Doppler shifted Hawking radiation from acoustic black holes in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions

Sanatan Digal, Ajit M. Srivastava · 2025

Read Doppler shifted Hawking radiation from acoustic black holes in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions by Sanatan Digal, Ajit M. Srivastava (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02079.txt.

Introduction

Sanatan Digal and Ajit M Srivastava predict Doppler shifted Hawking radiation from acoustic black holes in heavy ion collisions. When fluid flow turns supersonic, the boundary acts like a black hole horizon for sound. Hawking radiation from such acoustic horizons has been studied in cold atoms and electron fluids. In ultra relativistic collisions, the plasma flow pattern seemed to redshift the signal away to infinity.

Boost invariant flow holds only in a central window of the collision geometry. At large rapidities, meaning far along the beam direction, the flow must deviate from that pattern. An observer there sees a horizon with finite redshift instead. Particle momentum patterns should thus carry a Hawking imprint in that window, while central regions stay unaffected. The prediction opens a fresh observational target.

Catalog record

CREATORSanatan Digal, Ajit M. Srivastava
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02079

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Doppler shifted Hawking radiation from acoustic black holes in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions Preprint: IMSC/2025/06 Sanatan Digal, Ajit M. Srivastava Abstract In a hydrodynamic flow, with flow becoming supersonic at some point, the subsonic-supersonic boundary behaves as the horizon of a black hole. Possibility of detecting Hawking radiation from such acoustic black holes has been investigated in a variety of laboratory systems, ranging from cold atom systems, to condensed matter systems with hydrodynamic flow of electrons, to relativistic heavy-ion collisions (at relatively lower collision energies). Ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions, with boost-invariant longitudinal flow of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) in a wide rapidity window has eluded this remarkable possibility because in this case the black hole horizon is dynamical, moving away from center with sound velocity, leading to infinite red shift of Hawking radiation. We show here that such a conclusion is premature. The QGP flow at very large rapidities, necessarily deviates from Bjroken boost invariant flow. Due to this, an observer close to that region sees black hole horizon with a finite redshift. It leads to non-trivial prediction of Hawking radiation affecting particle momentum distributions for a window of rapidities, leaving near central rapidity regions unaffected. pacs PACS numbers: 04.70.Dy, 04.80.Cc, 12.38.Mh I Introduction Analogue gravity has opened new directions of investigating certain aspects of General Relativity in laboratory systems Unruh:1980cg ; Visser:1997ux . One of the most exciting possibility is the so called acoustic black holes, in particular the physics of Hawking radiation. In fact, most of the investigations of acoustic black holes have focused on the possibility of observing Hawking radiation in various laboratory systems. By analyzing the propagation of acoustic perturbations in the velocity potential of an inviscid, irrotational, barotropic fluid, Unruh had shown Unruh:1980cg that these acoustic perturbations obey an equation which is same as the Klein Gordon equation for a massless scalar field in a curved Lorentzian spacetime, with the spacetime metric determined by the flow velocity, density, and pressure of the fluid. If the flow changes from subsonic to supersonic, then the surface on which the normal component of fluid velocity equals the local speed of sound, becoming supersonic beyond it, behaves as the horizon of a black hole, as acoustic perturbations cannot cross this surface from the supersonic region to the subsonic region. This intuitive expectations was shown to be rigorously true by Unruh Unruh:1980cg who showed that for a spherically symmetric, stationary, convergent background fluid flow, the effective metric seen by acoustic perturbations of the velocity potential is the Schwarzschild metric, with the black hole horizon coinciding with the surface where the fluid velocity becomes supersonic. It then follows Unruh:1980cg that for the case when acoustic perturbations can be quantised, a thermal bath of acoustic phonons will be expected to be emitted from this sonic horizon in the form of Hawking radiation. A variety of laboratory systems have been proposed where this possibility of acoustic black holes may be realized and resulting Hawking radiation