IS THE EPR PARADOX REALLY A PARADOX?
Natalia Gorobey, Alexander Lukyanenko · 2025
Read IS THE EPR PARADOX REALLY A PARADOX? by Natalia Gorobey, Alexander Lukyanenko (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02085.txt.
Introduction
Natalia Gorobey and Alexander Lukyanenko revisit whether the EPR paradox is truly a paradox within quantized field theory. The classic puzzle involves two photons in a singlet state measured at separate detectors. If exciting a field system with set quantum numbers is impossible, the source trigger amplitude vanishes. They analyze the source plus two detector system in full detail.
Operation of one detector with a given photon polarization fixes the adequate choice for the second detector. That determination follows from motion laws and conservation of excitation quantum numbers. No nonlocal influence is invoked in their account. The conclusion reframes the correlation as a selection effect inside one global field system. Their stance adds to long running debates on quantum foundations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Natalia Gorobey, Alexander Lukyanenko |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02085
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
IS THE EPR PARADOX REALLY A PARADOX? Natalia Gorobey, Alexander Lukyanenko Abstract An analysis of the EPR paradox is proposed within the framework of the laws of the dynamics of excitations of quantized fields. These excitations are created and recorded in real time by sources and detectors (detector - source ”vice versa”). The source is defined as a region of space-time in which the excitation amplitude of quantized fields with a certain (acceptable!) set of quantum numbers is non-zero. I INTRODUCTION The thought experiment proposed by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen EPR was supposed to show the incompleteness of quantum mechanics, or more precisely, the incompleteness of the description of micro-phenomena using the wave function. The possibility of their more detailed description using hidden classical parameters is now excluded thanks to the theoretical work of Bell Bell and their experimental verification in the experiments of Aspect Asp . However, the incompleteness of quantum mechanics is revealed from another side – together with the realization of the need for secondary quantization BHJ and the construction of quantum field theory Dir . Now microparticles should be understood as excitations of quantized fields and, strictly speaking, in the description of microphenomena one should completely switch to the language of QFT. In relation to the EPR paradox, such a necessity is noted in the work of Prokhorov Prokh . Since the QFT formalism is intended to describe the dynamics of systems with a variable number of particles in terms of the amplitudes of the corresponding processes (elements of the S-matrix), it is necessary to formulate the statement of the problem with a set of particles “controlled” in a given experiment. Here we abandon the description of the state of the controlled set using a joint wave function, since it inevitably leads to the EPR paradox, which should be understood as an indication of the inadequacy of such a description. Instead, this paper introduces the concept of a source (sink) of particles that changes the excitation state of a quantized field ”controllably” in some region of space-time. This concept should not be confused with formal sources of quantized fields in the functional formalism of QFT Col . Also, our approach should not be confused with Schwinger’s source theory Schw , which attempts to abandon the quantized field as a fundamental concept. All we need is the birth in a controlled region of space-time of a certain admissible set of quantum numbers of particles and also its controlled detection. The formalism of the sources is also in agreement with the statement: “a photon is a registered photon” (see Bel ). In the next section, a source theory is proposed. In the second section, the concept of the wave function of excitation of quantized fields is introduced within the framework of source theory. In the third section, the source formalism within QFT is used to analyze the EPR experiment. II SOURCE IN QUANTUM FIELD THEORY Let us proceed immediately to the construction of the source formalism. For definiteness, as the initial field theory we shall consider ”scalar” electrodynamics with one complex scalar field of matter, described by the Lagrangian density \mathit{L}=-\frac{1}{4}F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}+\eta^{\mu\nu}\nabla_{\mu}\varphi^{\bullet}\nabla_{\nu}\varphi-V\left(\varphi\right), (1) where indicated: F_{\mu\nu}=\partial_{\mu}A_{\nu}-\partial_{\nu}A_{\mu},\nabla_{\mu}=\partial_{\mu}+ieA_{\mu}, (2) and \eta_{\mu\nu}=diag\left(+1,-1,-1-1\right). We need the electric current vector: j_{\mu}=ie\left(\nabla_{\mu}\varphi^{\bullet}\varphi-\varphi^{\bullet}\nabla_{\mu}\varphi\right). (3) We will also need the energy-momentum tensor of this theory, \displaystyle T^{\mu\nu} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-F^{\mu\alpha}\left.F_{\alpha}\right.