An Unfinished Collaboration with A. A. Starobinsky

Thibault Damour \orcidID 0000-0003-4519-6265 · 2025

Read An Unfinished Collaboration with A. A. Starobinsky by Thibault Damour \orcidID 0000-0003-4519-6265 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00558.txt.

Introduction

Thibault Damour, writing alone, sums up joint work begun in 2008 with A A Starobinsky. The work was never finished. The pair tried to apply the stochastic approach to quantum gravity. That approach treats long-wave quantum effects as random noise. They focused on infrared effects, meaning effects at very large scales. The setting was an inflationary space-time, an early universe that expands fast. Damour presents the results reached in those first stages. The text preserves ideas from a project that stopped early.

Catalog record

CREATORThibault Damour \orcidID 0000-0003-4519-6265
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00558

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An Unfinished Collaboration with A. A. Starobinsky Thibault Damour \orcidID 0000-0003-4519-6265 Abstract The present text summarizes some of the results obtained in 2008 during the initial stages of a collaboration with Starobinsky which remained unfinished. The collaboration was an attempt to apply the stochastic approach to infrared (IR) quantum-gravity effects in an inflationary spacetime. 1 Introduction My dear friend Alexei Alexander Starobinsky (henceforth Alyosha) visited the Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques (IHES) in October 2008. During this visit, we started a collaboration on the impact of infrared quantum gravity effects on the global structure of de Sitter (or inflationary) spacetimes. I had always hoped that Alyosha would come back at IHES to allow us to continue our discussions, and to hopefully finalize the preliminary results we had reached in October 2008. Alas this did not happen. Though I had the pleasure of meeting again Alyosha in person during some later visits of mine in Moscow (notably during the 2019 conference dedicated to the 100th anniversary of Khalatnikov), and though Alyosha kindly agreed to speak (remotely) during the 2021 “Damour Fest” at IHES, we were both dragged away from our collaborative project by other scientific pursuits, and we never finalized our collaboration. As an homage to him, and as a token of my admiration for all the deep and beautiful ideas he contributed to physics, the present text will present the gist of our discussions, as they were left at the time (together with some additional considerations on Brownian motion in the space of 3-by-3 matrices). Hopefully, the approach we pursued (crucially based on Alyosha’s stochastic approach to inflation) has still some value, in spite of the many developments that have since happened (and are still happening) in the study of infrared effects in de Sitter spacetimes. Before entering into details, let me mention that the stochastic approach to inflation is the idea, pioneered in Ref. Starobinsky:1982ee (see also Vilenkin:1983xq ; Linde:1986fd , as well as Starobinsky:1986fx ; Starobinsky:1994bd ), that the infrared part of a quantum fluctuating field during inflation may be considered as a classical (i.e., c -number) space-dependent stochastic field satisfying a local (i.e., without spatial derivatives) evolution equation where the classical evolution is completed by an additional Langevin-like fluctuating term (coming from the higher-frequency quantum fluctuations). For recent reviews of the stochastic approach to inflation see Ref. Cruces:2022imf ; Woodard:2025cez . For entries into the still growing literature on infrared effects in de Sitter (or inflationary) spacetimes, see Polyakov:2012uc ; Anderson:2017hts ; Akhmedov:2019cfd ; Akhmedov:2019esv ; Cohen:2020php ; Miao:2024shs ; Woodard:2025smz . The last two references, of which I became aware while writing the present account, have close links with the aim of my unfinished collaboration with Alyosha. I leave to the future to decide whether they make it irrelevant by superseding it. 2 First starting point The first starting point of our discussions was the following classic result of Alyosha. In 1983, Alyosha derived the asymptotic structure, at large times, of the general solution of Einstein’s equations in presence of a (positive) cosmological constant \Lambda=3H^{2} Starobinsky:1982mr (in 3+1 dimensions, and when neglecting other types of stress-energy tensor), namely (in synchronous gauge) ds^{2}=-dt^{2}+e^{2Ht}\hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t)dx^{i}dx^{j}\,, (1) where the rescaled spatial metric \hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t) admits an expansion in powers of e^{-Ht} of the form \hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t)=a_{ij}({\bf x})+b_{ij}({\bf x})e^{-2Ht}+c_{ij}({\bf x})e^{-3Ht}+\cdots\,. (2) One can further impose the unimodularity condition \det a_{ij}({\bf x})=1 . The latter expanded solution 1 1 1 In an anti-de-Sitter context, it would be called a Fefferman-Graham expansion. is general in that it