Data Humanism Decoded: A Characterization of its Principles to Bridge Data Visualization Researchers and Practitioners
Ibrahim Al-Hazwani University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative, Ke Er Zhang University of Bergen, Laura Garrison University of Bergen, Jürgen Bernard University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative · 2025
Read Data Humanism Decoded: A Characterization of its Principles to Bridge Data Visualization Researchers and Practitioners by Ibrahim Al-Hazwani University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative, Ke Er Zhang University of Bergen, Laura Garrison University of Bergen, Jürgen Bernard University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00440.txt.
Introduction
Ibrahim Al-Hazwani, Ke Er Zhang, Laura Garrison, and Jürgen Bernard characterize Data Humanism for visualization research in 2025. Data Humanism is a human-centered design approach that stresses the personal, contextual, and imperfect nature of data. Its thirteen principles, set out in Giorgia Lupi's visual manifesto, stay loosely defined for research use, which opens a gap between practice and systematic study.
A mixed-methods approach joins a systematic literature review, multimedia analysis, and expert interviews. The result gives concrete definitions that keep interpretive flexibility for design choices. Direct consultation with Lupi validates the reading. The team then decodes a visualization work, mapping principles to specific visual choices, to show the framework at work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ibrahim Al-Hazwani University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative, Ke Er Zhang University of Bergen, Laura Garrison University of Bergen, Jürgen Bernard University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00440
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Data Humanism Decoded: A Characterization of its Principles to Bridge Data Visualization Researchers and Practitioners Ibrahim Al-Hazwani University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative, Ke Er Zhang University of Bergen, Laura Garrison University of Bergen, Jürgen Bernard University of Zurich Digital Society Initiative Abstract Data Humanism is a human-centered design approach that emphasizes the personal, contextual, and imperfect nature of data. Despite its growing influence among practitioners, the 13 principles outlined in Giorgia Lupi’s visual manifesto remain loosely defined in research contexts, creating a gap between design practice and systematic application. Through a mixed-methods approach, including a systematic literature review, multimedia analysis, and expert interviews, we present a characterization of Data Humanism principles for visualization researchers. Our characterization provides concrete definitions that maintain interpretive flexibility in operationalizing design choices. We validate our work through direct consultation with Lupi. Moreover, we leverage the characterization to decode a visualization work, mapping Data Humanism principles to specific visual design choices. Our work creates a common language for human-centered visualization, bridging the gap between practice and research for future applications and evaluations. \vgtccategory Theory \vgtcinsertpkg keywords Data Humanism, Critical Data Visualization, Human-Centered Visualization 1 Introduction Data Humanism has attracted increasing attention within the practice and research visualization community, as exemplified by projects like “Data Garden” [ 38 ] , “Data Selfie” [ 24 ] , and “Dear Nature” [ 17 ] . Perhaps the best-known exemplar is Giorgia Lupi’s “Dear Data” project [ 32 ] , where she and Stefanie Posavec exchanged hand-drawn postcards visualizing personal data for a year. More recently, with her award-winning work \href https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/12/14/opinion/my-life-with-long-covid.html“1374 Days - My Journey with Long Covid” for The New York Times , Lupi demonstrated how personal, nuanced approaches to data representation can effectively communicate complex health experiences. These projects embody Data Humanism’s core principles: emphasize the human aspects of data, embrace imperfection, and prioritize personal connection over standardization [ 31 ] . The growing popularity of Data Humanism introduces a more personalized and emotionally resonant approach to data experiences [ 42 , 21 ] , presenting design considerations that challenge conventional practice. Critical visualization research has similarly gained momentum, challenging foundational assumptions in standard visualization approaches through frameworks such as feminist theory and critical theory [ 13 , 12 ] . Despite these interests, a considerable gap exists between design-driven examples like \href https://www.behance.net/gallery/154534141/From-my-terraceFrom My Terrace, \href https://mappingdiversity.euMapping Diversity or \href http://www.storiesbehindaline.comStory Behind a Line and research implementation guidance for those without formal design or humanist training. Computer scientists, researchers, and data practitioners often struggle to adapt these humanistic principles to their work [ 43 ] . While Data Humanism’s poetic nature inspires creativity, researchers need concrete guidance for systematic application, evaluation, and comparison