Gender Differences in Healthcare Utilisation - Evidence from Unexpected Adverse Health Shocks

Nadja van ’t Hoff · 2025

Read Gender Differences in Healthcare Utilisation - Evidence from Unexpected Adverse Health Shocks by Nadja van ’t Hoff (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01310.txt.

Introduction

Women live longer than men but report worse health, a puzzle often blamed on women using more healthcare. Nadja van 't Hoff, Giovanni Mellace, and Seetha Menon challenge that view with causal evidence from Denmark. They use the near-random timing of first non-fatal heart attacks and strokes in administrative records.

After such a shock, men raised their statin use and doctor visits far more than women did. The gap was not about willingness: both sexes filled the same number of prescriptions, but women got lower doses per fill. The gap also grew where doctors had more discretion in prescribing. Despite extra treatment, men did no better on death, illness, or work outcomes, raising the question whether women would fare even better with equal intensity of care.

Catalog record

CREATORNadja van ’t Hoff
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01310

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gender Differences in Healthcare Utilisation - Evidence from Unexpected Adverse Health Shocks Nadja van ’t Hoff Abstract This paper is the first to provide causal evidence of gender differences in healthcare utilisation to better understand the male-female health-survival paradox, where women live longer but experience worse health outcomes. Using rich Danish administrative healthcare data, we apply a staggered difference-in-differences approach that exploits the randomness in treatment timing to estimate the causal impact of adverse health shocks, such as non-fatal heart attacks or strokes, on healthcare use. Our findings suggest that men consistently use more healthcare than women, highlighting the underlying factors driving gender disparities in health outcomes. These insights contribute to the broader discourse on healthcare equity and inform policy interventions aimed at addressing these imbalances. 1 Introduction Women live longer than men by nearly half a decade ( Blaakilde 2012 ) , yet they tend to report worse health than men of the same age, particularly in later life ( Case and Paxson 2005 ; Pedersen et al. 2014 ) . This puzzling contradiction—known as the male-female health-survival paradox—has been well documented but remains only partially understood ( Cutler and Glaeser 2005 ) . This paper investigates whether differences in healthcare utilisation between men and women causally contribute to this paradox. Research consistently shows that men and women differ in their healthcare-seeking behaviours and treatment patterns ( Galdas et al. 2005 ; Juel and Christensen 2007 ; Nobili et al. 2011 ; Oksuzyan et al. 2011 ; Oksuzyan et al. 2008 ; van Loenen et al. 2015 ; Schulman et al. 1999 ) . For instance, men are more likely to receive invasive treatments, while women often face delays or less aggressive care ( Smith et al. 2009 ) . These disparities stem from multiple factors, including inequalities in prevention, diagnosis, treatment, biological differences affecting health outcomes, and the historical exclusion of women from clinical trials, which limits understanding of treatment efficacy in women ( Legato et al. 2016 ) . Even gender concordance between patient and provider has been shown to affect medical evaluations for women but not for men, suggesting that provider discretion may reinforce gender-based disparities ( Cabral and Dillender 2024 ) . However, much of this evidence remains descriptive and, the magnitude and underlying causes of these differences, particularly in response to acute health events, are not well understood. Identifying gender differences in healthcare utilisation is challenging because these differences often coincide with variations in underlying health status and behaviours, making it difficult to disentangle gender from correlated health factors. Moreover, men and women differ in their health-seeking behaviours and reporting of symptoms, introducing selection and measurement biases. To address this gap, we estimate sex-specific responses in healthcare utilisation following severe, unanticipated health shocks—specifically, first-time non-fatal heart attacks or strokes. These events are high-salience sudden shocks, the timing of which is plausibly exogenous for individuals without a prior cardiovascular diagnosis. As conceptualised in Grossman’s model of health demand ( Grossman 1972 ; Grossman 2000 ) , such shocks represent a sudden depreciation of health capital, prompting individuals to invest in healthcare—through doctor visits, medication, and other services—to restore or maintain their health. Economic research has used such shocks to study subjective survival probabilities ( Baji and Bíró 2018 ) , healthcare productivity spillovers ( Chandra and Staiger 2007 ) , returns to local healthcare spending ( Doyle 2011 ) , family labour supply responses ( Fadlon and Nielsen 2021 ) , allocative inefficiency and comparative advantage across hospitals ( Chandra and Staiger 2020 ) , and changes in family health behaviours ( Fadlon and Nielsen 2019 ) . Building on this literature, we compare men and women before and after these shocks, to isolate the causal effect of gender on post-shock healthcare utilisation. Our empirical analysis leverages comprehensive Danish administrative data recording individual-level healthcare utilisation over time, including visits to general practitioners (GPs), prescription drug use, and days hospitalised. We complement these utilisation measures with healthcare expenditure outcomes—specifically, patient out-of-pocket payments for statins and provider fees for GP visits—to assess whether differences in use translate into differences in healthcare expenditure. There are a number of strengths of our research setting. First, the Danish context is particularly well suited for this research due to its universal, free healthcare system, which minimizes confounding from financial barriers or differential insurance coverage. Second, Denmark ranks among the most gender-equal countries globally ( World Bank 2019 ) , limiting the influence of institutionalized gender bias in care delivery. These features enable us to focus on behavioural responses rather than structural constraints. We find a persistent gender gap in post-shock healthcare engagement: men increase their use of healthcare services—particularly GP visits and statin uptake—significantly more than women in the three to five years following a health shock. This difference is robust to differences in survival and shock severity, challenging the assumption that women’s longer lifespans and poorer self-reported health naturally translate to greater health-seeking behaviour. Healthcare expenditure patterns mirror these results: men spend more on statins than women in the five years post-shock, while GP visit fees show no consistent gender difference - suggesting that higher utilisation by men does not mechanically translate into higher healthcare expenditure. These results provide new causal evidence that gender differences in healthcare use are dynamic and may have important implications for long-term health outcomes. We test the robustness of our findings using matched samples, alternative estimators, and multiple definitions of the control group—all of which produce consistent results. To better understand the gender gap in post-shock healthcare use, we examine potential mechanisms and rule out explanations based on survival differences, household composition, or cohort effects. Our results point to both demand- and supply-side drivers: for instance, high-income men increase GP visits more than high-income women, and we find suggestive evidence that women are prescribed statins at lower rates than men. The paper is organised as follows. Section 2 introduces the data and defines key variables. Section 3 outlines the staggered difference-in-differences identification strategy. Section 4 discusses the assumptions underlying the empirical approach. Section 5 presents the main findings. Section 6 explores robustness checks and Section 7 investigates potential mechanisms that may drive these results. Section 8 discusses the broader implications and concludes. 2 Data Measuring underlying health status presents significant methodological challenges, particularly in survey data where measurement error is common. Inaccuracies in measuring healthcare utilization or the timing of health shocks can introduce substantial bias into our estimates. To address these limitations, we use reliable and objective administrative measures of health events and healthcare utilisation, characterised by high completeness and verified accuracy through multiple validation studies ( Schmidt et al. 2015 ; Özcan et al. 2016 ) . Our analysis draws on three comprehensive Danish administrative datasets. The Danish National Patient Register provides longitudinal, individual-level disease diagnosis data. We link this to the Danish Health Insurance database, which captures all visits to healthcare practitioners, and the Danish Prescription Drug database, which records all prescriptions filled at pharmacies nationwide. 2.1 Analytical Sample To leverage the convergence of cardiovascular disease risk between men and women at older ages, we restrict our sample to Danish adults aged 50-70 who experienced their first health shock during 1995-2018 (Section

Read the complete text