Photon surfaces extensions for dynamical gravitational collapse
Roberto Giambò, Camilla Lucamarini · 2025
Read Photon surfaces extensions for dynamical gravitational collapse by Roberto Giambò, Camilla Lucamarini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01368.txt.
Introduction
A photon surface is a boundary that traps light rays moving along it. Such surfaces shape what distant watchers can see of a collapsing star. Roberto Giambo and Camilla Lucamarini work out the equations for these surfaces. They assume spherical symmetry and use the most general dynamic setting. Their starting point is a known earlier formulation.
The condition for a timelike surface to be a photon surface can be recast in a new way. It becomes a dynamical system. The same condition holds when a light ray moving outward traces the surface. The team then studies a spherical dust cloud in collapse. The marginal case becomes an exact planar system. Its analysis shows a sharp split. The outer surface extends into the cloud in one lightlike way when the central singularity is covered. Timelike options open otherwise.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Roberto Giambò, Camilla Lucamarini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01368
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Photon surfaces extensions for dynamical gravitational collapse Roberto Giambò, Camilla Lucamarini Abstract The equations for the photon surface in spherical symmetry are worked out, starting from Claudel et al. 2001 , in the most general dynamical setting. We show that the condition for a timelike hypersurface to be a photon surface can be reformulated as a non-autonomous dynamical system, whose analysis reveals that the same condition also holds when the surface is generated by a null radial geodesic. As an application, we consider a well-known model of a spherical dust cloud undergoing gravitational collapse. Comparing our findings with those in Cao and Song 2021 , we establish that the photon surface uniquely extends in the interior spacetime as a null hypersurface, allowing us to analytically investigate whether it covers the singularity developing in the LTB model. keywords photon sphere, dust collapse, black hole, naked singularity † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. 1 Introduction Detection of black holes represents a intriguing challenge in the realm of observational astrophysics. The well-known international collaboration Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has utilized a network of radio telescopes across the globe to elaborate an image of the black hole in galaxy M87 Akiyama et al. 2019 ; Akiyama et al. 2024 , often referred to as the black hole shadow. The EHT collaboration has applied analogous methods to investigate other substantial cosmic entities also, notably the SgrA* black hole situated at the Milky Way’s core Akiyama et al. 2022 . It is important to note that the EHT images are not ”direct photographs,” but rather reconstructed radio maps illustrating hot gas in orbit around the black hole, which manifest as a luminous ring. Indeed, despite its name, what EHT aims to capture is not exactly the shape of the event horizon, but rather something that reveals the motion of objects revolving around the black hole, within the observable region to a faraway observer, which can be effectively described, in the simplest toy models, by the so-called photon sphere. Classically, the concept of a photon sphere arises in static and spherically symmetric settings such as the Schwarzschild solution, where it manifests as a timelike hypersurface at radius r=3M on which initially tangent null geodesics remain tangent as they evolve. A similar approach, based on the study of null radial geodesics, has been used in a context of static spacetimes Nolan 2014 ; Hasse and Perlick 2002 ; Chakraborty and Chakraborty 2011 ; Bogush et al. 2023 ; Bogush et al. 2024 ; Sadeghi and Afshar 2024 ; Vertogradov and Övgün 2024 , When it comes to dynamical spacetimes, the situation is more involved. One could think to generalize the above approach to this situation, which actually proves fruitful where the metric assumes a special form - for example, Mishra et al. 2019 ; Solanki and Perlick 2022 ; Vertogradov and Övgün 2024 study the situation for a spherical metric written in Bondi coordinates (v,r,\theta,\phi) , where v is a null coordinate, as is the case for the Vaidya solution. However, this notion has been extended and generalized to a broader geometric object known as the photon surface , formalized in the seminal work by Claudel, Virbhadra, and Ellis Claudel et al. 2001 , where it is defined independently of any specific symmetry or Killing structure. In their framework, photon surfaces are understood as nowhere-spacelike hypersurfaces invariant under the flow of null geodesics that remain confined within the surface. This perspective allows for a more flexible analysis, applicable not only in static spacetimes Virbhadra and Ellis 2002 but also in dynamical regimes where symmetry assumptions are weakened or absent. Subsequent studies, such as those by Cao and Song Cao and Song 2021 , have proposed quasi-local characterizations of photon surfaces in general spherically symmetric spacetimes, aiming to preserve the spirit of Claudel et al.’s geometric definition while adapting it to the complexity of evolving gravitational systems. One physically rich setting in which photon surfaces can be investigated dynamically is gravitational collapse. The Lemaitre–Tolman–Bondi (LTB) models, describing inhomogeneous spherical dust clouds undergoing collapse under their own gravity, provide a valuable laboratory for probing how such surfaces behave in the presence of singularities and horizons. These models allow for analytical control over the metric and matter profiles and, depending on the initial data, can yield either black hole formation or naked singularities, offering insight into the end-state of light rays and causal curves near regions of extreme curvature Joshi 2012 . Recent investigations have demonstrated that shadows and photon spheres, traditionally associated with black holes, can also arise in certain naked singularity spacetimes resulting from gravitational collapse, depending on specific parameters of the model Shaikh et al. 2019 . This challenges the conventional interpretation of shadow observations as definitive evidence for black holes. The central aim of this work is to explore how photon surfaces, originally defined in static contexts, can be meaningfully extended into dynamical spacetimes—specifically, within the LTB collapse model. By deriving and analyzing the governing equations for photon surfaces in the most general spherically symmetric dynamical setting, we assess whether and how these surfaces can be propagated from the exterior Schwarzschild geometry into the interior region occupied by the collapsing matter. In particular, we focus on whether such an extension can effectively cover the singularity forming at the center, depending on the visibility of that singularity. To carry out this investigation, we start by reviewing the photon surface condition for timelike hypersurfaces in spherically symmetric spacetimes, as given in Claudel et al. 2001 , and derive the relevant differential equations that such surfaces must satisfy. We then apply this framework to the LTB model, examining how the photon surface extends across the boundary between interior and exterior spacetimes and determining the precise conditions under which such an extension exists and remains physically meaningful. In this respect, the present paper aims to compare and discuss its findings with those presented in Cao and Song 2021 , trying to highlight some aspects that could be otherwise underestimated, particularly regarding the relation between the photon surface behavior and the appearance of naked singularities. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we recall the geometric setting for photon surfaces in spherically symmetric spacetimes and derive their evolution equations. Section 3 introduces the marginally bound LTB collapse model and discusses how the photon surface condition adapts to this context. We analyze the possible extensions of the photon surface from the Schwarzschild exterior into the collapsing interior, distinguishing between spacelike extensions and those corresponding to null radial geodesics. In Section 4 , we focus on the qualitative behavior of these surfaces, examining their ability to shield the central singularity. We show that the nature of the singularity—naked or covered—dictates whether the photon surface terminates at the regular center or reaches the singularity itself. Finally, Section 5 summarizes the main findings and suggests possible directions for further investigation. 2 Photon surfaces in spherical symmetry It is a well-established fact that Schwarzschild spacetime exhibits r=3m as a hypersurface with the property that initially tangent null geodesics remain tangent, called photon sphere . As we shall see, the paper Claudel et al. 2001 suggests that photon spheres arise as