Quality of Helicity-Dependent Magnetization Switching by Phonons

F.G.N. Fennema, C. S. Davies, A. Tsukamoto, A. Kirilyuk · 2025

Read Quality of Helicity-Dependent Magnetization Switching by Phonons by F.G.N. Fennema, C. S. Davies, A. Tsukamoto, A. Kirilyuk (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01480.txt.

Introduction

Flipping a magnet's direction with light promises faster, cheaper data storage, and phonons, quantized vibrations in a crystal, offer one route. F. G. N. Fennema, C. S. Davies, A. Tsukamoto, and A. Kirilyuk study magnetization switching driven by circularly polarized phonons in a sample's substrate. A polarization-modulated transient grating excites those phonons in a controlled pattern.

The polarized phonons induced robust reversal of the magnetic layer, with the direction set by the light's helicity, its spiral sense. At frequencies matching the target phonon modes, switching quality barely changed when the light's ellipticity was varied. Slightly off resonance, by contrast, quality became highly sensitive to ellipticity. The results show when phonon-driven switching is forgiving of imperfect light and when it is not, a practical guide for optical magnetic devices.

Catalog record

CREATORF.G.N. Fennema, C. S. Davies, A. Tsukamoto, A. Kirilyuk
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01480

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quality of Helicity-Dependent Magnetization Switching by Phonons F.G.N. Fennema, C. S. Davies, A. Tsukamoto, A. Kirilyuk Abstract Optical control of magnetization has emerged as a promising approach to achieve ultrafast and energy-efficient magnetization reversal. Here, we investigate helicity-dependent switching of magnetization driven by the resonant excitation of circularly-polarized transverse-optical phonons, using a polarization-modulated transient grating. Our results show that the polarized phonons within the sample substrate induce robust, helicity-defined magnetization reversal in the magnetic overlayer. Moreover, the quality of switching remains largely unaffected when the degree of ellipticity of the infrared excitation is varied at frequencies resonant with the targeted phonon modes. Conversely, as the excitation is moved slightly off-resonance, switching quality becomes highly sensitive to the ellipticity of the incident light. In recent decades, the exponential growth in global data collection has led to pessimistic projections of a three- to four-fold increase in data center energy consumption masanet_recalibrating_2020 . Despite technological advances, 90\% of all data recorded in data centers is still stored on hard drive disks (HDDs) seagate_technology_llc_why_nodate , highlighting the continued dominance of magnetic storage. In HDDs, magnetic bits are written using a spinning disk and a static electromagnet, which together consume several watts. Therefore, identifying more energy-efficient and faster magnetization switching pathways is essential for sustainable data storage. Advances in the research field of ultrafast magnetism have revealed a potentially more efficient switching method than that employed in present-day HDDs, based on the use of ultrashort optical pulses stanciu_all-optical_2007 ; kirilyuk_laser-induced_2013 . This approach allows the magnetization in specific ferrimagnetic alloys to be all-optically toggled by the thermal load delivered by the incident pulse vahaplar_ultrafast_2009 ; radu_transient_2011 ; ostler_ultrafast_2012 ; mentink_ultrafast_2012 ; davies_helicity-independent_2022 . Follow-up experiments showed that this exchange-driven process can become helicity-dependent due to the differential optical absorption introduced by magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) khorsand_role_2012 . Later, a different helicity-dependent all-optical switching (HD-AOS) mechanism was identified in a ferromagnetic multilayer, driven by multiple pulses mangin_engineered_2014 ; lambert_all-optical_2014 . In this mechanism, initial laser pulses create a multidomain state through thermal demagnetization, with subsequent pulses inducing a helicity-dependent temperature gradient via MCD, driving domain wall motion. This domain-wall motion can deterministically result in domain expansion or erasure, leading to the emergence of helicity-dependent switching medapalli_multiscale_2017 ; kichin_multiple-_2019 ; yamada_efficient_2022 . Subsequent research revealed non-thermal approaches for magnetization switching in dielectric iron-garnets. One mechanism involves the excitation of specific electronic states based on the orientation of the optical pump polarization. These excitations selectively lift the degeneracy between magnetization states, inducing magnetic anisotropy that guides perturbed spins to settle into the energetically favored magnetic state stupakiewicz_ultrafast_2017 . More recently, Stupakiewicz et al. demonstrated that switching in these garnets can also be achieved by driving particular optical phonons at resonance stupakiewicz_ultrafast_2021 . This latter mechanism is a promising avenue to achieve both non-thermal and universal means of magnetic switching. However, a key drawback of this