Supplementary Information for: Reentrant superconductivity and superconductor-to-insulator transition in a naturally occurring Josephson junction array tuned by RF power

S. Avraham, S. Sankar, S. Sandik, A. Burshtein, M. Goldstein, E. Sela, Y. Dagan · 2025

Read Supplementary Information for: Reentrant superconductivity and superconductor-to-insulator transition in a naturally occurring Josephson junction array tuned by RF power by S. Avraham, S. Sankar, S. Sandik, A. Burshtein, M. Goldstein, E. Sela, Y. Dagan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-02063.txt.

Introduction

S Avraham leads six co-authors in showing reentrant superconductivity in granular aluminum tuned by radio frequency power. Superconductivity normally fades as heat or magnetic field rises, but in rare cases it returns. Granular aluminum acts as a natural array of Josephson junctions, links that carry supercurrent across thin barriers. Radio power tunes the coupling energy between those junctions.

At low temperatures, giant Shapiro steps signal phase locking across the whole array like a single junction. Raising radio power can flip the system from coherent superconductivity to an insulating state. At higher temperatures, charge screening lowers charging energy and superconductivity reappears. That revival needs many body correlations beyond any single junction view. The system thus serves as a quantum simulator for competing order physics.

Catalog record

CREATORS. Avraham, S. Sankar, S. Sandik, A. Burshtein, M. Goldstein, E. Sela, Y. Dagan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-02063

