Multiply Robust Inference of Average Treatment Effects by High-dimensional Empirical Likelihood

Xintao Xia · 2025

Read Multiply Robust Inference of Average Treatment Effects by High-dimensional Empirical Likelihood by Xintao Xia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00312.txt.

Introduction

Xintao Xia and Yumou Qiu build a new way in 2025 to judge a treatment's mean effect when many background traits are tracked at once. The mean effect says what a treatment changes on the whole. To find it, one must model each person's chance of being treated, called a propensity score. A single such model can be wrong when the group mixes sources with distinct rules for who gets treated.

Their method weights the data so background traits balance out, and it blends many working score models at once. A wider set of check terms and a tuned outcome model fix the bias left by rough balance. The end result is a score with a key trait: small model flaws do not skew it to first order. The stated range for the effect stays valid if any one score model is right.

Catalog record

CREATORXintao Xia
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00312

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multiply Robust Inference of Average Treatment Effects by High-dimensional Empirical Likelihood Xintao Xia Abstract In this paper, we develop a multiply robust inference procedure of the average treatment effect (ATE) for data with high-dimensional covariates. We consider the case where it is difficult to correctly specify a single parametric model for the propensity scores (PS). For example, the target population is formed from heterogeneous sources with different treatment assignment mechanisms. We propose a novel high-dimensional empirical likelihood weighting method under soft covariate balancing constraints to combine multiple working PS models. An extended set of calibration functions is used, and a regularized augmented outcome regression is developed to correct the bias due to non-exact covariate balancing. Those two approaches provide a new way to construct the Neyman orthogonal score of the ATE. The proposed confidence interval for the ATE achieves asymptotically valid nominal coverage under high-dimensional covariates if any of the PS models, their linear combination, or the outcome regression model is correctly specified. The proposed method is extended to generalized linear models for the outcome variable. Specifically, we consider estimating the ATE for data with unknown clusters, where multiple working PS models can be fitted based on the estimated clusters. Our proposed approach enables robust inference of the ATE for clustered data. We demonstrate the advantages of the proposed approach over the existing doubly robust inference methods under high-dimensional covariates via simulation studies. We analyzed the right heart catheterization dataset, initially collected from five medical centers and two different phases of studies, to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method in practice. Keywords: Calibration; Clustering; Constrained optimization; High dimensionality; Multiply robust inference; Selection bias. 1 Introduction The estimation of the average treatment effect stands as one of the fundamental problems in causal inference. The concept of propensity score ( Rosenbaum and Rubin, 1983 ) is central in addressing and mitigating potential selection biases in non-randomized trials. Estimated propensity scores are used in various methods for estimating ATEs, including PS matching, the inverse probability weighted (IPW) estimator, also known as the Horvitz–Thompson estimator, and the augmented IPW (AIPW) estimator that incorporates the outcome regression (OR) model, thereby attaining the doubly robust and semi-parametrically efficient properties ( Bang and Robins, 2005 ) . Covariate balancing, which uses the IPW formulation with the estimated PS under the covariate balancing constraints, is another way to estimate the ATEs ( Imai and Ratkovic, 2014 ) . The AIPW and covariate balancing estimators are asymptotically equivalent under the fixed-dimensional setting, and their properties have been well studied in this regime. See, for example, Cao et al., 2009 ; Imai and Ratkovic, 2014 . The well-known doubly robust procedures only utilize a single PS and OR model. The two models are likely misspecified when the data are high-dimensional and from multiple heterogeneous sources with different treatment assignment mechanisms. For example, estimating ATEs based on combined datasets is common in clinical trials and medical studies. The right heart catheterization (RHC) dataset ( Connors et al., 1996 ) was collected from five medical centers and two studies, a prospective observational study and an interventional study, to examine the effect of the RHC treatment on the survival rate of severely ill patients. However, the released data do not share the subgroup information. Given the unknown subgroup structure, a single PS model is unlikely to be adequate. 1.1 Related work In fixed-dimensional settings, Han, 2014 proposed a multiply robust inference method by empirical likelihood (EL) that allows multiple working models for both the propensity score and outcome regression. Valid statistical inference can be obtained if any of those models are correctly specified. Chan and Yam, 2014 explored generalized empirical likelihood calibration estimators to achieve multiple robustness for missing data. Chen and Haziza, 2017 proposed a multiply robust imputation method in survey sampling settings. However, those methods do not consider high-dimensional covariates or data with clusters. In high-dimensional settings, Belloni et al., 2014 and Farrell, 2015 introduced a double selection approach for estimating the ATE. Their approaches employ regularized estimators for both the PS and OR models in the AIPW formulation. Chernozhukov et al., 2018 developed a versatile and flexible framework for conducting inference on a target parameter under high-dimensional nuisance parameters. Their method utilizes the Neyman orthogonal score and data-splitting technique, which includes the AIPW estimator as a special case for estimating the ATE. These methods are doubly robust for estimation of the ATE. However, these methods do not yield doubly robust inference, as valid inference requires correct specification of both the PS and OR models. In a related effort to derive asymptotically valid confidence intervals for ATEs, Athey et al., 2018 required correct specification of a linear outcome model. In recent work on linear outcome models, Ning et al., 2020 ; Tan, 2020a proposed doubly robust inference methods for ATEs under high-dimensional data by regularized calibrated estimation. Their proposed confidence intervals of ATEs achieve an asymptotically valid coverage if either the PS or OR model is correctly specified. Particularly, Ning et al., 2020 also considered generalized linear models (GLM) for the outcome variable. All the aforementioned high-dimensional methods do not utilize multiple PS models. The performance of doubly robust estimators can deteriorate, even with slight misspecification in both the PS and OR models. The phenomenon was highlighted in a comprehensive set of numerical studies by Kang and Schafer, 2007 , which demonstrated that, in certain scenarios, using two incorrectly specified models does not yield better results than using a single misspecified model. Therefore, it is important to develop multiply robust inference methods under high-dimensional data, especially when we lack confidence in using a single propensity score model to capture complex treatment assignment mechanisms. 1.2 Our contributions In this paper, we develop a novel method for estimating ATEs that utilizes multiple PS models with high-dimensional covariates. The proposed method achieves multiply robust inference under high-dimensional data; that is, it provides asymptotically valid statistical inference for ATEs if any working PS model, their linear combination, or the outcome regression model is correctly specified. Moreover, the proposed estimator achieves semiparametric efficiency if both the OR model and one of the working PS models (or their linear combination) are correctly specified. The multiply robust inference property is important for clustered data from heterogeneous sources, as a single PS model may not be adequate to reflect the true treatment assignment mechanism. Combining multiple working PS models based on the estimated clusters provides more guarantees of achieving valid statistical inference of the ATE against misspecified clustering algorithms or PS models under a heterogeneous population with subgroup structures. Our approach comprises high-dimensional empirical likelihood weighting, regularized augmented outcome regression, and high-dimensional clustering. We develop a novel soft covariate balancing procedure by high-dimensional EL to combine estimated propensity scores from multiple working PS models. Our soft calibration EL is related to the regularized EL estimation in Chang et al., 2018 ; Chang et al., 2021 . However, the main goals are different. The regularized EL approach is constructed to estimate high-dimensional estimating equations, while our method is proposed to estimate the propensity scores that achieve approximate covariate balancing. Note that exact covariate balancing is not possible under high-dimensional covariates. To achieve the multiply robust inference property, we apply

Read the complete text