Bayesian Polarization I thank Ian Ball, Roberto Corrao, Michael Crystal, Bnaya Dreyfuss, Drew Fudenberg, Nima Haghpanah, Stephen Morris, Anat Petruschka, Ariel Rubinstein, Ran Spiegler, and Alexander Wolitzky for helpful comments and conversations.

Tuval Danenberg · 2025

Read Bayesian Polarization I thank Ian Ball, Roberto Corrao, Michael Crystal, Bnaya Dreyfuss, Drew Fudenberg, Nima Haghpanah, Stephen Morris, Anat Petruschka, Ariel Rubinstein, Ran Spiegler, and Alexander Wolitzky for helpful comments and conversations. by Tuval Danenberg (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02513.txt.

Introduction

Tuval Danenberg wrote a 2025 solo political science theory paper on how polarisation and issue alignment can grow together under rational learning. Polarisation means views split toward opposite extremes; alignment means one person's views across issues become more consistent with each other.

The model uses Bayesian agents, ideal learners who update beliefs from public signals by the rules of probability. Danenberg characterises which public signals can keep agents polarised on every issue dimension at once. Evidence of alignment itself can push Bayesian agents apart. However, stronger forms of polarisation, beyond marginal beliefs, clash with Bayesian rationality. Whether belief splits become position splits also depends on whether issues can be separated from each other in agents' thinking.

Catalog record

CREATORTuval Danenberg
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02513

