Wrong Model, Right Uncertainty: Spatial Associations for Discrete Data with Misspecification
David R. Burt, Renato Berlinghieri, Tamara Broderick · 2025
Read Wrong Model, Right Uncertainty: Spatial Associations for Discrete Data with Misspecification by David R. Burt, Renato Berlinghieri, Tamara Broderick (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01776.txt.
Introduction
David R Burt, Renato Berlinghieri, and Tamara Broderick give trustworthy error bars for spatial links with yes-no or count data. Health teams often ask how disease presence shifts with heat or pollution across places. Past methods may assume the model is right or that places were sampled at random. Both assumptions fail in much real spatial work.
The authors give the first intervals with guaranteed long run coverage for such links with discrete outcomes. Their proof handles noise that varies by place and sampling that is not random. Standard methods can miss coverage badly and even flip the sign of a link in tests. Their method holds the promised coverage in those same checks.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | David R. Burt, Renato Berlinghieri, Tamara Broderick |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01776
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Wrong Model, Right Uncertainty: Spatial Associations for Discrete Data with Misspecification David R. Burt, Renato Berlinghieri, Tamara Broderick Abstract Scientists are often interested in estimating an association between a covariate and a binary- or count-valued response. For instance, public health officials are interested in how much disease presence (a binary response per individual) varies as temperature or pollution (covariates) increases. Many existing methods can be used to estimate associations, and corresponding uncertainty intervals, but make unrealistic assumptions in the spatial domain. For instance, they incorrectly assume models are well-specified. Or they assume the training and target locations are i.i.d. — whereas in practice, these locations are often not even randomly sampled. Some recent work avoids these assumptions but works only for continuous responses with spatially constant noise. In the present work, we provide the first confidence intervals with guaranteed asymptotic nominal coverage for spatial associations given discrete responses, even under simultaneous model misspecification and nonrandom sampling of spatial locations. To do so, we demonstrate how to handle spatially varying noise, provide a novel proof of consistency for our proposed estimator, and use a delta method argument with a Lyapunov central limit theorem. We show empirically that standard approaches can produce unreliable confidence intervals and can even get the sign of an association wrong, while our method reliably provides correct coverage. 1 Introduction Estimating associations between spatial variables and a binary- or count-valued response is fundamental across scientific disciplines. For instance, researchers are interested in (a) how much cardiovascular disease (a binary response per individual) increases with air pollution in Chinese cities ( Zhao et al., 2015 ) , (b) how the number of hospital admissions (a count-valued response per hospital) increases with temperature in European cities ( Michelozzi et al., 2009 ) , and (c) the extent to which ozone exceeding health guidance (a binary outcome) increases with meteorological variables in major cities in Texas ( Vizuete et al., 2022 ) . Moreover, quantifying uncertainty in these associations is fundamental for scientific and public health decision-making. There are two natural approaches. (A) We might fit a highly flexible classifier — e.g., a transformer ( Vaswani et al., 2017 ) , or gradient-boosted tree ( Chen and Guestrin, 2016 ) — and then apply a post hoc interpretability method ( Lundberg and Lee, 2017 ; Ribeiro et al., 2016 , e.g.) . But data in these applications are often very sparse in space, so we might hope to estimate an association well even when prediction quality could be very poor. (B) We might fit an interpretable model to start. For instance, when the response is continuous, Buja et al., 2019a argue that a linear model can be used to estimate associations even when the data are highly nonlinear — that is, even when the linear model is (potentially very) misspecified. Additional challenges arise in the applications described, though. Namely, the spatial locations where we want to draw inferences need not align well with the locations where we have data. E.g., in example (c) above, scientists have access to sensors across the state but are interested in associations in major Texas cities. Moreover, neither the training nor target locations are random. E.g., in