Recurrent visitations expose the paradox of human mobility in the 15-Minute City vision

Xiuning Zhang, Alexei Poliakov, Henrikki Tenkanen, Elsa Arcaute · 2025

Read Recurrent visitations expose the paradox of human mobility in the 15-Minute City vision by Xiuning Zhang, Alexei Poliakov, Henrikki Tenkanen, Elsa Arcaute (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00919.txt.

Introduction

Xiuning Zhang, with three co-authors, Alexei Poliakov, Henrikki Tenkanen, and Elsa Arcaute, tests the 15-Minute City vision, a planning idea that daily needs should lie within a fifteen minute reach. The vision assumes local amenity provision translates into local use, yet behavioral evidence on recurrent visitation remains limited.

Their K-Visitation framework compares recurrent destinations with nearest options for each person, using eighteen months of mobile phone data from hundreds of thousands of users in Finland. People repeatedly bypass nearby options that already cover needed amenity categories, incurring measurable travel time costs. Divergence is sharpest in amenity-rich urban cores. Routine anchors follow proximity more closely, while specialized functions depend on wider catchments and connectivity.

Catalog record

CREATORXiuning Zhang, Alexei Poliakov, Henrikki Tenkanen, Elsa Arcaute
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00919

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Recurrent visitations expose the paradox of human mobility in the 15-Minute City vision Xiuning Zhang, Alexei Poliakov, Henrikki Tenkanen, Elsa Arcaute Abstract In the transition towards sustainability and equity, proximity-centred planning has been adopted in cities worldwide. Exemplified by the 15-Minute City, this emerging planning paradigm assumes that spatially proximate provision translates into localised use, yet evidence on actual behaviour remains limited. We advance a behaviourally grounded assessment by introducing the K-Visitation framework, which identifies the minimal set of distinct visited places needed to cover essential amenities under two orderings: one based observed visitation frequency ( K freq K_{\text{freq}} ) and the other based on proximity to home ( K dist K_{\text{dist}} ). Applying it to a 18-month, anonymised mobility data from Finland, we directly compare local mobility potentials with habitual destination choices. We find systematic misalignment between proximity and behaviour, and this is most pronounced in metropolitan cores–areas traditionally viewed as ideal settings for local living–where residents voluntarily overshoot nearby options, while peripheral routines remain more locally constrained. The misalignment further revealed uneven amenity type influences, as distance differentials increase from everyday to specialised amenity. Furthermore, the social consequences of localism are spatially contingent: increased reliance on local options reduces experienced segregation in central districts but can exacerbate it elsewhere. The results stress that proximity is therefore necessary but insufficient for achieving the proximity living ideal; implementation should be behaviourally informed and place-sensitive, coupling abundant local provision of routine needs with access enhancement to specialised amenities to avoid unintended equity trade-offs. Introduction Cities are navigating intertwined challenges–from the imperative to achieve net-zero emissions to the socio-economic aftershocks of the pandemic. In response, cities are pivoting away from car-centric development towards more sustainable, inclusive, and locally oriented models of urban life. Among the ideas gaining momentum, the 15-Minute City (15mC) has emerged as a prominent framework: residents should be able to access essential services, such as groceries, schools, healthcare, and everyday services, all within a 15-minute walk or cycle from home [ 1 , 2 ] . Rooted in longer traditions of mixed-use, human-scale neighbourhoods [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] , the 15mC has achieved wide policy uptake and international diffusion [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . A substantial body of mobility science documents empirical local regularities in human travel: individuals’ repeated visitations follow distance-frequency trade-offs and scale-free patterns, which are shaped by hierarchical containers [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . These regularities underscore the salience of local mobility anchors in everyday life and offer prima facie support for proximity-centred planning. Nevertheless, a universal fixation on temporal thresholds (e.g., 15 minutes) risks obscuring the social and spatial heterogeneity that shapes realised mobility. Disparities in infrastructure and walkability [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] , differences in travel abilities and temporal constraints [ 16 ] , and heterogeneous preferences over amenity [ 17 ] jointly influence where people actually go. These dimensions are interdependent: for instance, high-quality networks amplify the returns to amenity diversity, while capability constraints