Azimuthal offsets in spiral arms of nearby galaxies
Miguel Querejeta, Sharon E. Meidt, Yixian Cao, Dario Colombo, Eric Emsellem, Santiago García-Burillo, Ralf S. Klessen, Eric W. Koch, Adam K. Leroy, Marina Ruiz-García, Eva Schinnerer, Rowan Smith, Sophia Stuber, Mallory Thorp, Thomas G. Williams, Médéric Boquien, Daniel A. Dale, Chris Faesi, Damian · 2025
Read Azimuthal offsets in spiral arms of nearby galaxies by Miguel Querejeta, Sharon E. Meidt, Yixian Cao, Dario Colombo, Eric Emsellem, Santiago García-Burillo, Ralf S. Klessen, Eric W. Koch, Adam K. Leroy, Marina Ruiz-García, Eva Schinnerer, Rowan Smith, Sophia Stuber, Mallory Thorp, Thomas G. Williams, Médéric Boquien, Daniel A. Dale, Chris Faesi, Damian (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01668.txt.
Introduction
Spiral arms shape disc galaxies, but whether they are lasting waves or passing patterns is still debated. Miguel Querejeta, with thirty co-authors, measures offsets between molecular gas peaks and star formation peaks across twenty-four nearby galaxies from the PHANGS survey, all with clear spiral structure. If gas crosses a steady arm, the youngest stars should sit ahead of the gas in the rotation direction.
Offsets were measured in radial bins and showed substantial scatter, implying star formation is not triggered only at one coherent spiral shock. Fourteen galaxies had positive mean offsets, typically a few hundred parsecs. In four, the offsets shrank with radius as a single steady density wave predicts. Ten showed positive offsets with no radial trend, fitting several overlapping modes, and ten showed no clear positive offsets, pointing to transient arms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Miguel Querejeta, Sharon E. Meidt, Yixian Cao, Dario Colombo, Eric Emsellem, Santiago García-Burillo, Ralf S. Klessen, Eric W. Koch, Adam K. Leroy, Marina Ruiz-García, Eva Schinnerer, Rowan Smith, Sophia Stuber, Mallory Thorp, Thomas G. Williams, Médéric Boquien, Daniel A. Dale, Chris Faesi, Damian |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01668
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Azimuthal offsets in spiral arms of nearby galaxies Miguel Querejeta, Sharon E. Meidt, Yixian Cao, Dario Colombo, Eric Emsellem, Santiago García-Burillo, Ralf S. Klessen, Eric W. Koch, Adam K. Leroy, Marina Ruiz-García, Eva Schinnerer, Rowan Smith, Sophia Stuber, Mallory Thorp, Thomas G. Williams, Médéric Boquien, Daniel A. Dale, Chris Faesi, Damian R. Gleis, Kathryn Grasha, Annie Hughes, María J. Jiménez-Donaire, Kathryn Kreckel, Daizhong Liu, Justus Neumann, Hsi-An Pan, Francesca Pinna, Alessandro Razza, Toshiki Saito, Jiayi Sun, Antonio Usero Abstract Spiral arms play a central role in disc galaxies, but their dynamical nature remains a long-standing open question. Azimuthal offsets between molecular gas and star formation are expected if gas crosses spiral arms, as predicted by quasi-stationary density wave theory. In this work, we measure offsets between CO and H α \alpha peaks in radial bins for 24 galaxies from the PHANGS survey that display a well-delineated spiral structure. The offsets exhibit substantial scatter, implying that star formation is not exclusively initiated at a coherent spiral shock. We define offsets such that positive values mean H α \alpha peaks lie ahead of CO peaks in the direction of galactic rotation. With this convention, 14 galaxies show mean positive CO-H α \alpha offsets, typically of a few hundred parsecs. In four of these 14 galaxies (17% of the total), offsets become smaller with increasing radius, as expected for a single quasi-stationary spiral density wave. Ten galaxies (42%) show positive mean offsets but no clear correlation with radius, which is compatible with multiple overlapping modes. In the remaining ten galaxies (42%), we find no significantly positive offsets, which could point to transient dynamical spirals or material arms, where gas and stars co-rotate with the spiral perturbation. Across the full sample, we find mostly positive offsets between CO peaks and the gravitational potential minimum, confirming that gas often crosses the spiral perturbation. For the four galaxies with clear positive offsets and a radial trend, we derived pattern speeds in good agreement with the literature. Overall, our results suggest that even well-delineated spirals in the local Universe can arise from a variety of underlying dynamical mechanisms. 