^{\nu} (4) \displaystyle+\eta^{\mu\alpha}\eta^{\nu\beta}\left(\nabla_{\alpha}\varphi^{\bullet}\nabla_{\beta}\varphi+\nabla_{\beta}\varphi^{\bullet}\nabla_{\alpha}\varphi\right)-\eta^{\mu\nu}\mathit{L,} tensor of orbital angular momentum, M^{\mu,\alpha\beta}=x^{\alpha}T^{\mu\beta}-x^{\beta}T^{\mu\alpha}, (5) spin momentum, S^{\mu,\alpha\beta}=F^{\alpha\mu}A^{\beta}-F^{\beta\mu}A^{\alpha}, (6) and the total angular momentum of the system of fields: J^{\mu,\alpha\beta}=M^{\mu,\alpha\beta}+S^{\mu,\alpha\beta}. (7) All these quantities obey local conservation laws (continuity equations), which are consequences of the equations of motion of fields, and they determine the canonical generators of the corresponding symmetries, which are also the main observables of the theory. Thus, the electric charge in a certain region \Omega_{0} of space, Q=\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}xj^{0}, (8) serves as a canonical generator of the gradient transformation of fields in this region. We begin the definition of the source with the differential equation of the creation of a certain amount of charge in \Omega_{0} , \partial_{\mu}j^{\mu}=D, (9) where D is the spatial power density of the charge source ( [D]=C/m^{3}\cdot\sec ). In accordance with Eq.( 9 ), in the region \Omega_{0} we have: \frac{dQ}{dt}=\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}x\partial_{0}j^{0}=-\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}x\partial_{l}j^{l}+\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}xD. (10) If the source worked for a time \tau_{0} , and the generated charge left \Omega_{0} during this time, \Delta Q=0=-\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}x\partial_{l}j^{l}+\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\Omega}d^{3}xD. (11) Thus, the condition that in the region \Omega_{0} during time \tau_{0} a charge Q was born (and left this region) is written in the form: -\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\partial\Omega_{0}}d\sigma_{m}j^{m}+Q=0. (12) The conditions for certain quantities of energy and momentum to be generated in the region \Omega_{0} during time \tau_{0} is written down in a completely analogous way. These quantities are canonical generators of space-time translations. The corresponding condition has the form: -\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\partial\Omega_{0}}d\sigma_{m}T^{ma}+P^{a}=0. (13) Let us also consider in detail the birth of the angular momentum in the source. The total angular momentum contained at a given moment in the region \Omega_{0} is equal to: J_{i}=\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}xJ^{0,kl}\varepsilon_{kli}, (14) and the rate of change of the square of this vector, \frac{d}{dt}J^{2}=-2\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}xJ^{0,kl}\varepsilon_{kli}\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}y\partial_{0}J^{0,mn}\varepsilon_{mni}. (15) Therefore, the condition for the birth of the square of the angular momentum in the region \Omega_{0} during time \tau_{0} is written in the form: -2\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}xJ^{0,kl}\varepsilon_{kli}\int_{\partial\Omega_{0}}d\sigma_{p}J^{p,mn}\varepsilon_{mni}+J^{2}=0. (16) Finally, in connection with the discussion of the EPR experiment, a special role in this work will be played by the generation of a certain value of the projection of the angular momentum onto the selected direction \mathbf{a} . The corresponding additional condition has the form: -\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\partial\Omega_{0}}d\sigma_{p}\frac{1}{\left|\mathbf{a}\right|}a^{i}J^{p,kl}\varepsilon_{kli}+J_{a}=0. (17) In what follows we will consider only those classical observables that can be measured simultaneously in quantum theory. Their values (quantum numbers) form a complete set of observables in quantum theory that uniquely identifies the excitation arising in the source. By collecting together the additional conditions Eqs.( 12 - 17 ) as an addition to the original action of the theory in the region \left[t_{0},t_{0}+\tau_{0}\right]\times\Omega_{0} with the corresponding Lagrange multipliers, we obtain the action of the source: \displaystyle I_{0}+\partial I_{0} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}x\mathit{L} (18) \displaystyle-\lambda_{Q}\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}x\partial_{l}j^{l} \displaystyle-\lambda_{P^{a}}\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\partial\Omega_{0}}d\sigma_{m}T^{ma} \displaystyle-2\lambda_{J^{2}}\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\Omega_{0}}d^{3}xJ^{0,kl}\varepsilon_{kli} \displaystyle\times\int_{\partial\Omega_{0}}d\sigma_{p}J^{p,mn}\varepsilon_{mni} \displaystyle-\lambda_{J_{a}}\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+\tau_{0}}dt\int_{\partial\Omega_{0}}d\sigma_{p}\frac{1}{\left|\mathbf{a}\right|}a^{i}J^{p,kl}\varepsilon_{kli} \displaystyle+\left[\lambda_{Q}Q+\lambda_{P^{a}}P^{a}\right. \displaystyle\left.+\lambda_{J^{2}}\hslash^{2}J\left(J+1\right)+\lambda_{J_{a}}\hslash J_{a}\right] All that is contained in the additional conditions is the statement that in the specified region of space-time the change in the complete set of observables (admissible in quantum theory) is definite and will remain so after quantization. Note that the components of the source power, D , etc., do not enter explicitly into the action Eq.( 18 ). We can quantize the system in the region \Theta_{0}=\left[t_{0},t_{0}+\tau_{0}\right]\times\Omega_{0} independently of the rest of space-time if the field values on the boundary \partial\Theta_{0}=\left[t_{0},t_{0}+\tau_{0}\right]\times\partial\Omega_{0} are considered and quantized as an independent system. This is the structure of the action Eq.( 18 ) of the source. The attachment of the source to the rest of the space-time along the boundary \partial\Theta_{0} is carried out in the form of an obvious boundary condition: the boundary value of the wave function of the fields in the rest coincides with the wave function of the independent system on the boundary formed by the boundary values of the fields. When quantizing the source, we encounter one fundamental difficulty: the fourth term (in the third line) of the total action Eq.( 18 ) contains the interaction of the boundary and interior parts of the source. With the canonical approach to