across projects. Without clear definitions, researchers often struggle to consistently apply these principles or assess their effectiveness. Additionally, the visualization research community increasingly values affect and engagement alongside traditional insight goals [ 3 ] , still frameworks and guidance for use are minimal [ 35 ] . Data Humanism’s principles offer potential pathways to bridge these gaps, yet their characterization remains ill-defined. This raises an important question: “How can the Data Humanism principles be operationalized for the visualization community?” To address this question, we contribute by characterizing the 13 Data Humanism principles through a mixed-methods approach combining systematic literature review, multimedia analysis, and expert interviews. We validate our characterization through direct exchange with Lupi. Lastly, we demonstrate its practical application by decoding a visualization project. Our work bridges Data Humanism’s design origins with visualization research, creating a common language for human-centered visualization that enables researchers and practitioners to operationalize these principles in future applications and evaluations. 2 Data Humanism as Practice-Driven Lens to Critical Data Visualization Data Visualization Evolution – Data visualization has evolved multiple times to reflect changes in technological capabilities, societal needs, and epistemologies for reasoning about and representing data. In his Tapestry 2018 keynote, Meeks [ 33 ] speaks of contemporary visualization approaches occurring in three waves. The first wave (1980s) focused on clarity and basic visualization types within the constraints of early software tools. This wave emphasized fundamental principles, including data-to-ink ratio and minimizing chart junk, and was heavily influenced by statistical approaches [ 44 ] . The second wave (1990s–2010s) was marked by structured approaches to visualization specifications and grammars [ 45 ] . This period saw the emergence of tools and libraries [ 6 ] that enabled the systematic binding of data attributes to visual elements and interaction. The third wave (late 2010s) represents a synthesis of technical capability and human-centered approaches to emphasize long-term engagement, personalization, and integration within larger contexts. Data Humanism emerged within this third wave as a design-driven and practitioner-focused perspective on human-centered visualization [ 31 ] . Data Humanism’s concepts closely relate to theories and concepts in critical data visualization. Critical Data Visualization – Data visualization has experienced a critical turn in recent years, with scholars and practitioners increasingly questioning fundamental assumptions about data objectivity, neutrality, and the politics embedded in visualization practices. Johanna Drucker’s concept of “capta”, which posits that data are not merely given but are actively taken and interpreted, challenges the notion of data objectivity [ 14 ] . Similarly, the broader field of Critical Data Studies asserts that “raw data is an oxymoron” [ 19 ] , underscoring data as constructed and contextual [ 8 ] . We see a clear through-line of these assertions in Data Humanism through the principles imperfect and subjective data. Within visualization, Dörk et al. [ 13 ] first formulated a set of “Critical InfoVis” design principles that explored the politics of visualization and power structures between visualization authors and their readers. Kennedy [ 23 ] further develops this critical perspective, analyzing how visualization conventions embed authority and objectivity through design choices, while Hill et al. [ 20 ] explore how gender-, class-, and age-related judgments influence perceptions of visualizations. Correll and Garrison [ 10 ] ’s examination of historical anatomical illustrations explore the power dynamics and sociocultural norms encoded within scientific visualization practices. Such power structures and their entanglements have also been examined through the lens of feminist theories [ 12 ] , which emphasize data, visualizations, and insights as inseparable from history, society, and the material world. We see these critical perspectives as the bedrock of the practitioner-centric principles of Data Humanism, in particular principles such as depict complexity and data is people . While sharing many critical concerns about objectivity and power, Data Humanism qualitative point of view and emphasis on artistic expression, imperfection, narrative, and data as design material offers practical, high-level guidance for visualization designers that are not immediately evident through theory. However, this guidance is non-specific, leaving many design choices open-ended and difficult to operationalize. The formal conceptualization of tacit knowledge has recently been tackled through an iceberg sensemaking process model [ 4 ] . We are similarly interested in systematically characterizing the tacit knowledge behind Data Humanism. This motivates our work in characterizing Data Humanism’s principles, enabling other researchers to operationalize these principles when developing or examining human-centered visualization. Data Humanism – Proposed by Italian information designer Giorgia Lupi in 2017, Data Humanism synthesizes several existing ideas about human-centered design [ 26 ] and critical