1 Introduction Despite the widespread presence of spiral arms in the local Universe ( Nair & Abraham 2010 ; Willett et al. 2013 ; Buta et al. 2015 , e.g.) , understanding their origin and nature remains an open subject of research in contemporary astrophysics. One of the most popular theories to explain the spiral pattern in disc galaxies is quasi-stationary spiral density wave theory ( Lin & Shu 1964 ; Lin & Shu 1966 ; Bertin et al. 1989 ; Bertin 2000 ) , which posits that spiral arms are long-lived, self-sustaining modes of the disc that rigidly rotate at a constant pattern speed, \Omega_{\rm P} . In this model, spiral arms are local overdensities formed by different stars over time as gas and stars cross the spirals. In another leading theory, spirals are temporary material patterns that rotate with the disc. This would be the case for spirals originating through swing amplification ( Goldreich & Lynden-Bell 1965 ; Julian & Toomre 1966 ; Meidt & van der Wel 2024 ) or spirals that are tidal features produced during interactions and mergers ( Toomre 1969 ; Toomre 1981 ; Donner & Thomasson 1994 ; Kawata et al. 2014 , e.g.) . The former are thought to be consistent with the spirals in flocculent galaxies, whereas the latter are argued to be prominent in some grand-design spirals, such as M51 (especially in the outer regions; Meidt et al. 2009 , Tress et al. 2020 ). In either case, in contrast to the Lin-Shu quasi-stationary modes, material spirals are temporary features of the disc, and they co-rotate with the disc material ( Dobbs & Baba 2014 ; Sellwood & Masters 2022 ) such that the gas and stars do not cross the spiral. The spirals formed in modern simulations of isolated disc galaxies exhibit properties resembling both types of theory: They are short-lived rigidly rotating ‘groove’ modes of the disc shaped by both swing amplification (which amplifies small perturbations as they shear due to differential rotation) and changes to the disc properties brought about by earlier spiral features ( Sellwood & Carlberg 2014 ; see also Binney 2020 ; Sridhar 2019 ; Meidt & van der Wel 2024 ; Hamilton 2024 ). These spirals are often composed of multiple independent modes, each excited around its own co-rotation. Observational measurements of multiple independent pattern speeds ( Meidt et al. 2008 ; Meidt et al. 2009 ; Font et al. 2011 ; Font et al. 2014 ; Font et al. 2024 ; Colombo et al. 2014 ; Marchuk 2024 , e.g.) tend to support this picture, especially when the co-rotation resonance of one spiral overlaps with a resonance of another spiral ( Sellwood & Carlberg 2014 ) . Resonance overlaps such as these, which are also thought to allow for non-linear mode coupling ( Sygnet et al. 1988 ) , produce radially extended spiral arms that allow for energy and angular momentum transfer extending widely across the disc ( Masset & Tagger 1997 ) . The spirals produced in these different pictures yield different responses to the gas and the young and old stellar discs, which can offer a way to discriminate between them. In the picture of quasi-stationary density waves, the shock predicted in the gas as it overtakes the spiral pattern leads to a systematic offset between the accumulation of gas at the shock front and star formation peaks and thus also between young and older stars ( Roberts 1969 ) . This offset will decrease in amplitude moving outwards along the spiral and switch direction, passing from inside to outside co-rotation. For multiple ‘groove’ modes that extend only out to co-rotation, no switch in offset location will be produced. For material arms, no systematic offset is expected ( Grand et al. 2012a ; Grand et al. 2012b ; Kawata et al. 2014 ; Baba et al. 2015 ) . Numerous studies have attempted to identify angular offsets associated with spiral arms. Different approaches include measuring changes in pitch angle for several bands or colour maps ( Grosbøl & Dottori 2009 ; Abdeen et al. 2020 ; Martínez-García et al. 2023 ; Marchuk et al. 2024b ) , identifying stellar populations or clusters of different ages ( Choi et al. 2015 ; Chandar et al. 2017 ; Shabani et al. 2018 ; Peterken et al. 2019 ) , pinpointing offsets involving HII regions ( Egusa et al. 2009 ; Egusa et al. 2017 ; Cedrés et al. 2013 ) , deriving w cross-correlations for different tracers ( Tamburro et al. 2008 ; Foyle et al. 2011 ; Schinnerer et al. 2013 ) , and even conducting comparisons with numerical simulations ( Dobbs & Bonnell 2007 ; Wang et al. 2015 ) . Based on the analysis of offsets or pitch angles, some studies have found strong evidence supporting quasi-stationary spiral density wave theory for certain galaxies ( Egusa et al. 2009 ; Peterken et al. 2019 ; Miller et al. 2019 ; Abdeen et al. 2020 ; Martínez-García et al. 2023 ; Marchuk et al. 2024b , e.g.) . However,