Mysteries of Capotauro — investigating the puzzling nature of an extreme F356W-dropout
G. Gandolfi 1,2, G. Rodighiero 1,2, M. Castellano 3, A. Fontana 3, P. Santini 3, M. Dickinson 4, S. Finkelstein 5, M. Catone 1, A. Calabrò 3, E. Merlin 3, L. Pentericci 3, L. Bisigello 2, A. Grazian 2, L. Napolitano 3,6, B. Vulcani 2, A. J. Taylor 5, P. Arrabal Haro 7, A. Kirkpatrick 8, B. E. Backha · 2025
Read Mysteries of Capotauro — investigating the puzzling nature of an extreme F356W-dropout by G. Gandolfi 1,2, G. Rodighiero 1,2, M. Castellano 3, A. Fontana 3, P. Santini 3, M. Dickinson 4, S. Finkelstein 5, M. Catone 1, A. Calabrò 3, E. Merlin 3, L. Pentericci 3, L. Bisigello 2, A. Grazian 2, L. Napolitano 3,6, B. Vulcani 2, A. J. Taylor 5, P. Arrabal Haro 7, A. Kirkpatrick 8, B. E. Backha (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01664.txt.
Introduction
Giovanni Gandolfi leads forty co-authors in a study of Capotauro, a faint source that drops out of Webb telescope images at shorter wavelengths. Its light falls by more than three steps in brightness across a narrow color range and vanishes below that range. Such sharp drops can mark very distant galaxies, dusty systems, or cold objects inside our own galaxy. The team blends Webb and Hubble data to test each option.
Fits to the light favor a break that would place the source at an extreme distance tied to the first stars. Lower distance fits need odd mixes of dust and aging starlight to match the drop. A very cold brown dwarf or free floating planet also fits some traits. More data will be needed to settle what Capotauro is.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | G. Gandolfi 1,2, G. Rodighiero 1,2, M. Castellano 3, A. Fontana 3, P. Santini 3, M. Dickinson 4, S. Finkelstein 5, M. Catone 1, A. Calabrò 3, E. Merlin 3, L. Pentericci 3, L. Bisigello 2, A. Grazian 2, L. Napolitano 3,6, B. Vulcani 2, A. J. Taylor 5, P. Arrabal Haro 7, A. Kirkpatrick 8, B. E. Backha |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01664
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mysteries of Capotauro — investigating the puzzling nature of an extreme F356W-dropout G. Gandolfi 1,2, G. Rodighiero 1,2, M. Castellano 3, A. Fontana 3, P. Santini 3, M. Dickinson 4, S. Finkelstein 5, M. Catone 1, A. Calabrò 3, E. Merlin 3, L. Pentericci 3, L. Bisigello 2, A. Grazian 2, L. Napolitano 3,6, B. Vulcani 2, A. J. Taylor 5, P. Arrabal Haro 7, A. Kirkpatrick 8, B. E. Backhaus 8, B. W. Holwerda, M. Giulietti 10, N. J. Cleri 11,12,13, E. Daddi 14, H. C. Ferguson 15, M. Hirschmann 16, A. M. Koekemoer 15, A. Lapi 17,10, F. Pacucci 18,19, P. G. Pérez-González 20, A. de la Vega 21, S. Wilkins 22, L. Y. A. Yung 16, M. Bagley 5, R.Bhatawdekar 23, J. Kartaltepe 24, C. Papovich 25,26, N. Pirzkal 27 Abstract Context. The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has uncovered a diverse population of extreme near-infrared dropouts, including ultra high-redshift ( z > 15 z>15 ) galaxy candidates, dust-obscured galaxies challenging theories of dust production, sources with strong Balmer breaks—possibly compact active galactic nuclei in dense, gas-rich environments—and cold, sub-stellar Galactic objects. Aims. This work presents Capotauro , a F356W-dropout identified in the CEERS survey with a F444W AB magnitude of ∼ 27.68 \sim\!27.68 and exhibiting a sharp flux drop by ¿ 3 mag between 3.5 and 4.5 μ 4.5\,\mu m, being non-detected below 3.5 μ 3.5\,\mu m. We investigate its nature and constrain its properties, paving the way for follow-up observations. Methods. We combine JWST/NIRCam, MIRI, and NIRSpec/MSA data with HST/ACS and WFC3 observations to perform a spectro-photometric analysis of Capotauro using multiple SED-fitting codes. Our setup is tailored to test z ≥ 15 z\!\geq\!15 as well as z < 10 z\!<\!10 dusty, Balmer-break or strong-line emitter galaxy solutions, and the possibility of Capotauro being a Milky Way sub-stellar object. Results. Among extragalactic options, our analysis favors interpreting the sharp flux drop of Capotauro as a Lyman break at z ∼ 32 z\!\sim\!32 , consistent with the formation epoch of the first stars and black holes, with only ∼ 0.5 % \sim\!0.5\% of the redshift posterior volume lying at z < 25 z\!<\!25 . Lower-redshift solutions struggle to reproduce the extreme break, suggesting that if Capotauro resides at z < 10 z\!<\!10 , it must show a non-standard combination of high dust attenuation and/or prominent Balmer breaks, making it a peculiar interloper. Finally, our analysis indicates that Capotauro ’s properties could be consistent with it being a very cold (i.e., Y2-Y3 type) brown dwarf or a free-floating exoplanet with a record-breaking combination of low temperature and large distance ( T eff ≤ 300 T_{\rm eff}\!