the preferred choice, whether they are resolving, due to their compatibility with historical construction practices. Moreover, from the structural point of view, traditional strengthening methods respect the original structural behavior. In contrast, recent solutions are generally united by the concept that reinforcement is obtained by introducing tensile strength in the structures, since the low tensile strength is viewed as a weakness, rather than a peculiar feature, capable of revealing unexpected structural advantages if studied through suitable structural analysis approaches. In fact, the modern history of masonry strengthening interventions began with the addition of steel and/or reinforced concrete elements. More recently, advancements in materials science have led to the employ of externally bonded fiber-reinforced polymers (FRPs) and fiber-reinforced cementitious matrix (FRCM) composites, which offer high strength-to-weight ratios, improved durability, and ease of application; strengthening effects, bond properties and adhesion issues have been studied through theorical and experimental investigations Grande2008 , Cancelliere2010 , Carozzi2018 , Alecci2016 , Leone2017 , Meriggi2022 , Castellano2025 . Despite the advantages recalled, the use of modern reinforcement techniques might have several drawbacks. Indeed, while locally effective, these interventions can introduce unintended consequences for the global structural behavior of the system. Specifically, they can create zones of excessive stiffness, thereby disrupting the continuity and integrity of the original structural response. In fact, reinforcement elements can introduce discontinuities in stiffness, which may hinder the development of natural deformation patterns or generate localized stress peaks. This issue is particularly critical in historic buildings, where preserving original load paths and failure mechanisms is often as essential as improving structural strength. Although reinforcements may delay or mitigate certain failure modes, they can also instigate more brittle or less favorable mechanisms. Moreover, substantial changes introduced in the overall structural behavior could obliterate the so important masonry capacity to adapt to settlements and to withstand seismic actions through rocking motions, at the end resulting in a reduction of the structural capacity and/or in unexpected damages due to unfavorable stress redistribution Cimellaro2011 , Arcidiacono2016 , Borri2019 . These drawbacks are substantially due to the fact that in the in the strengthened parts of the structure the reinforcements totally prevent blocks articulations, inducing a continuum body-like behavior, and that the counterpart of the increase of the structural capacity of the strengthened parts is the transmission of much higher forces to the unstrenghtened parts, like, e.g., it can happen when a strengthened masonry domes is connected to unstrenghtened pillars or support walls. To address the above-described complexities introduced by the reinforcements in structural behavior, computational modeling has become an indispensable tool Grande2011 , Grande2023 , Castellano2023 . Anyway, describing masonry non-linear behavior is already quite complex, and the addition of reinforcements requires the description of non-linear interactions between masonry and reinforcements, and this is even more complex. Moreover, the structural models needed require the characterization of a large number of mechanical parameters that is generally experimentally challenging, if not infeasible. This makes very difficult, and substantially out of reach of professionals the application of proper analysis techniques for describing the structural behavior of reinforced masonry and for designing effective reinforcement interventions. On the other hand, limit analysis has proven especially effective in assessing the ultimate load-bearing capacity and identifying potential failure mechanisms in unreinforced masonry structures. This approach does not require a detailed stress–strain characterization of the materials involved, but instead focuses on the limit state, making it particularly well-suited to systems with unilateral frictional contact, such as dry-joint or weakly bonded masonry. Block2006 ,