Looking beyond lambda

Alexie Leauthaud, Adam Riess · 2025

Read Looking beyond lambda by Alexie Leauthaud, Adam Riess (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00359.txt.

Introduction

Alexie Leauthaud and Adam Riess argue in 2025 that cosmology must prepare to move beyond the standard Lambda-CDM model. That model pairs cold dark matter with a cosmological constant, lambda, as dark energy. It now struggles to fit the full expansion history drawn from the cosmic microwave background, baryon acoustic oscillations, and local Type Ia supernovae at once.

Taken at face value, recent results hint at a dark sector more complex than assumed. Testing one dark energy value will no longer suffice, in their view. The authors urge deeper pursuit of the physics of dark matter, dark energy, and gravity on cosmic scales, guided by robust new data. Settling for the simplest account risks missing real structure.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexie Leauthaud, Adam Riess
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00359

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Looking beyond lambda Alexie Leauthaud, Adam Riess Abstract Widening cracks are appearing in the Λ \Lambda CDM model and it is becoming increasingly clear that the standard cosmological model struggles to describe the full expansion history of the Universe as revealed by the Cosmic Microwave Background, Baryon Acoustic Oscillation measurements, and locally calibrated Type Ia supernovae. Taken at face value, recent results suggest a dark sector that may be more complex than commonly assumed. We must prepare for the possibility of moving beyond the Λ \Lambda CDM era, where merely testing w = − 1 w=-1 is no longer sufficient, and embrace the challenge of unraveling the physics of dark matter, dark energy and gravity on cosmic scales. Guided by increasingly robust data—secured through considerable investment—we should pursue deeper understanding while being open to complexity in the dark sector, rather than settling for the simplest phenomenology. New data from new facilities and a new dark energy task force could help illuminate the path forward while changes to our scientific practices will be essential to navigate the potentially rocky road ahead. 1 Introduction One of the greatest success stories in Cosmology has been the development of the \Lambda CDM model that describes the key ingredients of our Universe and how they evolve with time. Since the discovery of the late-time acceleration of the universe in 1998 Riess1998 ; Perlmutter_1999 , the \Lambda CDM model has become the cornerstone of modern cosmology and has withstood rigorous testing from increasingly large data-sets and sophisticated analysis techniques. Remarkably, the model stood up to 4-5 orders of magnitude reduction in its allowed parameter space produced by space-based Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) experiments. But while \Lambda CDM is both elegant and simple compared to many alternatives, it is also maddeningly elusive. With only 6 free parameters, and a few other core components (the laws of general relativity, a spatially flat and homogeneous universe, known particles, and gaussian initial conditions), \Lambda CDM is able to fit an astonishing amount of data, including the exquisitely measured CMB power spectrum (with a fractional error of only \sim 10 -4 , the angular size of the acoustic peaks in the CMB is one of the most well measured quantities in astrophysics!), long stretches of cosmic expansion history and much of general astrophysics. However, despite this tremendous success, \Lambda CDM fails to explain in any detail the physics of both dark energy and dark matter which comprise \sim 95% of the Universe today. In this perspective piece, we discuss cracks appearing in the \Lambda CDM model and how the cosmology community might prepare for a potential post- \Lambda era. 2 The dark sector The \Lambda CDM model fits a Universe with 70% of its energy density today in the form of vacuum-energy, represented by the cosmological constant \Lambda , 25% in the form of Cold Dark Matter (CDM), with the remaining 5% being in the form of regular matter (“baryons”). Both dark matter and dark energy point to physics beyond the Standard Model of Particle Physics – understanding these two components has the potential to revolutionize physics Murayama_2023 . The search for dark matter is a needle in a haystack problem: we have a number of compelling candidates, but beyond determining that dark matter is “Cold” (it clumps gravitionally) and ruling out some regions of parameter space (e.g., cross section vs. dark matter mass), we are still pretty much in the dark. Testing for specific models can be very difficult, and each candidate comes with its own set of often complicated signatures to be compared against data. Most analyses assume that dark matter is one single particle, but this is merely out of convenience and simplicity, not because we have theoretical reasons to believe that dark matter is simple. In reality, there could be several distinct types of dark matter, or even worse, “dark matter” may be a manifestation of a whole hidden sector of dark particles and forces Arbey_2021 . When it comes to dark energy, \Lambda CDM assumes there is a constant equation of state, with the internal pressure and energy density having a fixed ratio of w=P/(\rho c^{2})=-1 . In Einstein’s General Relativity, the internal pressure of vacuum energy carries additional gravity, in this case, negative (i.e. repulsive). If energy is an eternal, static property of the vacuum of space, then cosmic expansion eventually dilutes the attractive gravity of matter (dark or otherwise) until the low-level repulsive gravity of the vacuum wins and accelerates the expansion. In contrast, “dynamical dark energy” (a phenomenological model) could mimic vacuum energy, being the potential energy of a slowly changing (minimally kinetic) scalar field and thus could have an equation of state w that varies with time. Unlike dark matter, we have few compelling theoretical models for dark energy. But similarly, nothing guarantees that dark energy is even as simple as a single-field vacuum type of energy. Given similarities between dark energy and inflation, it is not unreasonable to assume that there are multiple fields driving cosmic expansion, perhaps sprinkled throughout the history of cosmic expansion. Other more complex scenarios include the possibility of dark energy interacting with dark matter, or that General Relativity breaks down on cosmological scales which have only recently entered our horizon. Recent astronomical observations suggest we may be witnessing the demise of \Lambda CDM. While this is an exciting prospect, we also need to face the sobering possibility that \Lambda CDM might have anchored us to an assumption of simplicity; the real, dark universe could be far more complex. While it is said that “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”, it is no longer clear which possibility may be considered the extraordinary one–the failure of a powerful, standard model or the perfection of a phenomenological model that lacks compelling, physical explanation. Lacking a firm physical footing, we must follow the data. In the following, we suggest that current observations may be pointing us beyond the model and that we may further benefit from profound changes to the scientific structures in which we operate to decipher the dark sector. 3 Chasing lambda In 2006, the Astronomy and Astrophysics Advisory Committee (AAAC) and the High Energy Physics Advisory Panel (HEPAP) formed a subcommittee to advise NASA and NSF on the future of dark energy research. The resulting landmark report of the dark energy task force albrecht_report_2006 laid out a road map for dark energy research. This roadmap labeled Astrophysical surveys according to their potential to constrain w(z) , the dark energy equation of state as a function of time, with “Stage III” surveys being more constraining than “Stage II” surveys. Around this time, an ongoing debate in the Astronomy and High-Energy physics communities centered around the question of whether or not to invest significant resources in Astronomy experiments to probe dark energy. On one side of the argument was the notion that the pursuit of \Lambda might not pay off and that decades of efforts and billions of dollars could end up with little more to show that w=-1.000... . The fear was that no hints as to the nature of dark energy would be found and that the opportunity cost to general astrophysics would be large white2007 . Others

Read the complete text