Suppression of errors in collectively coded information
Martin Falk*, Leon Zhou*, Yoshiya J. Matsubara, Kabir Husain, Jack W. Szostak, Arvind Murugan · 2025
Read Suppression of errors in collectively coded information by Martin Falk*, Leon Zhou*, Yoshiya J. Matsubara, Kabir Husain, Jack W. Szostak, Arvind Murugan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21806.txt.
Introduction
Six researchers test whether genetic information can live in a crowd of fragments in a paper from 2025. Modern life copies single long molecules, which demands precise machinery. Their alternative, a virtual circular genome, spreads information across overlapping short DNA pieces. No single molecule holds the whole message. In mixtures of such pieces, mutant fragments arose but were held down.
Simulations and theory explain the suppression: mutants lose the contest for good binding partners. Healthy pieces extend off each other and multiply faster. Robust copying survives even at mutation rates expected before life began. The authors offer the scheme as a plausible prebiotic information system.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Martin Falk*, Leon Zhou*, Yoshiya J. Matsubara, Kabir Husain, Jack W. Szostak, Arvind Murugan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21806
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Suppression of errors in collectively coded information Martin Falk*, Leon Zhou*, Yoshiya J. Matsubara, Kabir Husain, Jack W. Szostak, Arvind Murugan Abstract Modern life largely transmits genetic information from mother to daughter through the duplication of single physically intact molecules that encode information. However, copying an extended molecule requires highly processive copying machinery and high fidelity that scales with the genome size to avoid the error catastrophe. Here, we explore these fidelity requirements in an alternative architecture, the virtual circular genome, in which no one physical molecule encodes the full genetic information. Instead, information is encoded and transmitted in a collective of overlapping and interacting segments. Using a model experimental system of a complex mixture of DNA oligos that can partly anneal and extend off each other, we find that mutant oligomers are suppressed relative to a model without collective encoding. Through simulations and theory, we show that this suppression of mutants can be explained by competition for productive binding partners. As a consequence, information can be propagated robustly in a virtual circular genome even if the mutation rate is above the error catastrophe for a physically intact genome. Modern life transmits genetic information using long, physically continuous polymers such as chromosomes and plasmids. This mode of storage imposes several stringent demands on the copying process. First, replication must be highly processive: subsequent bases of the coding polymer must be copied in sequence without dissociation. Second, the strands must be physically separated during copying, requiring mechanisms capable of strand displacement. Third, fidelity must scale and increase with genome length to avoid the so-called error catastrophe, where errors accumulate faster than they can be purged by natural selection eigen1971selforganization . All of these requirements are met by complex life today but at the cost of enormous complexity in the copying machinery. For example, the requirements of strand displacement and processivity are are handled by the coordinated action of helicases, single-strand binding proteins and polymerases. Fidelity is enforced through multiple layers of error correction, from nucleotide selectivity echols1991fidelity and exonucleolytic proofreading brutlag1972enzymatic to post-replicative mismatch repair modrich1996mismatch . But such complexity likely arose gradually and would have been unavailable during the earliest stages of evolution of life on earth, raising the question of how genomic information could be copied at early stages. Notably, even efforts to engineer minimal cells today are constrained by these same requirements: currently, these ‘minimal’ cells must still encode genomes large enough to code for complex proteins required for reliable replication of long polymers hutchison2016design . As a consequence, several prior studies have explored how informational patterns can emerge and persist in pools of short oligonucleotides, often using random sequence mixtures subjected to cycles of annealing, extension, or ligation to mimic simple or primitive replication environments prywes2016nonenzymatic ; mutschler2018random ; toyabe2019cooperative ; kudella2021structured ; rosenberger2021self ; mizuuchi2023minimal ; calacca2024replication . These studies showed that even in the absence of long templates or sophisticated enzymes, simple chemical processes