\leq\!300 K, d ≳ 130 d\!\gtrsim\!130 pc, up to ∼ 2 \sim\!2 kpc). Conclusions. While present observations cannot determine Capotauro ’s nature, our analysis points to a remarkably unique object in all plausible scenarios. This makes Capotauro stand out as a compelling target for follow-up observations. 1 Introduction The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST; Gardner et al. 2006 ; Gardner et al. 2023 ) has greatly enhanced our ability to identify and characterize faint near-infrared (NIR) dropout sources — objects that drop out of detection in the bluest available NIR filters. Due to JWST’s unparalleled sensitivity at wavelengths >2\,\mu m, NIR dropout selections have become a powerful tool for uncovering new classes of objects that were previously inaccessible. Indeed, JWST NIR-dropout searches successfully pushed Lyman-break galaxy confirmations to z\!\sim\!14 ( Carniani et al. 2024 ; Naidu et al. 2025b ) , spurring efforts to extend dropout selections into even redder JWST/NIRCam bands in search of ultra high-redshift ( z\!\gtrsim\!15 ) candidates ( Yan et al. 2023 ; Austin et al. 2023 ; Harikane et al. 2023 ; Donnan et al. 2023 ; Pérez-González et al. 2023 ; Kokorev et al. 2024a ; Pérez-González et al. 2025 ; Castellano et al. 2025 ; Gandolfi et al. 2025 ; Whitler et al. 2025 ) . Although some models, such as FLARES ( Lovell et al. 2021 ; Wilkins et al. 2023 ) , are able to reproduce the observed number densities up to at least z\!<\!13 without enhancements, the observed excess of bright galaxies at z\!>\!9 (e.g., Naidu et al. 2022 ; Castellano et al. 2022 ; Sun et al. 2023 ; Finkelstein et al. 2023 ; Finkelstein et al. 2024 ) could still point to processes such as enhanced star formation efficiency, a different initial mass function (IMF), rapid baryon assembly (e.g., weak feedback), bursty/stochastic star formation or low dust attenuation ( Dekel et al. 2023 ; Ferrara et al. 2023 ; Ciesla et al. 2024 ; Lapi et al. 2024 ; Trinca et al. 2024 ; Yung et al. 2024a ; Ferrara et al. 2025 ; Mauerhofer et al. 2025 ; Somerville et al. 2025 ) . If such mechanisms are already in place by z\!\sim\!9\!-\!10 , then the detection of candidates at z\!\geq\!15 could provide critical insights into the underlying physics responsible for this excess. However, given the depth of current surveys, the selection of ultra high-redshift candidates — expected to appear as dropouts at \lambda\!\gtrsim\!2\,\mu m in JWST/NIRCam imaging — is complicated by by contamination from lower-redshift sources. Through diverse and often astrophysically interesting mechanisms, several classes of foreground objects can produce a sharp flux decrement at the short-wavelength end of their NIR emission, mimicking a Lyman break and, in general, reproducing the photometric signatures expected for z\!\geq\!15 objects ( Vulcani et al. 2017 ; Gandolfi et al. 2025 ; Castellano et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . Among the potential interlopers, sources with substantial dust obscuration can appear as NIR dropouts, despite residing at z\!\ll\!15 . The so-called High Extinction, Low Mass (HELM) systems ( Bisigello et al. 2023 ; Bisigello et al. 2024 ; Bisigello et al. 2025 ) exhibit low stellar masses ( \langle\log M_{*}/M_{\odot}\rangle\!\sim\!7.3 ) yet extreme dust attenuation ( \langle A_{V}\rangle\!\sim\!4.9 ), challenging the conventional expectation that dust content scales positively with stellar mass if dust was produced predominantly by evolved stars and supernovae ( Scalo & Slavsky 1980 ) . Indeed, the NIR color-magnitude properties of HELM galaxies can overlap with those expected for ultra high-redshift objects ( Gandolfi et al. 2025 ; Castellano et al. 2025 ) . At the opposite extreme in terms of stellar mass, F200W-dropout searches have also revealed JWST/MIRI-detected red monsters at z\gtrsim 6 , suggesting that massive, heavily obscured systems with substantial dust reservoirs were already in place at early cosmic epochs ( Rodighiero et al. 2023 ) . At the same time, ultra high-redshift object searches may be contaminated by foreground sources with sharp Balmer breaks, originating from mature stellar populations or, perhaps, from even more exotic mechanisms. Indeed, JWST has recently revealed a number of compact objects featuring extremely sharp Balmer breaks ( Wang et al. 2024 ; Kokorev et al. 2024b ; Matthee et al. 2024 ; Weibel et al. 2025 ; de Graaff et al. 2025b ; Naidu et al. 2025a ; de Graaff et al. 2025a ; Taylor et al. 2025 ) . With effective radii typically below 100 pc, some of these sources are related to the mysterious Little Red Dots (see, e.g., Barro et al. 2024 ; Kocevski et al.