and time budgets condition the benefits of proximity [ 16 ] . Moreover, critics caution that translating the 15mC into a universal agenda may underplay agglomeration benefits, thereby risking decentralisation targets that are neither productive nor realistic in all settings [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Consequently, a central conceptual and measurement challenge arises. Contemporary 15mC assessments rely heavily on potential accessibility–the most prominent approach being isochrones and multimodal catchment areas that indicate what could be reached under prevailing transport conditions [ 20 ] . While essential for goal-setting, such supply-side measures abstract from habit, preference, and trip chaining that structure realised travel behaviour in daily life. Against this backdrop, longitudinal, passively sensed mobility traces enable observation of habitual itineraries at scale, making it possible to compare proximate opportunities with recurrent destination choices directly [ 21 , 22 ] . Early applications suggest that behaviour often departs from isochrone-based expectations [ 23 , 24 ] , but a systematic, scalable framework for diagnosing when—and for whom—proximity translates into local use remains underdeveloped. This paper addresses this gap by advancing a behaviourally grounded assessment of proximity-based living. Leveraging large-scale human mobility traces–linked to detailed amenity and socioeconomic context–we leveraged behavioural data to enable direct comparison between local mobility potentials and recurrent destination choices [ 23 , 25 ] . Specifically, we ask: to what extent do individuals’ recurrent visitations align with those implied by proximity to home; how does this alignment vary across urban cores and peripheries and across socioeconomic groups; and what are the implications of any misalignment for the feasibility and equity of 15mC interventions? We introduce the K-Visitation framework, which quantifies the minimal number of visitations, K , required for an individual to satisfy all essential amenity exposure. This framework operates under two orderings: (i) K-Frequency , in which visitations are selected by empirical visitation frequency, characterising their recurrent behaviour, and (ii) K-Distance , in which visitations are selected by proximity to home, representing their proximate baseline scenario. We compare these two operational variants to obtain the alignment between recurrent and local mobility. Our empirical setting is Finland, a European country known with high walkability and public transport provision [ 26 , 27 ] . Drawing on 18 months of anonymised mobile phone location data from approximately 1.8 million users, three headline findings emerge. First, city centres and larger metropolitan areas exhibit a misalignment between recurrent and proximate mobility, revealing a paradox of surplus whereby residents voluntarily overshoot nearby options. Furthermore, by investigating this surplus with amenity types, we revealed inherent disproportionated amenity visitations. Lastly, the social benefits of “living locally” are spatially contingent: only central residents gain most heterogeneous encounters from increased local usage, whereas localism elsewhere exacerbates existing segregation. Together, these findings demonstrate that radical transformations towards solely local provision may not guarantee realised local mobility and can in fact exacerbate existing social inequality. They underscore that the 15mC’s one-size-fits-all emphasis on proximity as a universal development target overlooks the spatial, social and behavioural complexities that shape realised accessibility beyond immediate neighbourhoods. Moreover, our behaviourally-based analysis reveals a clear amenity hierarchy–highlighting that certain categories (e.g.,dining, transport, groceries) exert disproportionate influence on local mobility destinations–which could support planners and policymakers to tailor interventions within local contexts. Results K-Visitation framework. To evaluate how closely individual mobility aligns with the 15mC principle, we introduce the K-Visitation framework. For each user, it identifies the smallest set of distinct visitations that together provide exposure to at least one point of interest (POI) from each of the daily amenity categories (see "Stay location and visitation data" in Methods). Places are operationalised as H3 level-10 cells, and the user’s home cell is excluded from the candidate set. This framework offers a behaviourally grounded proxy for comparing recurrent mobility with its proximity counterfactual. Recurrent mobility and its proximity counterfactual. We characterise recurrent mobility behaviour by ordering users’ visitations according to empirical visitation frequency. This is achieved by applying a greed search algorithm, accumulating places until all amenity categories are covered. The resulting count is denoted K_{\text{freq}} and reflects habit-seeking patterns. As a proximity-based counterfactual, we re-run the same greedy selection after ordering places by increasing distance from

Read the complete text