Very Massive, Rapidly Spinning Binary Black Hole Progenitors through Chemically Homogeneous Evolution – The Case of GW231123

Silvia A. Popa, Selma E. de Mink · 2025

Read Very Massive, Rapidly Spinning Binary Black Hole Progenitors through Chemically Homogeneous Evolution – The Case of GW231123 by Silvia A. Popa, Selma E. de Mink (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-00154.txt.

Introduction

Silvia A. Popa and Selma E. de Mink ask in 2025 how the giant, fast-spinning black holes in event GW231123 could form in a close pair. The event is the most massive black hole merger yet seen among more than two hundred detections, with extreme spins. Its origin is debated, with paths from repeated mergers to early stars each facing hurdles.

The pair focus on chemically homogeneous evolution, where rapid spin mixes a star fully so it stays compact. They compute detailed models of very massive pairs above the pair-instability gap, a mass range where stars should blow apart. The work tests if that mixed path can yield massive, fast-spinning helium stars that collapse to the observed holes.

Catalog record

CREATORSilvia A. Popa, Selma E. de Mink
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-00154

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Very Massive, Rapidly Spinning Binary Black Hole Progenitors through Chemically Homogeneous Evolution – The Case of GW231123 Silvia A. Popa, Selma E. de Mink Abstract Among the over 200 gravitational wave detections reported so far, GW231123 is a remarkable event that not only hold the record for the most massive black hole merger, but also exhibits extreme spins. Its origin is actively debated. Proposed scenarios include dynamical formation involving a sequence of mergers, Population III stars, accretion in an AGN disk and also more exotic explanations including primordial black holes and cosmic strings, each facing different challenges. Recent work showed that the incoming black holes of GW231123 can be formed out of massive rapidly rotating collapsing helium stars. Here, we address the question how such very massive rapidly rotating helium stars can be formed in very close binary systems. For this we explore chemically homogeneous evolution (CHE) involving progenitors with masses above the pair-instability mass gap. We compute a grid of detailed massive binary models with the stellar evolution code MESA to follow the early evolution of binary progenitors and show that: (i) very massive ( M i > 140 ​ M ⊙ M_{i}>140\,M_{\odot} ) CHE binaries at low metallicity ( Z = 10 − 5 Z=10^{-5} ) naturally produce rapidly rotating progenitors with high masses and high spins matching the properties of the black holes in GW231123 and (ii) the maximum spin of the progenitors is bound by their critical rotation rate leading to a tight correlation between the dimensionless spin and mass, a ∝ M − 0.9 a\propto M^{-0.9} , in models that have no hydrogen left. We conclude that the CHE channel appears to be a viable and natural scenario to produce progenitors. We compare and discuss the differences with earlier studies and comment on the large uncertainties in the final fate and collapse. show][email protected] I Introduction Recently, the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA collaboration reported the detection of GW231123, the most massive binary black hole merger observed to date ( The LIGO Scientific Collaboration et al. 2025 ) . The event involved two black holes with masses of 137^{+22}_{-17}\,M_{\odot} and 103^{+20}_{-52}\,M_{\odot} , which places both components within or above the predicted pair-instability mass gap ( A. Heger et al. 2002 ; R. Farmer et al. 2019 ; R. Farmer et al. 2020 ; S. E. Woosley & A. Heger 2021 ; E. Farag et al. 2022 ; A. K. Mehta et al. 2022 ) . Both black holes also exhibit exceptionally high spins of \chi_{1}=0.9^{+0.10}_{-0.19} and \chi_{2}=0.8^{+0.20}_{-0.51} , the largest spins observed so far in a gravitational-wave (GW) event. Since its announcement, GW231123 has inspired several theoretical studies attempting to explain its origin and formation history. Proposed explanations range from astrophysical formation channels to more exotic scenarios, such as primordial black holes formed in the early universe ( C. Yuan et al. 2025 ; V. De Luca et al. 2025 ) and cusps or kinks on a cosmic string ( I. Cuceu et al. 2025 ) . Several authors considered hierarchical assembly through dynamical formation, where black holes (BHs) grow in mass via successive mergers in dense stellar environments ( M. C. Miller & D. P. Hamilton 2002 ; M. Fishbach et al. 2017 ; Y. Yang et al. 2019 ; D. Gerosa & M. Fishbach 2021 , e.g.,) . Y.