Quantifying the Effect of Thermal Illusions in Virtual Reality DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: ; ; CCS: Human-centered computing Haptic devices CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality
Yannick Weiss, Marlene Eder, Oguzhan Cesur, Steeven Villa · 2025
Read Quantifying the Effect of Thermal Illusions in Virtual Reality DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: ; ; CCS: Human-centered computing Haptic devices CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality by Yannick Weiss, Marlene Eder, Oguzhan Cesur, Steeven Villa (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01609.txt.
Introduction
Feeling heat or cold matters in virtual reality, yet real thermal hardware is bulky, power hungry, and limits movement. Yannick Weiss, Marlene Eder, Oguzhan Cesur, and Steeven Villa quantify thermal illusions, perceptual tricks where sight and sound cues shift felt temperature without any physical change. Such illusions had been shown to move subjective ratings, but not how far.
Two user studies followed psychophysical procedures. The first ordered and scaled the effects of varied visual and auditory cues across twenty participants. The second, with twenty-four, measured how well single and combined cues could offset real temperature changes. Illusions produced robust shifts in judgments, and auditory cues showed promise as an alternative channel. Weiss and the team give designers numbers, not just impressions, for faking temperature in immersive systems.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yannick Weiss, Marlene Eder, Oguzhan Cesur, Steeven Villa |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01609
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantifying the Effect of Thermal Illusions in Virtual Reality DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: ; ; CCS: Human-centered computing Haptic devices CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality Yannick Weiss, Marlene Eder, Oguzhan Cesur, Steeven Villa Abstract . Thermal sensations are central to how we experience the world, yet most virtual and extended reality systems fail to simulate them effectively. While hardware-based thermal displays can provide accurate temperature changes, they are often bulky, power-intensive, and restrict user mobility. Consequently, recent works have explored thermal illusions, perceptual effects that rely on cross-modal interactions, to achieve thermal experiences without physical heating or cooling. While thermal illusions have been shown to consistently alter subjective ratings, the actual extent of their effect on the perceived temperature of interacted objects remains unexplored. To address this, we contribute the findings of two user studies following psychophysical procedures. We first ordered and scaled the effects of a variety of visual and auditory cues (N=20) and subsequently quantified their isolated and combined efficacy in offsetting physical temperature changes (N=24). We found that thermal illusions elicited robust changes in subjective judgments, and auditory cues showed potential as an alternative or complementary approach to established visual techniques. However, the actual effects induced by thermal illusions were relatively small (±0.5°C) and did not consistently align with abstract ratings, suggesting a need to reconsider how future thermal illusions or experiences are designed and evaluated. 1. Introduction From enjoying a hot cup of tea, receiving a warm embrace from friends, to checking the bathwater before hopping in, our sense of temperature plays a crucial role in our daily lives, helping us experience and interact with our environment and each other. Although thermal sensations are an essential component of our experience of the real world, current virtual (VR) or extended reality (XR) systems generally lack the capabilities to simulate these haptic experiences. To address this, researchers have developed various room-scale ( Shaw et al. 2019 ; Han et al. 2018 ) and wearable ( Wang et al. 2024 ; Chen et al. 2017 ) thermal displays to apply temperature changes to users’ skin. However, these systems require the integration of additional hardware, limiting users’ mobility, massively increasing power consumption, and preventing interactions and experiences beyond the specific device. Consequently, researchers explored novel alternative and complementary approaches using sensory illusions to manipulate temperature sensations. By exploiting multisensory interactions between visual and thermal cues, these illusions have been shown to effectively alter the perceived temperatures of virtual objects or environments, for instance, via changes in colors ( Villa et al. 2024b ; Käthner et al. 2019 ) , displaying fire or ice metaphors ( Günther et al. 2020 ; Blaga et al. 2020 ) , or changing virtual surroundings ( Brooks et al. 2020 ; Kocur et al. 2023 ) . However, the effectiveness of these approaches is always measured and compared using subjective, abstract scales ( Käthner et al. 2019 ; Günther et al. 2020 ; Peiris et al. 2017 ; Villa et al. 2024b ) . The actual perceptual shift in temperature that these visuo-thermal illusions induce has not been explored. This leaves open the fundamental question of whether thermal illusions are capable of inducing large temperature alterations akin to hardware-based approaches or solely serve as tie-breakers when consciously sorting or mapping temperature sensations. To address this gap, we investigate and quantify the efficacy of thermal illusions. We employed two established psychophysical procedures to first order and scale, and subsequently quantify the effect of a set of thermal illusions on the perceived temperature of an interacted object. In addition, while prior research has primarily focused on visual cues ( Blaga et al. 2020 ; Günther et al. 2020 ; Villa et al. 2024b ) , we expand this scope by examining a broader range of visual, auditory, and visuo-auditory stimuli. Across the two studies, we found that thermal illusions reliably influenced subjective temperature judgments, with auditory cues proving particularly effective both alone and in combination with visual input. However, we observed an incongruence between subjective ratings and actual perceptual shifts, exposing a key limitation of relying solely on abstract evaluation methods. Crucially, direct measurements revealed that the illusions produced only small changes in perceived temperature (within \pm 0.5°C), indicating that their perceptual impact is far weaker than what prior evaluations relying on subjective scales might suggest. While these illusions did not impair perceptual sensitivity and can still serve as subtle enhancements, our findings call into question their suitability as substitutes for physical thermal feedback. 2. Related Work This work draws from a large body of research aiming to understand and enhance thermal experiences in virtual environments. In the following, we provide an overview of conventional thermal rendering approaches ( Section 2.1 ) and prior explorations of thermal illusions ( Section 2.2 ). 2.1. Devices for Thermal Rendering Rendering realistic thermal sensations in virtual environments has been a large area of haptics research (see ( Park 2025 ; Ichihashi et al. 2025 ) for recent reviews), due to its importance for immersion ( Shaw et al. 2019 ) , affective communication ( Williams and Bargh 2008 ) , and comfort ( Knierim et al. 2024 ) . Thermal sensations of warm and cold are primarily perceived through cutaneous receptors ( Jones and Ho 2008a ) , leading a majority of approaches to focus on wearable devices constantly in contact with the skin ( Park 2025 ) . Research primarily relies on Peltier elements placed on users’ hands ( Nasser and Hasan 2024 ; Wang et al. 2024 ) , arms ( Peiris et al. 2019 ; Kang et al. 2024 ) , or mounted on a head-mounted display ( Peiris et al. 2017 ; Chen et al. 2017 ; Ranasinghe et al. 2018 ; Wolf et al. 2019 ) , enabling both warm and cold sensations depending on polarity. Peltiers are small and easily controlled; however, these devices require large heatsinks and power supplies to remain effective, making them generally very rigid, which restricts users’ dexterity. Therefore, novel research also looked at pneumatic ( Cai et al. 2020 ) or liquid ( Günther et al. 2020 ) alternatives, which can be delivered to the skin through tubes. While these allow more dexterous interactions by being able to be bent and deformed, they still consume a large amount of power and tether the user to a large external device. Wearable approaches generally require constant contact with the skin, obstructing other haptic feedback or physical interactions. For controlled environments, research therefore applied alternate approaches, using external devices to deliver temperature feedback with encounter-type systems ( Villa et al. 2024a ) or through the air, such as infrared heaters ( Shaw et al. 2019 ) , hot air blowers ( Han et al. 2018 ) , or moving heated air precisely using ultrasound ( Wang and Chen 2023 ; Singhal et al. 2021 ) . This allows users to interact with their hands freely while still receiving thermal sensations. However, these systems require complex hardware setups that cannot easily be moved or scaled to different scenarios and environments. Generally, thermal rendering devices are widespread and simple to control and integrate, but severely restrict mobility, portability, and scalability due to complicated hardware setups