The State of the Art in Visualization Literacy

Matthew Varona 1 , Karen Bonilla 2 , Maryam Hedayati 3 , Alark Joshi 4 , Matthew Kay 3 , Lane Harrison 2 , and Carolina Nobre 1 1 University of Toronto, Canada 2 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, United States 3 Northwestern University, United States 4 University of San Francisco, United States · 2025

Read The State of the Art in Visualization Literacy by Matthew Varona 1 , Karen Bonilla 2 , Maryam Hedayati 3 , Alark Joshi 4 , Matthew Kay 3 , Lane Harrison 2 , and Carolina Nobre 1 1 University of Toronto, Canada 2 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, United States 3 Northwestern University, United States 4 University of San Francisco, United States (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-01018.txt.

Introduction

Matthew Varona leads a team of seven authors on visualization literacy. This field studies the skills needed to engage with charts and graphs. The report surveys the current literature in depth. It aims to give a comprehensive overview of the field. The term itself remains ambiguous across studies, the team notes.

Their taxonomy organizes the field into themes and research categories. Literacy is pinned down by context: domain, scenario, and audience. Skills fall under consumption, construction, critique, and connection. Work is grouped into five categories. They are ontology, assessment, mechanisms, populiteracy, and intervention. For each, key trends and open challenges are named. The report shows how advances in one area inform the others.

Catalog record

CREATORMatthew Varona 1 , Karen Bonilla 2 , Maryam Hedayati 3 , Alark Joshi 4 , Matthew Kay 3 , Lane Harrison 2 , and Carolina Nobre 1 1 University of Toronto, Canada 2 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, United States 3 Northwestern University, United States 4 University of San Francisco, United States
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE96 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-01018