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bayesian Polarization I thank Ian Ball, Roberto Corrao, Michael Crystal, Bnaya Dreyfuss, Drew Fudenberg, Nima Haghpanah, Stephen Morris, Anat Petruschka, Ariel Rubinstein, Ran Spiegler, and Alexander Wolitzky for helpful comments and conversations. Tuval Danenberg Abstract We study belief polarization among Bayesian agents observing public information about a multidimensional state. Baliga et al. 2013a show that divergence in the sense of first-order stochastic dominance is impossible for one dimensional beliefs, but we find that in multidimensional settings it can occur for all marginal beliefs, even with infinitely many signals. At the same time, we extend their impossibility result: divergence in the sense of multidimensional stochastic dominance is impossible. For an intermediate stochastic order, polarization may arise only in the short-run. We provide necessary and sufficient conditions on signal structures for persistent polarization and discuss implications for polarization in actions. 1 Introduction Polarization is a buzzword in current political discourse. Merriam-Webster named it its 2024 Word of the Year, noting that it is “one idea that both sides of the political spectrum agree on.” 1 1 1 See Merriam-Webster “2024 Word of the Year: Polarization,” accessed June 26, 2025: merriam-webster.com/wordplay/word-of-the-year . DiMaggio et al. 1996a clarify that polarization can be defined both as a state —one in which society’s views are concentrated at opposite extremes, or as a process —i.e., the movement towards such a state. Furthermore, polarization can pertain to attitudes, beliefs, preferences etc. This paper focuses on beliefs and on polarization as a process. Specifically, we will use the following notion, based on the definition in Dixit & Weibull 2007a (henceforth DW). Polarization occurs if the beliefs of two agents move further apart and in opposite directions after they observe the same information. At first glance, this type of polarization appears at odds with rational Bayesian models. A common feature of such models is the prediction that when agents observe the same information their beliefs move closer together. Therefore, widespread polarization seemingly offers evidence of irrationality on at least one side. This intuition is formalized by several theoretical results, notably the impossibility theorem of Baliga et al. 2013a (henceforth BHK). Considering two Bayesian agents with different priors, they show that observing a common public signal cannot cause beliefs to diverge in the sense of first-order stochastic dominance. 2 2 2 Meaning that if agent H ’s prior stochastically dominates agent L ’s prior, it cannot be the case that H ’s posterior dominates H ’s prior while L ’s posterior is dominated by L ’s prior. Interpreting polarization as irrational has deep implications. It fits the broader view that we are living in a post-truth era, marked by erosion of shared facts and a narrowing scope for constructive public discourse ( McIntyre 2018a ; Kavanagh & Rich 2018a ) . In BHK, agents’ beliefs are defined over a one-dimensional state space. In practice, political beliefs are multidimensional, spanning foreign policy, the economy, cultural issues, and more. The first contribution of this paper is to show that once beliefs are multidimensional, a strong and practically relevant form of Bayesian polarization becomes possible: agents’ marginal beliefs can diverge simultaneously in the sense of stochastic dominance on each dimension. In other words, the type of divergence that Baliga et al. 2013a rule out in one dimension may arise coordinatewise across all dimensions. The analysis also clarifies the limits of Bayesian polarization. Two distinctions matter: whether polarization is measured after a single signal realization ( one-shot ) or after an infinite sequence of i.i.d. realizations ( limit ); and which stochastic order is used to compare beliefs. The coordinatewise order described above requires stochastic dominance on each marginal dimension separately, and here both one-shot and limit polarization are possible. The paper’s second contribution is to establish the restrictions that Bayesian updating places on polarization, by showing impossibility results for stronger notions of divergence. The multidimensional stochastic dominance order is the standard generalization of one-dimensional stochastic dominance to higher dimensions. Under this order, both one-shot and limit polarization are impossible---an extension of BHK’s impossibility result to any number of dimensions. The upper-orthant order requires divergence on events involving multiple dimensions being simultaneously high (or low). It is stronger than the coordinatewise order but weaker than multidimensional stochastic dominance. 3 3 3 Both the multidimensional stochastic order and the upper-orthant order have been suggested as generalizations of univariate stochastic dominance ( Shaked & Shanthikumar 2007a ) . The former preserves the property that one distribution dominates another if and only if it dominates it in expectation for every increasing function. The latter is weaker, and preserves the property that one distribution dominates the other if and only if its distribution function dominates the other’s at every point. Under this intermediate criterion, one-shot polarization is possible but limit polarization is not. Table 1 summarizes. Taken together, the results show that while there are forces pushing Bayesian agents towards agreement, these still allow for significant polarization in the face of common information. We demonstrate this idea from a different angle by considering polarization in beliefs on individual states. In any finite state space, there are always two states—the minimum- and maximum-likelihood states—on which both agents’ beliefs must move in the same direction. On all other states, however, their beliefs may move in opposite directions. Mathematically, the BHK impossibility result generalizes, but substantively it is the coordinatewise order—not multidimensional stochastic dominance—that best reflects how polarization is measured in practice. Survey evidence often tracks divergence across separate issue dimensions such as climate change, trade, or cultural issues (see, e.g., Newport 2023a ). The possibility result shows that this form of polarization is fully consistent with Bayesian updating, even in the long run. By contrast, the stronger orders capture divergence on combinations of issues, e.g., whether the state is simultaneously high on both economic and cultural dimensions. The impossibility results imply that agreement may persist on such joint events, even when marginals diverge. Evidence of polarization on such issue combinations would be harder to reconcile with rational updating. Table 1 : Possibility of Polarization Stochastic Order One‐shot Polarization Limit Polarization Coordinatewise \checkmark \checkmark Upper Orthant \checkmark X Stochastic Dominance X X The third contribution is a complete characterization of the signals that can lead to limit coordinatewise polarization in two-dimensional state spaces. An immediate necessary condition is partial identification : there must be at least one additional state that is observationally equivalent to the true state of the world. Otherwise, beliefs converge to the truth, precluding polarization. 4 4 4 Formally, if the signal is X , the state space is \Theta , and the true state is \hat{\theta} , then there must be at least one state \theta\in\Theta\setminus\{\hat{\theta}\} such that for every realization x : \Pr[X=x|\theta]=\Pr[X=x|\hat{\theta}] . Otherwise, Doob’s Consistency Theorem ( Doob 1949a ) implies that, from any full-support prior, beliefs converge to a point mass on \hat{\theta} . Fixing the true state, any polarizing signal must therefore induce a set of states observationally equivalent to it, which we call the identified set . The problem of identifying polarizing signals thus reduces to characterizing the identified sets that permit polarization. Under a mild technical condition, Theorem 5 shows that an identified set can lead to polarization if and only

Read the complete text