An affinity based opinion dynamics model

for the evolving pattern of political polarization · 2025

Read An affinity based opinion dynamics model by for the evolving pattern of political polarization (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01244.txt.

Introduction

Political camps in the United States have drifted apart over a long span. Zhang Xiaoming, Hu Yuzhong, and Zhang Yiming model that drift with opinion dynamics. Such math tracks how views shift through contact. Their model joins an affinity effect, where like-minded members pull together, with a national norm effect. That norm draws all views toward a shared center.

Three forces shape the outcome. The two parties repel each other. Members inside each party both attract and repel. The norm pulls on everyone. The model matches the patterns of spread seen in Congress. It fits one hundred fifty-four years of recorded data. The norm's changing strength also lines up with major events of that era.

Catalog record

CREATORfor the evolving pattern of political polarization
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01244

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An affinity based opinion dynamics model for the evolving pattern of political polarization Abstract Abstract Political polarization has been a subject that has attracted many studies in recent years. We have developed an opinion dynamics model with affective homophily effect and national social norm effect to describe this phenomenon. The time evolution of the polarization between the two parties and the spread of opinions within each party are affected by three factors: the repulsive effect between the two parties, the attractive and repulsive effects between the members in each party, and the national social norm effect that pulls the opinions of all members towards a common norm. The model is internally consistent and is applied to the simulation of the symmetric patterns of polarization and spread of the opinion distributions in the U.S. Congress and the results align well with 154 years of recorded data. The time evolution of the strength of the national social norm effect is obtained and is consistent with the important historical events occurred during the past one and half century. 1 Introduction The political landscape of the United States has become increasingly polarized over the past four decades [ 1 ] . Researchers have suggested that while the polarization is undermining democracy and legislative effectiveness, understanding the phenomenon could ultimately reveal strategies for bridging the divides [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . However, despite past efforts in studying political polarization, most analytical models are fundamentally limited in capturing the interactions among congress members and the historical context. It is therefore appealing for us to raise the following questions: What drives the separation and reunion of ideologies in the U.S. political system? Is there a relationship between partisan polarization and critical historical events? Political polarization arises as the spectrum of public opinion fractures or as differences in perspectives sharpen. Jost et al. [ 5 ] has delineated that affective polarization is characterized by the strong emotional responses, whether positive or negative, that members of different social groups evoke in each other. As an important psychological mechanism that plays a pivotal role in driving polarization, group justification encompasses the collective inclination to promote the benefit of one’s own group while opposing rival groups. Cole et al. [ 6 ] have reviewed the works on political polarization related to climate change issues. They emphasize two types of mechanisms of political polarization: individual-level psychological processes and group-level psychological processes. The former drives the polarization through ideology, personality traits and cognitive styles, and perception of risks, threats, and morality. The latter includes social identities, social norms, and affective polarization. Researchers have been attempting to explain political polarization with agent-based models and data simulations. These models usually adopt a utility maximization approach which assumes that the agents, affected by various types of public influences, selfishly make decisions to maximize their utility. Depending on the problem of interest, these models study the temporal evolution of opinion distribution among all Congress members, either in a discrete or continuous form, by either a deterministic or stochastic process. One common assumption is that the political parties make decisions to maximize their vote counts. Downs [ 7 ] has modeled the competition of two parties for voters, where the voters’ opinions follow an invariant zero-mean Gaussian distribution, and each voter votes for a party to maximize an expected utility. Each party adjusts its opinion position to maximize the expected number of votes it receives. The Downsian model predicts that the two parties should reach a consensus at the median opinion position of all voters. However, this conclusion does not coincide with the reality, as partisan polarization in the U.S. has been a well observed phenomenon. A notable variant of the Downsian model is the satisficing model developed by Yang et al. [ 8 ] . The time evolution of a party’s opinion can be described using two characteristic variables: the party’s opinion as the average opinion of its members and the party’s opinion spread as the standard deviation of its members. Like the Downsian model, the opinion of a party moves in a direction that maximizes the expected number of votes. At the same time, a voter decides which party to vote for by randomly selecting a satisficing party (or abstaining from voting if there is none). Through data validation, the satisficing model captures opinion polarization between the U.S. Democratic and Republican parties since 1961. The model also develops a relationship between partisan polarization and opinion spread and predicts that the opinions of the members of each party are more centralized as the two parties become more polarized, which agrees well with the observed data. However, the work does not provide an explanation on how the polarization is developed and why it exhibits a wavy ideology distribution pattern over the past one and a half century of the U.S. Congress. Recently, Lanzetti et al. [ 9 ] have extended the satisficing model to predict the complete opinion distribution of a party using Wasserstein gradient flows. The model predicts that the opinion distributions of the two parties should become more polarized and homogeneous within each party with time, converging to asymmetric distributions. However, while the extended satisficing model captures the overall tendency of partisan polarization, it does not explain notable exceptions where the opinion distributions change with time in a wavy fashion over the long history of the U.S. Congress. The author indicates that these exceptions are due to impact factors such as historical context, election rounds, and political campaigns without elaborated analysis. Jones et al. [ 10 ] have introduced a new way to define voters’ distribution and utilities, where the voters’ population is composed of two subpopulations with polarized centers. Partisan polarization would exceed subpopulation polarization either when the two subpopulations are homogeneous and polarized or when they are heterogeneous and centralized. Ferri et al. [ 11 ] have introduced a three-state model that borrows ideas from thermodynamics to opinion dynamics. The system is analogized with a thermal bath of a specific temperature, representing social agitation that affects the stochastically evolving dynamics of the system. The result shows that the system converges to a disordered state with polarized opinion clusters when the temperature is high and the neutrality parameter is small, or to a relatively unified state when the opposite is true. This corresponds closely to the relationship between population spread and partisan polarization in [ 10 ] . Opinion dynamics models have been used in studying affective polarization. The interactions of people with close opinions would lead to agreement and positive affection, while interactions of people with distant opinions result in distrust and negative affection [ 4 , 12 ] . Iyengar et al. [ 13 ] have traced affective polarization to the power of partisanship as a social identity. Finkel et al. [ 14 ] have utilized a “feeling thermometer” to measure the out-party hate level and find that it is the strongest in America than in eight other nations. Lu et al. [ 15 ] have studied a dynamic system of the conversion between polarization and cooperation in political interactions. The system has used data from roll-call votes cast in the U.S. Congress and showed a growth of polarization over

Read the complete text