may be detected Steinhauer:2015ava ; Steinhauer:2015saa ; MunozdeNova:2018fxv ; Wang:2016jaj ; Michel:2016tog ; Grisins:2016gru ; Liberati:2019fse ; Isoard:2019buh ; Jacquet:2021scv ; Syu:2022ajm ; Tian:2018srd ; Ganguly:2019mza ; Kolobov:2019qfs ; Barcelo:2005fc . First experimental realization was with cold atom systems where the observation of Hawking radiation in terms of correlated pairs of Hawking particles emitted from the sonic horizon has been claimed with the two partners of the pair propagating on the two sides of the sonic horizon Steinhauer:2015ava ; Steinhauer:2015saa ; MunozdeNova:2018fxv , (see, also Wang:2016jaj ; Michel:2016tog ; Grisins:2016gru ; Liberati:2019fse ; Isoard:2019buh ; Jacquet:2021scv ; Syu:2022ajm in this context). Some of us recently investigated this possibility Dave:2022wgk for certain condensed matter systems where it has now become possible to realize the hydrodynamic regime for electron transport. It was shown in ref. Dave:2022wgk that for a 2-dimensional sample with the converging-diverging geometry of a de Laval nozzle, it is possible to realize electron flow pattern suitable for acoustic black hole, with the black hole horizon forming at the neck of the de Laval geometry. Resulting Hawking radiation in this case should then be observable in terms of current fluctuations. It was further argued that current fluctuations on both sides of the acoustic horizon should show correlations expected for pairs of Hawking particle. Apart from these very low energy/temperature condensed matter systems for acoustic black holes, a completely different regime of very high energy/temperature was proposed by some of us Das:2020zah for relativistic heavy-ion collisions. It was shown in Das:2020zah that an acoustic black hole metric may be constructed in the flow of quark-gluon plasma (QGP) in relativistic heavy-ion collisions Das:2020zah , with the resulting thermal radiation of acoustic phonons observable in terms of modification of the rapidity dependence of the transverse momentum distribution of various particles. One limitation of the analysis in Das:2020zah was that it was applicable for relatively lower energy relativistic heavy-ion collisions with resulting plasma temperature of order 135 MeV for which it was shown that resulting Hawking temperature will be about 4-5 MeV. It is important to note that 5 MeV of Hawking temperature, with background plasma having temperature of 135 MeV does not mean at all that the signal of Hawking radiation will be highly suppressed. This is because these two temperatures refer to completely different physical quantities. While plasma temperature directly relates to the p_{T} distribution of emitted particles, the Hawking radiation temperature corresponds to the temperature of phonon system which represents fluctuations in the longitudinal flow velocity (potential). Low value of this temperature for the phonon system corresponds to longer wavelengths, meaning that p_{T} distribution of relatively widely separated rapidity windows will get mixed up. A detailed analysis of the resulting signal in terms of perturbations on the p_{T} distribution is underway and we hope to report it in a future work. The reason that the analysis in Das:2020zah was restricted to lower energy collisions was due to expected boost-invariance of the longitudinal flow of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) in a wide rapidity window in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions at very high energies, such as at LHC and the high center of mass energy collisions at RHIC. In that case, the black hole horizon is dynamical, moving away from center with sound velocity, which leads to infinite red shift of Hawking radiation (see, refs. Ganguly:2019mza ; Nielsen:2008cr ; Nielsen:2005af in this context). At low energy collisions, the longitudinal flow does not follow Bjorken boost invariance, except possibly in a very narrow central rapidity region. Energy density gradients lead to acceleration of flow which can (almost) compensate for the slow down of the flow due to expansion. using URQMD simulations, it was shown in Das:2020zah that for a limited duration of proper time, it is then possible to achieve static horizon with observable predictions for the associated Hawking radiation. In this paper, we will reconsider this chain of arguments and show that even at ultra-high energy collisions, e.g. the highest center of mass collisions at LHC with very wide range of rapidity with boost invariant longitudinal flow for considerable duration of time, it is possible to have observable signals of Hawking radiation. The QGP flow velocity in this regime has only z-component v^{z} (along the beam axis), with the scaling law v^{z}=z/t as measured

Read the complete text