effect is that subsequent pulses appear to be unable to restore the magnetization to its original state. Our recent work davies_phononic_2024 presented an alternative approach to magnetization switching via the resonant excitation of circularly polarized transverse-optical (TO) phonons, not within the ferrimagnetic material but rather in the paramagnetic substrate dornes_ultrafast_2019 ; tauchert_polarized_2022 ; juraschek_phono-magnetic_2020 ; juraschek_phono-magnetic_2020 ; basini_terahertz_2024 ; luo_large_2023 . Our measurements revealed that the quality of magnetization reversal in the magnetic overlayer followed the absorption spectra of the sapphire and glass-ceramic substrates. Using a single wavelength-tuned pulse resulted in only demagnetization, while multiple pulses yielded magnetization reversal. This suggests a multi-step process in which the initial magnetization of the magnetic layer must diminish before the circularly polarized optical phonons can successfully drive the switching process. By varying the helicity of the pump light, we can selectively excite left- or right-handed circularly polarized optical phonons, resulting in helicity-defined magnetization reversal. However, key aspects of the underlying mechanism remain unclear. In particular, the degree of circular polarization required to effectively excite the circular phonons at the given wavelength was unknown. Moreover, the achievable wavelengths were constrained to below 21 \mu m by the absorption properties of the CdSe-based quarter-waveplate. In this letter, an optical transient grating was employed to extend the wavelength and polarization range and thus further explore this mechanism. The transient grating offers the possibility to continuously vary the optical polarization across the sample, enabling the study of its influence on switching efficiency and the extension of the wavelength range beyond the quarter-waveplate’s capabilities. In this excitation scheme, two orthogonally-polarized infrared laser pulses intersect at an angle and interfere, generating a spatially-varying polarization with continuous intensity, providing an ideal environment to measure the helicity dependence of the mechanism. Moreover, this scheme is independent of the optical spectrum, allowing for rapid changes in excitation wavelength with limitations arising only from the light source itself. Our results reveal that when the pump wavelength is resonant with a targeted phonon, a high degree of circular polarization is not crucial. Conversely, when the light is slightly off-resonance, a small reduction in circularity significantly diminishes the quality of the switching. The sample used in this investigation consisted of four layers. At the base is a 0.5-mm-thick double-side polished c-cut sapphire substrate commercially obtained from Alineason. Atop this substrate, magnetron sputtering was used to deposit a 10-nm-thick \mathrm{Si}_{3}\mathrm{N}_{4} interlayer, a 20-nm-thick amorphous ferrimagnetic \mathrm{Gd}_{24}\mathrm{Fe}\mathrm{Co} film and a 60-nm-thick \mathrm{Si}_{3}\mathrm{N}_{4} capping layer stanciu_all-optical_2007 ; stanciu_ultrafast_2006 . Infrared (IR) optical pulses from the FELIX facility in Nijmegen, the Netherlands, were used to excite circularly-polarized phonons at resonance. The free-electron laser (FEL) used is widely tunable, offering a wavelength range of 3 to 120\ \mathrm{\textrm{$\mu$}} m and a pulse bandwidth between 0.5 and 2 \% oepts_free-electron-laser_1995 . Due to the use of normal-conducting linacs, the light generated by the FEL is emitted in bursts (”macropulses”) with a typical length between 2 and 10\ \mathrm{\textrm{$\mu$}} s, at a frequency of 10 Hz. Each macropulse consists of shorter pulses (”micropulses”) with energies on the order of 10 \mu J, pulse durations between 0.25 and 7 ps, and a tunable repetition rate between 25 MHz and 1 GHz. To generate the polarization-modulated transient grating, linearly polarized IR pulses from the FEL were split by a pellicle beamsplitter into transmitted and reflected beams. The transmitted beam passed through a polarization rotator knippels_fel_1998 , rotating its polarization by 90 ∘ , and was then focused on the sample via a 3-inch concave mirror with a 150 mm focal length. The reflected beam was sent across a retroreflector mounted on a motorized delay line to equalize the beam paths, and was then focused onto the sample surface by the same concave mirror, forming an angle of 29 ∘ between the overlapping beams. The interference between the two orthogonally polarized light pulses created a spot with spatially varying polarization and continuous intensity janusonis_magnetoelastic_2017 ; davies_towards_2018 , see Fig. 1 a, enabling simultaneous helicity-dependent measurements across the sample. The effect of the IR light on the magnetization of the sample was probed several seconds after optical irradiation using a Faraday microscope equipped with an LE.5211 cold light source, two polarizers, a 20× objective lens, and a Thorlabs Quantalux scientific sCMOS camera. Figure 1: Schematic overview of transient grating. (a) Two light pulses (marked A and B) with orthogonal

Read the complete text