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The State of the Art in Visualization Literacy Matthew Varona 1 , Karen Bonilla 2 , Maryam Hedayati 3 , Alark Joshi 4 , Matthew Kay 3 , Lane Harrison 2 , and Carolina Nobre 1 1 University of Toronto, Canada 2 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, United States 3 Northwestern University, United States 4 University of San Francisco, United States Abstract Research in visualization literacy explores the skills required to engage with visualizations. This state-of-the-art report surveys the current literature in visualization literacy to provide a comprehensive overview of the field. We propose a taxonomy of visualization literacy that organizes the field into competency themes and research categories. To address ambiguity surrounding the term “visualization literacy”, we provide a framework for operationalizing visualization literacy based on application contexts (including domain, scenario, and audience) and relevant competencies, which are categorized under consumption, construction, critique, and connection. Research contributions are organized into five categories: ontology, assessment, mechanisms, populiteracy, and intervention. For each category, we identify key trends, discuss which competencies are addressed, highlight open challenges, and examine how advancements within these areas inform and reinforce each other, driving progress in the field. \copyrightTextTitPag \copyrightTextRunPag † † teaser: A taxonomy of visualization literacy uniting research categories and competency themes . Research categories provide structure to the types of contributions found in our survey corpus of 374 papers. Competency themes broadly describe the skills necessary to engage with visualizations. 1 Introduction While literacy originally referred to the ability to read and write, the metaphor of “literacy” is now often used to describe various groups of related competencies, such as health literacy, media literacy, and information literacy. Among the fields that have adopted the term, it is perhaps visualization literacy that most closely matches early conceptualizations of literacy as reading and writing. Analogous to a shared set of symbols (letters) from which meaning is derived, visualization literacy refers to the ability to meaningfully engage with visual representations of data. Visualization literacy has received increased attention from the visualization research community over the past few years. Driven by the increased ubiquity of visualizations in daily life, researchers have sought to define, model, and measure visualization literacy, investigate factors that influence visualization comprehension, and improve visualization literacy through various interventions [ CHRA∗18 , LKK17 , NZM∗24 , CCB22 , PFLJ22 ] . This increase in research appetite is further demonstrated through workshops at IEEE VIS and ACM CHI [ KHP∗23 , GHC∗24 ] , the recent Dagstuhl Seminar [ BCHH23 ] , and a special issue in IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications [ BHH∗21 ] , which have collectively sought to advance our understanding of visualization literacy and encourage discourse about the topic. Visualization literacy has been studied not only by visualization researchers, but in related disciplines where visual communication of data plays an important role. For example, health risk communication research has investigated the role of individual differences in visualization reading ability on the efficacy of visual aids [ GC17 , GC13 ] . The ability to confidently use visualizations has also been identified by science educators as a gateway for building disciplinary expertise [ DBALI18 ] . These varied contexts of study have given rise to different terms referring to similar phenomena, such as graph literacy [ GG11 ] , graphicacy [ Bal76 ] , and representational competence [ DBALI18 ] . While this survey includes research using a variety of related terms, we use visualization literacy for consistency throughout the report. Accompanying the rise of visualization literacy research are challenges in scoping the field. The use of the literacy metaphor invites varied interpretations, resulting in differences in how visualization literacy is conceptualized, measured, and taught [ GHC∗24 ] . For instance, while visualization literacy is often described as encompassing both reading and creating visualizations [ BBG19 , Sol22 , GHC∗24 ] , assessments in the field have predominantly focused on the reading of visualizations. This narrow focus overlooks other important competencies, such as designing effective visualizations or relating visualizations to the broader contexts in which they are used. Just as the concept of “literacy” has expanded beyond basic reading and writing to be viewed as a gateway to achieving one’s goals, we argue that visualization literacy should be similarly broadened to reflect a fuller range of abilities and purposes. At the same time, clarifying the concept through more precise operationalization —that is, breaking down an abstract idea into well-defined, researchable components—can help resolve some of the current ambiguities and support more coherent development in the field [ AC01 ] . To address these challenges, our State-of-The-Art Report (STAR) synthesizes existing research on visualization literacy and identifies key opportunities for future work. Our contributions are as follows: • We organize existing work into a taxonomy of visualization literacy, providing an overview of concepts and techniques across five categories of research. (Section 5 ) • We provide a framework of relevant competencies, derived from the analysis of prior work, that enables more precise operationalizations of visualization literacy. (Section 3 ) • For each category, we summarize unsolved questions, highlight research implications for other categories, and explore opportunities for future work. Our systematic review of visualization literacy research reveals several key insights about the field’s current state and future directions. The field has made substantial progress in developing assessments of visualization skills and creating effective interventions for teaching visualization literacy. At the same time, our analysis reveals opportunities for growth - while some aspects of visualization literacy, such as the ability to read a visualization, are well-studied, others, like the ability to critique, receive less attention. Finally, while research has successfully characterized visualization literacy in several specific populations and contexts, significant gaps remain, particularly regarding non-Western contexts and accessibility considerations. These findings suggest important opportunities for expanding both the theoretical framework and practical applications of visualization literacy research. 2 Related Surveys This STAR is meant to provide a comprehensive and current overview of visualization literacy research. We found two prior surveys related to visualization literacy [ FJL22a , Sol22 ] , as well as a set of related papers that provide partial overviews of the field [ BBG19 , HHK24 , CHRA∗18 ] . While they tend to be narrower in scope than our STAR, they provide valuable insight into specific aspects of visualization literacy. Firat et al. [ FJL22a ] conducted a survey of 34 papers that studied users’ visualization literacy. With a focus on evaluative approaches, they categorized papers based on different types of evaluations (crowdsourcing, classroom-based, controlled user study, or “in the wild”). Similarly, Solen’s survey of visualization literacy [ Sol22 ] analyzed 20 papers and proposed three research themes, namely interpretation, construction, and believability. In order to address gaps in existing surveys, this STAR 1) employs a wider scope by reviewing 4,519 papers (374 in the final set), 2) encompasses a broader range of visualization literacy research, including papers from outside “traditional” visualization venues, 3) examines and categorizes diverse types of contributions in visualization literacy, including non-evaluative research such as interventions or theoretical models, and 4) provides a deeper exploration of visualization competencies and how they cut across various categories of research. 3 Methodology Figure 1: The 4-stage methodology followed to acquire and tag

Read the complete text