can give rise to heritable molecular features. Building on this foundation, we examine a more structured scenario in which the genome is deliberately encoded across a designed set of overlapping sequences that form a virtual circular genome (VCG) zhou2021virtual ; ding2023experimental . In this architecture, no single molecule encodes the full sequence; instead, information is distributed redundantly across a population of short oligonucleotides, each of which can act as both primer and template. This compositional, collectively encoded system enables replication through thermally-driven melt-anneal-extend cycles. Here, we explore the propagation of errors in this alternative distributed architecture, the Virtual Circular Genome, for storing and replicating genetic information. We show that cooperative interactions inherent to the VCG architecture naturally suppress the propagation of replication errors. Using an experimental DNA system combined with simulations and theoretical analysis, we demonstrate that mutant alleles, particularly when they arise at 3 ′ -ends of strands, are at a competitive disadvantage (compared to wildtype alleles) due to reduced access to productive extension partners. This fidelity arises from ecological interactions among molecules, rather than explicit proofreading, and is enhanced by stalling at mismatches huang1992extension ; rajamani2010effect . These results suggest that the architecture of genome encoding can play a central role in enabling robust information transmission, with implications for early life and the design of minimal or synthetic self-replicating systems. Figure 1: Co-operative replication of genetic information in a virtual circular genome. (A) (i) In physically circular genomes found in extant life, genetic information is encoded in long nucleic acid polymers (ii) that are replicated by the extension of short priming strands. (iii) As each primer is extended to cover the entire genome, a neutral mutant allele in one part of the genome is replicated just as often as its wildtype counterpart. (B) (i) In contrast, the proposed virtual circular genome of a protocell is the consensus sequence (purple) of many short oligonucleotides (black and grey). (ii) Each oligonucleotide (oligo) may act as both primer and template during replication. (iii) Here, we show that the resulting co-operative effects, in which wildtype and mutant oligos compete as both primers and templates, suppress the replication of isolated mutant alleles in favor of wildtype alleles already coded on many oligos. I Experimental model Figure 2: Suppression of mutant propagation in an experimental DNA model of the virtual circular genome (VCG). (A) 60 bp consensus sequence for the VCG analyzed here; sequence designed to avoid repeats of length \geq 4 bp. VCG was synthesized as 24 DNA oligonucleotides (12 each clockwise and counterclockwise), each one 25 bp in length and staggered 5 bp along the consensus sequence. (B) Mutant oligos were designed by replacing a 4 bp region of one VCG oligo with a mutated sequence. (C) Experimental setup for VCG replication. Mix of VCG and mutant oligos (here, initial mutant oligo concentration is 5% of corresponding wildtype (wt) concentration) is combined with dNTPs (1mM), Bst DNA polymerase, and 1X Bst buffer and subject to thermal cycling. (D) Denaturing gel electrophoresis of samples after 0, 10, 20, and 30 thermal cycles. DNA ladders (outermost lanes) range from 25 to 90 nt. The initial 25 nt oligos at cycle 0 progressively extend, with predominant products reaching \sim 60 nt by 20 cycles, consistent with the melting temperature T_{\mathrm{m}}=80~^{\circ}\mathrm{C} used in the cycles. (E) Amplification of wildtype and mutant oligos as a function of thermal cycle, for 5% initial mutant levels. Replication is quantified by qPCR every 10 thermal cycles, using primers specific to either a wildtype (green) or mutant (orange) sequence. Measured cycle threshold (Ct) values are converted to absolute DNA concentrations by a standard curve obtained by serial dilution of a known concentration. Amplification of an oligo is defined as oligo concentration normalized to its initial concentration before thermal cycling. Here, as later, circle and square markers denote two independent thermal-cycle replicates, each measured by qPCR in duplicate. Although our ultimate interest lies in RNA-based virtual circular genomes, we employ here a DNA-based experimental model as done in prior related work kudella2021structured ; calacca2024replication ; luther1998surface ; sievers1994oligomers . This choice allows precise control over sequence composition, strand concentrations, and reaction conditions, while enabling direct quantification of wildtype and mutant abundances. Importantly, despite the chemical differences between DNA and RNA, the critical features