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Supplementary Information for: Reentrant superconductivity and superconductor-to-insulator transition in a naturally occurring Josephson junction array tuned by RF power S. Avraham, S. Sankar, S. Sandik, A. Burshtein, M. Goldstein, E. Sela, Y. Dagan Abstract See pages 1 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 2 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 3 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 4 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 5 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 6 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 7 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 8 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 9 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 10 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 11 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 12 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf See pages 13 of Reentrant_SC_01092025.pdf I The Bloch band picture As noted in the main text, the zero-bias peak R_{\textrm{I}} in Fig. 1a of the main text cannot be captured within the RCSJ model. We speculate that its emergence may be attributed to the dual Bloch band picture. The periodic potential of a Josephson junction, -E_{J}\cos\phi , gives rise to Bloch wavefunctions that are 2\pi -periodic in \phi up to a phase that depends on the quasicharge q , which is analogous to the crystal momentum k in solid state systems and is defined in the Brillouin zone -e\leq q\leq e . From the solid state analogy, we find energy bands E_{n}(q) that depend periodically on q and are given by the Mathieu characteristic values Koch et al. 2007 , where n=0,1,\ldots is the band index. In the experimentally-relevant limit E_{J}\gg E_{C} , the junction potential is in the tight-binding limit, and the lowest Bloch band is approximately given by E_{0}(q)\approx-\Delta\cos(\pi q/e) , where \Delta\approx\frac{32}{2^{1/4}\sqrt{\pi}}(E_{J}^{3}E_{C})^{1/4}e^{-\sqrt{8E_{J}/E_{C}}} is the phase slips rate, which is the tunneling amplitude between adjacent minima in the cosine potential. The superconducting phase \phi and the quasicharge q are conjugate variables and satisfy an uncertainty relation. If the quantum fluctuations in the quasicharge are small (corresponding to a fluctuating phase), the semiclassical equation of motion for a junction biased by DC and RF currents I_{\textrm{b},\textrm{RF}} reads Likharev and Zorin 1985 \dot{q}=-\frac{1}{R_{\textrm{qp}}}\frac{dE_{0}(q)}{dq}+I_{\textrm{b}}+I_{\textrm{RF}}\sin(\omega_{\textrm{RF}}t), (S1) where R_{\textrm{qp}} is the quasiparticle resistance of the junction and \omega_{\textrm{RF}}=2\pi f_{\textrm{RF}} . Here we assume that the bias currents and the temperature are small enough such that the quasicharge is restricted to the lowest Bloch band, n=0 . This equation is dual to the RCSJ equation (Eq. (1) of the main text), with the absence of a second-derivative intertia term \ddot{q} ; this term may be added with an inductor L connected in series with the junction (dual to the parallel capacitance in the RCSJ model), but is unimportant in the following discussion and we omit it henceforth. The analysis of Eq. ( S1 ) is due to Likharev and Zorin Likharev and Zorin 1985 . Consider the case I_{\textrm{RF}}=0 , and set E_{0}(q)\approx-\Delta\cos(\pi q/e) . At I_{\textrm{b}}<I_{\textrm{th}} with I_{\textrm{th}}=\pi\Delta/(eR_{\textrm{qp}}) , the solution for the quasicharge is stationary, \dot{q}=0 , and the current flows through the quasiparticle channel, such that the voltage across the junction is V=I_{\textrm{b}}R_{\textrm{qp}} . As I_{\textrm{b}} exceeds the threshold I_{\textrm{th}} , the quasicharge is no longer stationary and enters the Bloch oscillations regime, less current flows through the quasiparticle channel, and the differential resistance dV/dI_{\textrm{b}} is negative. One therefore expects a resistance peak around I_{\textrm{b}}=0 with a width I_{\textrm{th}} . Such a peak was observed for resistively-shunted junctions Penttilä et al. 1999 , and also for a two-dimensional Josephson array Takahide et al. 2000 . Let us now consider the effect of a small RF current on the resistance peak. Within linear response in I_{\textrm{RF}} , we write q(t)=\tilde{q}(t)+\Re\{\delta qe^{i\omega_{\textrm{RF}}t}\} , where \tilde{q}(t) is the solution to Eq. ( S1 ) in the absence of RF current. Plugging q(t) to Eq. ( S1 ) and expanding in \delta q/\tilde{q}\ll 1 , we find \delta q=\frac{I_{\textrm{RF}}}{\omega_{\textrm{RF}}+i\frac{\pi^{2}\Delta}{e^{2}R_{\textrm{qp}}}\cos(\pi\tilde{q}/e)}. (S2) The correction \delta q renormalizes the Bloch bandwidth \Delta . To see this, plug q=\tilde{q}+\Re\{\delta qe^{i\omega_{\textrm{RF}}t}\} into \Delta\sin(\pi q(t)/e) : \Delta\sin(\pi q(t)/e)=\Delta J_{0}(\pi|\delta q|/e)\times\sin(\pi\tilde{q}/e)+\sum_{n\neq 0}J_{n}(\pi|\delta q|/e)e^{in(\omega_{\textrm{RF}}t-\varphi)}, (S3) where J_{n}(x) is the n th Bessel function of the first kind, and \varphi is the phase of \delta q . Integrating over a period of the RF current, the high-order Bessel functions average out, and we are left with a renormalized DC term: \Delta_{\textrm{eff}}=\Delta J_{0}(\pi|\delta q|/e). (S4) Using J_{0}(x\ll 1)\approx 1-x^{2}/4 , we find that \Delta_{\textrm{eff}} is reduced as the RF current is increased. This effect is expected to diminish at large frequencies, \omega_{\textrm{RF}}\gg\pi^{2}\Delta/(e^{2}R_{\textrm{qp}}) . We note that the same conclusions may be derived by diagonalizing the Floquet Hamiltonian of a periodically-tilted cosine potential and extracting the width of the lowest Bloch band from the Floquet quasienergies Gómez-León and Platero 2013 . Recalling that the Bloch bandwidth \Delta is the tunneling rate in the cosine potential, this effect may be interpreted as the coherent destruction of tunneling Grossmann et al. 1991 . In the experiment, the zero-bias resistance peak narrows as the RF power is increased, as shown in Fig. 1a of the main text. This is in line with the prediction of the Bloch band picture: decreasing \Delta_{\textrm{eff}} corresponds to decreasing I_{\textrm{th}}=\pi\Delta_{\textrm{eff}}/(eR_{\textrm{qp}}) . However, the rest of Fig. 1a is captured quite well by the RCSJ model, which cannot coexist with the Bloch band picture, since the two models correspond to two different regimes of quantum fluctuations in \phi and q . This possibly suggests that a more complete analysis is required to explain the experimental observations, not only the low-temperature phase diagram, but also the reentrant superconductivity at finite temperatures. II Controlling E_{J} with RF current In this section, we demonstrate how the application of RF current leads to a reduction in E_{J} within the RCSJ picture. Consider the semiclassical equation of motion for the phase, \frac{\phi_{0}}{2\pi}C\ddot{\phi}+\frac{\phi_{0}}{2\pi R}\dot{\phi}+I_{c}\sin(\phi)=I_{\textrm{b}}+I_{\textrm{RF}}\sin(\omega_{\textrm{RF}}t). (S5) Note that now R is the normal state resistance of the junction and not the quasiparticle resistance in the Bloch band picture. Neglecting the capacitive intertia term, which is unimportant in this context, the equation for the phase \phi is dual to Eq. ( S1 ) for the charge, with the critical current I_{c} replacing the phase slips rate \Delta . One may repeat the calculation from the previous section in the present situation: applying linear response in the RF current leads to a renormalization of the critical current, \delta I_{c,\textrm{eff}}=I_{c}J_{0}(|\delta\phi|), (S6) with \delta\phi=\frac{RI_{\textrm{RF}}}{\frac{\phi_{0}}{2\pi}\omega_{\textrm{RF}}+iRI_{c}\cos(\tilde{\phi})}, (S7) where \tilde{\phi} is the solution to Eq. ( S5 ) at I_{\textrm{RF}}=0 . Thus, we find that E_{J,\textrm{eff}}=\Phi_{0}I_{c,\textrm{eff}}/(2\pi) decreases as I_{\textrm{RF}} increases. Note that Eqs. ( S4 ) and ( S6 ) result from the Bloch band and RCSJ pictures, respectively, which correspond to different regimes of quantum fluctuations and hint at a non-trivial dependence of the junction parameters on the RF current. On the one hand, the Bloch band picture predicts that the phase slips rate is decreased as the RF current is increased. On the other hand, the RCSJ model predicts a decrease in I_{c} and hence E_{J} as well, corresponding to a larger phase slips rate \Delta\sim e^{-\sqrt{8E_{J}/E_{C}}} . We conclude that the dependence of the junction parameters on the RF current is drastically altered by the regime of quantum fluctuations. III Comparing the experiment with the RCSJ model In a simplified picture, the granular aluminum (grAl) sample can be thought of as a stack of many parallel 1D JJ chains. When current biased,

Read the complete text