Simulation study of neutral tungsten emissions for fusion applications
Ritu Dey sup1,#, Ayushi Agrawal sup2,#, Reetesh Kumar Gangwar sup1, Deepti Sharma sup3, Rajesh Srivastava sup2, Malay B. Chowdhuri sup3, Joydeep Ghosh sup3,4 · 2025
Read Simulation study of neutral tungsten emissions for fusion applications by Ritu Dey sup1,#, Ayushi Agrawal sup2,#, Reetesh Kumar Gangwar sup1, Deepti Sharma sup3, Rajesh Srivastava sup2, Malay B. Chowdhuri sup3, Joydeep Ghosh sup3,4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00878.txt.
Introduction
Ritu Dey leads a team of seven authors on tungsten emissions for fusion use. Tungsten is used in tokamak walls, the walls of fusion devices. Its spectral lines help diagnose the plasma inside. The study is a simulation study of neutral tungsten. It reports electron-impact excitation data for that species.
The team computes cross-sections and rate coefficients for three transitions. The wavelengths of the transitions are listed in the record. They use the relativistic distorted wave approach in the flexible atomic code. Energy levels in the code were corrected against the NIST database. Cross-sections cover incident electron energies up to a high stated value. Some of these lines are also observed in tokamak plasma. The rate coefficients are provided for fusion applications.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ritu Dey sup1,#, Ayushi Agrawal sup2,#, Reetesh Kumar Gangwar sup1, Deepti Sharma sup3, Rajesh Srivastava sup2, Malay B. Chowdhuri sup3, Joydeep Ghosh sup3,4 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 14 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00878
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simulation study of neutral tungsten emissions for fusion applications Ritu Dey sup1,#, Ayushi Agrawal sup2,#, Reetesh Kumar Gangwar sup1, Deepti Sharma sup3, Rajesh Srivastava sup2, Malay B. Chowdhuri sup3, Joydeep Ghosh sup3,4 Abstract The article reports electron-impact excitation cross-sections and rate coefficients for neutral tungsten for three transitions (400.87 nm, 429.46 nm, and 430.21 nm) using the relativistic distorted wave approach within the flexible atomic code. Some of these lines are also observed in tokamak plasma. Cross-sections are computed for incident electron energy up to 30 keV. The energy levels in flexible atomic code were corrected to match the NIST database. The electron impact excitation rate coefficients are also provided. # Contributed equally 1 Introduction Tungsten is a highly valuable material for magnetic confinement devices due to its low tritium retention, low erosion rate, and high melting point. These properties make it an ideal choice for critical components in fusion reactors. As a result, tungsten is used in the construction of the ITER first wall and divertor plates [1] to handle the high heat fluxes. Similarly, the upgrade version of EAST is used a ITER-like tungsten monoblock divertor configuration [2,3]. Moreover, WEST is a superconducting, actively cooled, full tungsten (W) tokamak [4]. Previously, there were many studies involving erosion due to tungsten [5]. For example, in the divertor of the ASDEX-Upgrade tokamak, erosion properties are investigated by observing the WI emission line at 400.9 nm [5]. It is found that the sputtering yield is in the order of 10 -4 atoms/ion for typical divertor plasma conditions. JET was used tungsten on the divertors [6] to handle the wall materials issues that are critical for the fusion devices. The usage of tungsten material makes it abundant in fusion devices, and it presents as an impurity material. Due to a large radial variation of electron temperature in tokamak devices, various charged states of tungsten along with the neutral can exist inside the tokamak. Over the years, spectroscopic investigations/diagnostics have been carried out to study the W emissions [7] to determine the erosion rate. Various theoretical approaches are used to calculate the energy levels, radiative transition probabilities, and ionization/excitation cross sections, which support the spectroscopic diagnostics results. The various approaches applied worldwide for the above purpose are relativistic distorted wave approximation (RDW) [8], relativistic Hartree-Fock method [9], multi-configuration Dirac-Fock method (MCDF) [10], binary encounter Bethe Model [11], etc. The well-known codes in which these methods are implemented to calculate various atomic structures are Cowan [12,13], flexible atomic code (FAC) [14], DARC [15], GRASP [16], MDFGME [17]. Very recently, Duck-Hee Kwon and Paul Indelicato [18] reported MCDF calculations to obtain radiative electron-impact transition rates for neutral tungsten. They have reported electron impact excitation rate-coefficients for visible transition wavelengths of neutral W of 400.87 nm, 488.69 nm, 498.26 nm, and 522.47 nm for incident electron energy up to 30 eV. They found that the accuracies for electron impact excitation (EIE) cross-sections are challenging, and more experimental and theoretical investigations are necessary to evaluate the neutral W emissions. To address this issue, in the present manuscript, the electron impact excitation cross sections are calculated by using the relativistic distorted wave approximation within the FAC [14] code for the neutral W atom. It is to be noted that these WI emission lines are observed in laser induced breakdown spectrsocopy (LIBS) experiments [19]. To the best of our knowledge, the results reported here are presented for the first time, except for those at the 400.87 nm wavelength. Furthermore, the cross-sections are averaged over electron energy space to obtain the Maxwellian-averaged EIE rate coefficients. The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 describes the brief theory for calculating the cross-section and rate coefficients within the RDW approximation. Section 3 contains the results. A concluding remark is given in section 4. 