contains four physical arbitrary functions of three variables: there are two arbitrary functions in the unimodular spatial metric a_{ij}({\bf x}) (considered modulo 3-diffeomorphisms); the function b_{ij}({\bf x}) is determined by the Ricci tensor of a_{ij}({\bf x}) (namely H^{2}b_{ij}({\bf x})=R_{ij}[a]-\frac{1}{4}R[a]a_{ij} ); and the other two arbitrary functions of three variables are contained in c_{ij}({\bf x}) (which must satisfy c_{i}^{i}=0 and \nabla^{j}c_{ij}=0 ). [The latter constraints use a_{ij}({\bf x}) as background metric.] Terms beyond c_{ij}({\bf x}) in the expansion ( 2 ) are fully determined by a_{ij}({\bf x}) and c_{ij}({\bf x}) . The expansion ( 2 ) is valid in many spatial coordinate systems. E.g., one recovers the global de Sitter metric with \hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t)dx^{i}dx^{j}=H^{-2}e^{-2Ht}\cosh^{2}Htd\Omega_{3}^{2} (where d\Omega_{3}^{2} is a round 3-sphere metric), which leads to a_{ij}({\bf x})dx^{i}dx^{j}=\frac{1}{4}H^{-2}d\Omega_{3}^{2} and b_{ij}({\bf x})=2a_{ij}({\bf x}) . Alternatively, the Poincaré-patch case corresponds to a_{ij}({\bf x})=\delta_{ij} and b_{ij}({\bf x})=0 . The crucial point here is that though this general solution exhibits a phenomenon of local isotropization, dubbed the cosmic no-hair behavior (with an exponentially vanishing Weyl tensor, C_{\mu\nu\kappa\lambda}C^{\mu\nu\kappa\lambda}\propto e^{-6Ht} ), its global spatial geometry is conformal, at large times, to an arbitrary (unimodular) 3-metric a_{ij}({\bf x})=\lim_{t\to\infty}\hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t) . The conformal spatial geometry defined by a_{ij}({\bf x}) is globally inhomogeneous and anisotropic. It can be arbitrarily different from the round sphere obtained for a global de Sitter spacetime. On the other hand, it is time-independent. 3 Second starting point As just reviewed, in a classical context the large-time limit of the conformal spatial metric exists and defines a globally inhomogeneous and anisotropic, but time-independent geometry. The second basic starting point of my collaboration with Alyosha was to extend his stochastic approach to inflation to an approximate description of the evolution of \hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t) in a quantum context, and to argue that a suitably coarse-grained version of the quantum \hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t) would define a stochastically evolving (unimodular) 3-metric a_{ij}({\bf x},t) becoming exponentially anisotropic as t\to+\infty . Let us first recall another classic result of Alyosha, concerning the production of “relict gravitational radiation” from quantum gravitational inflationary fluctuations Starobinsky:1979ty . Linearized quantum gravitational fluctuations in a de Sitter background, i.e. small fluctuations in the (conformally rescaled) spatial metric of the type, \hat{g}_{ij}({\bf x},t)=\delta_{ij}+h_{ij}({\bf x},t)\,, (3) can be Fourier-decomposed as (with \kappa\equiv\sqrt{32\pi G} ) h_{ij}({\bf x},t)=\sum_{e}\kappa\int\frac{d^{3}k}{(2\pi)^{\frac{3}{2}}}e_{ij}a_{\bf k}e^{i{\bf k}\cdot{\bf x}}\frac{\chi_{\bf k}(\eta)}{a(\eta)}+{\rm h.c.} (4) Here, we assumed for simplicity that we work in a Poincaré patch, and we introduced the conformal time \eta , varying between -\infty and 0^{-} , and such that a=e^{Ht}=-\frac{1}{H\eta}\,. (5) In Eq. ( 4 ), e_{ij} labels two different normalized ( e_{ij}e_{ij}=1 ) transverse-traceless polarization tensors, and the corresponding mode functions 2 2 2 For simplicity we leave implicit the extra label, say e=+,\times , on the mode functions, and on the annihilation operators. \chi_{\bf k}(\eta) satisfy the equation (with {}^{\prime}=d/d\eta ) \chi_{\bf k}^{\prime\prime}(\eta)+\left(k^{2}-\frac{a^{\prime\prime}}{a}\right)\chi_{\bf k}(\eta)=0\,, (6) whose solution (corresponding to the Bunch-Davies vacuum) is \chi_{\bf k}(\eta)=\frac{e^{-ik\eta}}{\sqrt{2k}}\left(1-\frac{i}{k\eta}\right)\,. (7) Finally, a_{\bf k} is a corresponding quantum annihilation operator satisfying the canonical commutation relation [a_{\bf k}\,,a^{\dagger}_{\bf k^{\prime}}]=\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k^{\prime}})\,, (8) and defining the Bunch-Davies vacuum through a_{\bf k}|0\rangle=0 . A first way to see the physics associated with the quantum gravitational field ( 4 ) is to compute the VEV of h_{ij}^{2}({\bf x},t) , namely \langle 0|h_{ij}^{2}({\bf x},t)|0\rangle=2\kappa^{2}\left(\frac{H}{2\pi}\right)^{2}\int_{k_{\rm min}}^{k_{\rm max}}\frac{dk}{k}(1+(k\eta)^{2})\,. (9) The latter integral is both UV and IR divergent. The UV (power-law) divergence is the usual local-Minkowski divergence of the two polarization modes of the gravitational field (with h_{ij}(L)\sim\kappa/L over a small (sub-Hubble) spatial length L\ll H^{-1} ). On the other hand, the IR (logarithmic) divergence involves the lower bound k_{\rm min}=Ha(\eta_{0}) corresponding to the Hubble scale of some initial time, \eta_{0} . When integrated over the interval of momenta k_{\rm min}<k<Ha(\eta) (where the upper bound

Read the complete text