-J. Li et al. 2025 suggest that the progenitors of GW231123 originated from the hierarchical merger of 4 and 6 first-generation black holes to make the primary and secondary component. To prevent the intermediate merger products from escaping due to the recoil kicks, this channel requires an environment with sufficiently deep potential wells, such as those found in nuclear star clusters or Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). V. Delfavero et al. 2025 explore the AGN formation channel and propose that GW231123 is most consistent with a merger of third- or fourth-generation BHs. J. Stegmann et al. 2025 , however, point out that the very high spins in the progenitors are very unlikely in dynamically assembled systems. Due to the isotropic distribution of the spin orientations of the incoming black holes, a spin distribution peaking at 0.7 is expected ( D. Gerosa & E. Berti 2017 ; M. Fishbach et al. 2017 ) . They argue that spins above \chi_{i}>0.9 can only be formed through mergers of first-generation black holes that already have large and closely aligned spins pointing toward an isolated binary evolution channel, such as the chemically homogeneous evolution channel, as a necessary precursor. Alternatively, I. Bartos & Z. Haiman 2025 propose that the extreme properties of GW231123 might be explained by sustained accretion, which may occur either in AGN disks or in metal-poor or metal-free Population III stars. Indeed, spin up may be expected as a result of accretion in the case of a thin disk ( J. M. Bardeen 1970 ; A. R. King & U. Kolb 1999 ) . However, at super-Eddington accretion rates, the inflow is expected to form a thick accretion disk or even reach a near-radial geometry ( M. Volonteri & M. J. Rees 2005 ) . It is debated whether the black hole would spin up under such conditions. A. Tchekhovskoy et al. 2012 even show how, under the influence of magnetic fields, the black hole may even spin down. A. Tanikawa et al. 2025 instead propose an isolated binary evolution channel involving Population III stars. This channel relies on several assumptions. The progenitor stars must have very small cores to avoid disruption induced by pair-instability, and they should have very massive envelopes, which are retained during stellar evolution and subsequently accreted onto the resulting black holes. Finally, D. Croon et al. 2025 and O. Gottlieb et al. 2025 explore the evolution and collapse of very massive, rapidly rotating single helium cores above the mass gap as potential progenitors of the incoming black holes of GW231123. D. Croon et al. 2025 follow the evolution using the 1D stellar evolution code MESA until core collapse and estimate the final black hole mass following A. Batta & E. Ramirez-Ruiz 2019 . O. Gottlieb et al. 2025 start from a MESA model of a helium core and use general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations to model the collapse, BH formation and the subsequent accretion. Both studies find solutions consistent with the inferred masses and spins of GW231123’s incoming black holes. In this study, we explore how such very massive rapidly rotating helium stars may form in a binary system through the chemically homogeneous evolution (CHE) channel. This channel has been proposed to produce nearly equal-mass, high-spin black hole binaries that merge within a Hubble time in low-metallicity environments ( S. E. de Mink & I. Mandel 2016 ; I. Mandel & S. E. de Mink 2016 ; P. Marchant et al. 2016 ; L. du Buisson et al. 2020 ) . Here, we focus on progenitors with masses above the pair-instability mass gap, capable of producing black holes consistent with the properties inferred for GW231123. The CHE channel consists of massive, rapidly rotating stars in tight, initially tidally-locked binaries that can avoid the post-main-sequence expansion expected from classical stellar evolution due to efficient chemical mixing ( B. Paczynski 1976 ; A. Maeder 1987 ; S.-C. Yoon et al. 2006

Read the complete text