2 Theory Flexible atomic code (FAC) [14] Version 1.1.5 is used to simulate the EIE cross-sections. The radial wavefunctions for single-electron orbitals are obtained with a self-consistent field method based on the Dirac equations. The Dirac–Coulomb Hamiltonian is diagonalized to obtain energy levels and atomic state wavefunctions. This code is used the RDW approximation to determine the collision strength for EIE process for neutral W. The collision strength ( \Omega_{01} ) is expressed as, \displaystyle\Omega_{01}=2\sum_{k}\sum_{{\alpha_{0}\alpha_{1}\beta_{0}\beta_{1}}}Q^{k}(\alpha_{0}\alpha_{1};\beta_{0}\beta_{1}) (1) \displaystyle\langle\Psi_{0}||Z^{k}(\alpha_{0},\alpha_{1})||\Psi_{1}\rangle\langle\Psi_{0}||Z^{k}(\beta_{0},\beta_{1})||\Psi_{1}\rangle, where, \displaystyle Q^{k}(\alpha_{0}\alpha_{1};\beta_{0}\beta_{1})=\sum_{\kappa_{0},\kappa_{1}}[k]^{-1}P^{k}(\kappa_{0}\kappa_{1};\alpha_{0}\alpha_{1}) (2) \displaystyle P^{k}(\kappa_{0}\kappa_{1};\beta_{0}\beta_{1}). \kappa_{0} , \kappa_{1} are the relativistic angular quantum numbers of the incident and the scattered electrons, respectively. \Psi_{0} and \Psi_{1} are the wave-functions of the initial and final state, respectively. Z^{k} ( \alpha_{0} , \alpha_{1} ), Z k ( \beta_{0} , \beta_{1} ) are the tensor operators. \alpha_{0} , \alpha_{1} , \beta_{0} and \beta_{1} are the orbitals of the electron. The radial integral Q^{k} (\alpha_{0}\alpha_{1};\beta_{0}\beta_{1}) contains (P k ) which is expressed as: \displaystyle P^{k}(\kappa_{0}\kappa_{1};\alpha_{0}\alpha_{1}) \displaystyle=X^{k}(\alpha_{0}\kappa_{0};\alpha_{1}\kappa_{1})+\sum_{t}(-1)^{k+t}[k] \displaystyle\quad\times\begin{Bmatrix}J_{\alpha_{0}}&J_{1}&t\\ j_{0}&j_{\alpha_{1}}&k\end{Bmatrix}X^{t}(\alpha_{0}\kappa_{0};\kappa_{1}\alpha_{1}). (3) X^{k} is the two electron Slater integral and k is the multipolarity. The total EIE cross-section is expressed in terms of collision strength as (in atomic unit) follows: \displaystyle\sigma_{01}=\frac{\pi}{k_{0}^{2}g_{0}}\Omega_{01}. (4) Because the RDW theory is perturbative, its accuracy near threshold energies is limited. Therefore, low-energy corrections up to approximately two to three times the excitation threshold are required. The corrected cross section, expressed as a function of the projectile electron energy, is given below [20]. \displaystyle\sigma_{01[corrected]}=[1-(E_{threshold}/E)^{3}]\sigma_{01}, (5) where E is the electron energy and E threshold is the threshold energy for the excitation. The similar equation is applied to find out the electron impact excitation cross-sections and rate coefficients using fully relativistic distorted wave approach of cesium atom [21]. The electron-impact excitation cross-sections is averaged over the Maxwellian electron energy space and then the rate coefficient is expressed as: R_{ij}=2\sqrt{\left(\frac{1}{\pi m_{e}}\right)}(K_{B}T_{e})^{-3/2}\int_{{\epsilon}}^{\infty}E\sigma_{ij}(E)exp\left(-\frac{E}{K_{B}T_{e}}\right)dE, (6) where, K_{B} is the Boltzmann coefficient and m e , T e are the mass and temperature of the electron, respectively. \epsilon is the threshold energy for the particular transition. 3 Results and Discussion In the present work, FAC is parallelized and executed using 32 CPU cores on ANTYA, an IPR LINUX cluster, to calculate the EIE cross-sections and rate coefficients. It is worth mentioning that the cross-sections and rate coefficients calculated for the particular transitions in the visible range, which are often measured in plasma diagnostics [4, 6], are found in various tokamaks. It is also observed by the LIBS experiment [19]. Neutral tungsten atom which has a total of 74 electrons and the ground state configuration is [Xe]4f^{14} 5d^{4}6s^{2} ( {}^{5}D_{0} ). The atomic structure of neutral tungsten (W I) contains partially filled 5d subshells and due to this the complexity arises in theoretical modelling to investigate the fine-structure spectrum. Table 1 presents the configurations and excitation energies of the neutral W in lower and upper states from the NIST database [22]. A total of 1754 fine-structure-resolved energy levels are considered, corresponding to the excited level configurations. The energy levels from FAC are corrected to match with the energy values from NIST. Figure 1 displays the collison strength for the above three transitions listed in Table 1. The configurations that are taken for the present calculations are as follows: 5d 4 6s 2 , 5d 5 6[s,p], 5d 4 6s6[p,d], 5d 4 6s7[s,p] and 5d 6 . It is noticed that all three transitions are dipole allowed transitions and the transition probabilities are