Origins of the Ising model
Mário J. de Oliveira · 2025
Read Origins of the Ising model by Mário J. de Oliveira (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00632.txt.
Introduction
Mario J de Oliveira, writing alone, traces the origins of the Ising model. The Ising model is a landmark model of ferromagnetism. That is the permanent magnetism of materials like iron. Wilhelm Lenz proposed the model in 1920. Ernest Ising then analyzed it in a paper from 1925. Its units take only two states each. Each unit interacts only with its neighbors.
Ising found no ordered magnetic state in a linear chain. That result was correct but frustrating at the time. Rudolf Peierls later showed that order does arise in two dimensions. It thus arises in three dimensions as well. Two spare ingredients explain the model's lasting success. They are the two states and the short-range interaction. The account covers the model's birth up to 1936.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mário J. de Oliveira |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00632
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Origins of the Ising model Mário J. de Oliveira Abstract In 1925, Ernest Ising published a paper analyzing a model proposed in 1920 by Wilhelm Lenz for ferromagnetism. The model is composed of constituent units that take only two states and interact only when they are neighbors. Ising showed that in a linear chain the model does not present an ordered ferromagnetic state, a frustrating but correct result. However, Rudolf Peierls demonstrated in 1936 that the model does in fact present an ordered state in two dimensions, and therefore in three dimensions. This result reveals that short-range interaction and only two states for each constituent unit are sufficient for ordering to occur over long distances. These two elements are the key to understanding the success of the model and its variants even a hundred years after its appearance. Here we analyze the emergence of the model in the period up to 1936. I Introduction The Ising model domb1960 ; brout1965 ; brush1967 ; ziman1972 ; salinas1997 ; niss2005 was conceived by Wilhelm Lenz in 1920 lenz1920 and proposed to his student Ernst Ising as a model for ferromagnetism. It was analyzed by Ising in his doctoral thesis entitled Contribution to the Theory of Ferromagnetism , defended at the University of Hamburg. The results of the thesis were published the following year in a paper of 1925 ising1925 . Although it is not a model for every type of ferromagnetism, the model is reasonably appropriate for the ferromagnetism of spin-half anisotropic magnetic systems domb1964 . The Ising model consists of interacting dipoles residing on the sites of a lattice. The basic ingredients of the model, which result in ferromagnetism, are the interaction only between neighboring dipoles and only two states for each dipole. However, these two ingredients are not inherent to magnetic systems and can therefore be used in models to describe the ordering of systems of other natures, such as the ordering in metallic alloys. More generally, the model is capable of explaining and describing the cooperative state of systems composed of interacting elements domb1960 . Ising solved the one-dimensional model in the presence of a magnetic field. The results showed that the magnetization vanishes when the field vanishes, leading Ising to correctly conclude that the one-dimensional model does not describe the ferromagnetic state. He further argued that the three-dimensional model would not exhibit the ferromagnetic state, a frustrating result given the purpose of the model. However, Herzfeld in 1925 herzfeld1925 referring to Ising paper stated that the result in three dimensions would need to be proven. Lenz motivation lies in Pierre Weiss theory of ferromagnetism, published in 1907 weiss1907 . In his exposition of the theory, Weiss shows that the interaction between elementary magnetic dipoles cannot be magnetic in nature, a result also commented on by Lenz. The interaction does indeed have a quantum origin and was incorporated into the model for ferromagnetism introduced by Heisenberg in a paper of 1928 heisenberg1928 . In this papaer, Heisenberg comments on Ising result regarding the absence of ferromagnetism in a chain, and, in a letter to Pauli dated 1928, he suggested that if Ising had used a sufficient number of near neighbors, he would have obtained ferromagnetism niss2005 . In a lecture on magnetism delivered at the 1930 Solvay conference, published in 1932 pauli1932 , Pauli used Heisenberg theory in conjunction with Weiss molecular field to obtain the ferromagnetic state. Pauli also obtains magnetization at low temperatures and comments that the three-dimensionality of the crystal lattice is essential for the emergence of ferromagnetism. He mentions the Ising result on the absence of ferromagnetism in a chain but states that this also occurs with quantum models. He adds that it is very likely that an extension of Ising theory to the case of a three-dimensional lattice would produce ferromagnetism. In his book of 1932 vanvleck1932 on the theory of electric and magnetic susceptibilities, van Vleck discusses Heisenberg theory of ferromagnetism. He shows how to adapt Weiss molecular field theory to obtain the ferromagnetic state and the critical temperature of Heisenberg model. He claims that Ising results on the absence of ferromagnetism are in apparent contradiction with his own, justifying that this is supposedly due to Ising use of a coupling between elementary magnetic dipoles as being the product of two scalars rather than the scalar product of two vectors. With the introduction of the Heisenberg model, considered more appropriate for describing ferromagnetism, we should have expected the Ising model to be forgotten brush1967 ; niss2005 . However, the model reappeared as models for the ordering of alloys and for the adsorption of gases on solid surfaces. Gorsky in 1928 gorsky1928 , Bragg and Williams in 1934 bragg1934 ; bragg1935 , and Bethe in 1935 bethe1935 analyzed models for ordering in alloys that are equivalent to the Ising model, although Ising is not cited. Bethe paper is particularly interesting for two reasons. One is his concern to show that the model he analyzes does not support ordering in one dimension but does have ordering in two dimensions. The other is the use of an approximate method that becomes exact in one dimension. The model analyzed by Ising was cited by Fowler in his paper of 1935 on the adsorption of gases on solid surfaces fowler1936 . Fowler comments that the problem he analyzes was solved exactly by Ising in a linear chain but not in two or more dimensions. A method equivalent to Bethe was used by Peierls in 1936 peierls1936a to analyze the Fowler model for adsorption. In another paper of 1936 peierls1936 , Peierls acknowledges that the models analyzed by Bragg and Williams, Fowler, and Bethe are equivalent to the model analyzed by Ising. In this paper, whose title contains the term ’Ising’s model’, Peierls demonstrates that in two dimensions the Ising model does indeed exhibit the ordered state at sufficiently low temperatures. Peierls argument leads us to the conclusion that the ordered state also occurs in three-dimensional models. With the recognition that the Ising model is equivalent to models of ordering in alloys, it came to be understood as a model for cooperative phenomena niss2005 . In this sense, the model was studied by Kramers and Wannier in 1941 kramers1941 as a model of statistical mechanics. In this paper, they showed that the partition function, and therefore the free energy, is related to the largest eigenvalue of a certain matrix. Furthermore, they managed to determine the exact value of the critical temperature in the square lattice through a symmetry relation between high and low temperatures. The calculation of the free energy of the two-dimensional model in the absence of a field was performed by Onsager and published in 1944 onsager1944 . The calculation showed that the free energy f as a function of temperature has a singularity at the critical temperature of the type f-f_{0}\sim\varepsilon\ln|\varepsilon| where \varepsilon is the deviation of the temperature from its critical value. From this result, the following singular behavior is obtained for the specific heat c\sim\ln|\varepsilon| . As for magnetization, it cannot be determined from the free energy at zero field. However, it can be obtained from correlations, a method used by Yang yang1952 in