Texas, air pollution monitor placement is decided by state and local governments under regulatory constraints from the United States Environmental Protection Agency. And major Texas cities are not randomly sampled from a larger population. For continuous responses, Burt et al., 2025a address these concerns; they provide confidence intervals that maintain nominal coverage over spatial associations, even when training and target spatial locations can be nonaligned and nonrandom. However, their method requires continuous responses with homoskedastic (spatially constant) noise. In all of the applications discussed above, and many other spatial analyses, the response is binary- or count-valued, and so the noise is heteroskedastic in space. To instead provide confidence intervals for binary- or count-valued data, we might naturally think to apply the delta method ( van der Vaart, 1998 , Chapter 3) to the estimator from Burt et al., 2025a . However, the delta method requires a consistent point estimate. In the present work, we show that the point estimate from Burt et al., 2025a is not generally consistent. Therefore, we need both a new estimator, as well as a new confidence interval, for the binary- and count-valued response setting. We provide these in the present work. Along the way, we also provide an estimator and asymptotically valid confidence intervals for continuous responses with spatially varying noise. In particular, we suggest a new point estimate inspired by Buja et al., 2019a , Buja et al., 2019b , Burt et al., 2025b , and Burt et al., 2025a ; our estimate starts from a (misspecified but interpretable) generalized linear model (GLM) but takes into account nonrandom and nonaligned sampling of spatial locations. We show that in an infill asymptotic setting , where we have a sequence of spatial locations that eventually becomes dense in space but may not be sampled from any probability measure, our estimator is consistent. This consistency requires adaptivity; we demonstrate that the estimator of Burt et al., 2025a and standard GLM point estimates using the training data are generally not consistent in this setting. We establish asymptotic normality of our estimator under conditions strictly more general than assuming training locations are sampled from a distribution supported around target locations. Our approach requires a Lyapunov central limit theorem applicable to non-identically distributed data. We propose a new, computationally efficient variance estimator suitable for problems with spatially varying noise and prove its consistency under infill asymptotics. Combining these results, we propose confidence intervals that can be computed efficiently from the available data, and prove that these confidence intervals are asymptotically conservative. Our simulations demonstrate that existing methods can lead to fundamentally incorrect conclusions. In some cases, all baseline confidence intervals achieve zero empirical coverage and produce associations with the wrong sign while excluding zero. Our method consistently achieves coverage at or above the nominal level and never produces wrong-signed associations with confidence intervals excluding zero. Importantly, one simulation requires extrapolation, demonstrating that even when infill assumptions are unrealistic, our approach often provides conservative uncertainty estimates. 2 Setup and Background We first describe our data and data-generating process. Then we describe our (misspecified) model and estimand. Our assumed data-generating process and estimand in this section are similar to those in Burt et al., 2025a . Our estimator, theory, and experiments form our major contributions (in subsequent sections) and are substantially different from Burt et al., 2025a . 2.1 Data-Generating Process The training data consist of N fully observed triples (S_{n},X_{n},Y_{n})_{n=1}^{N} , with spatial location S_{n}\in\mathcal{S} , covariate X_{n}\in\mathbb{R}^{P} , and response Y_{n}\in\mathcal{Y}\subset\mathbb{R} . While our motivation and experiments focus on \mathcal{Y}=\{0,1\} (binary-valued) or \mathcal{Y}=\mathbb{N} (count-valued), our treatment also handles Y_{n}\in\mathbb{R} . \mathcal{S} represents geographic space; we assume \mathcal{S} is a metric space with metric d_{\mathcal{S}} . We collect the training covariates in the matrix X\in\mathbb{R}^{N\times P} and the training responses in the N -tuple Y\in\mathcal{Y}^{N} . The target data consist of M pairs (S^{\star}_{m},X^{\star}_{m})_{m=1}^{M} , with S^{\star}_{m}\in\mathcal{S} , X^{\star}_{m}\in\mathbb{R}^{P} . The corresponding responses \{Y^{\star}_{m}\}_{m=1}^{M} are unobserved. We collect target covariates in X^{\star}\in\mathbb{R}^{M\times P} and unobserved target responses in a tuple