Uncertainties within Weather Regime definitions for the Euro-Atlantic sector in ERA5 and CMIP6
Lotte Hompes , 1,2 Swinda Falkena , 2 Laurens Stoop 1,* 1 Advanced Analytics, TenneT TSO, Arnhem, the Netherlands 2 Institute for Marine and Atmospheric research Utrecht, Utrecht University, the Netherlands * Corresponding Author: [email protected] · 2025
Read Uncertainties within Weather Regime definitions for the Euro-Atlantic sector in ERA5 and CMIP6 by Lotte Hompes , 1,2 Swinda Falkena , 2 Laurens Stoop 1,* 1 Advanced Analytics, TenneT TSO, Arnhem, the Netherlands 2 Institute for Marine and Atmospheric research Utrecht, Utrecht University, the Netherlands * Corresponding Author: [email protected] (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21701.txt.
Introduction
Lotte Hompes, Swinda Falkena, and Laurens Stoop published this study in 2025. It stress-tests weather regimes, the handful of named circulation patterns, like winter blocking highs, that energy planners use to foresee shortages over Europe and the Atlantic.
The team compared three regime definitions built by different methods, then nudged each method's choices to see whether the patterns held. They were fragile: small changes in settings or in the training years shifted how often regimes appeared and how long they lasted, and some pattern sets lost their shape entirely. Climate models fared worse: regimes drawn from their data mostly failed to match the reference patterns. One four-regime scheme stayed recognizable; others drifted beyond the team's similarity threshold or failed visual checks. The authors urge great caution when feeding regimes into energy risk models. Decisions about grid resilience, they warn, may rest on patterns that are partly artifacts of method.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lotte Hompes , 1,2 Swinda Falkena , 2 Laurens Stoop 1,* 1 Advanced Analytics, TenneT TSO, Arnhem, the Netherlands 2 Institute for Marine and Atmospheric research Utrecht, Utrecht University, the Netherlands * Corresponding Author: [email protected] |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 85 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21701
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Uncertainties within Weather Regime definitions for the Euro-Atlantic sector in ERA5 and CMIP6 Lotte Hompes , 1,2 Swinda Falkena , 2 Laurens Stoop 1,* 1 Advanced Analytics, TenneT TSO, Arnhem, the Netherlands 2 Institute for Marine and Atmospheric research Utrecht, Utrecht University, the Netherlands * Corresponding Author: [email protected] Abstract Certain Weather Regimes (WR) are associated with a higher risk of energy shortages, i.e. Blocking regimes for European winters. However, there are many uncertainties tied to the implementation of WRs and associated risks in the energy sector. Especially the impact of climate change is unknown. We investigate these uncertainties by looking at three methodologically diverse Euro-Atlantic WR definitions. We carry out a thorough validation of these methods and analyse their methodological and spatio-temporal sensitivity using ERA5 data. Furthermore, we look into the suitability of CMIP6 models for WR based impact assessments. Our sensitivity assessment showed that the persistence and occurrence of regimes are sensitive to small changes in the methodology. We show that the training period used has a very significant impact on the persistence and occurrence of the regimes found. For both WR4 and WR7, this results in instability of the regime patterns. All CMIP6 models investigated show instability of the regimes. Meaning that the normalised distance between the CMIP6 model regimes and our baseline regimes exceeds 0.4 or are visually extremely dissimilar. Only the WR4 regimes clustered on historical CMIP6 model data consistently have a normalised distance to our baseline regimes smaller than 0.4 and are visually identifiable. The WR6 definition exceeds the normalised distance threshold for all investigated CMIP6 experiments. Though all CMIP6 model experiments clustered with the WR7 definition have a normalised distance to the baseline regimes below 0.4, visual inspection of the regimes indicates instability. Great caution should be taken when applying WR’s in impact models for the energy sector, due to this large instability and uncertainties associated with WR definitions. 1 Introduction Human well-being is at risk due to Earth’s changing climate ( Pörtner et al. 2022a ) . To mitigate greenhouse gas emissions, and their adverse effects on our climate, society is shifting towards renewable energy sources ( IPCC 2021a ) . Although these are more sustainable, they are dependent on the ever changing weather and its associated uncertainties, such as the unknowns of climate variability ( Gernaat et al. 2021a ; Bloomfield et al. 2021a ; Stoop 2024a ) . Energy system planners and operators around the world guide this transition towards renewables. For their work, they need insightful knowledge on the weather-driven threats that might pose a risk to the adequacy of the electricity grid in the future ( Gernaat et al. 2021a ; Craig et al. 2022a ) . A critical situation in a power system where load cannot be met by demand may not always be due to an outage of a power plant. It can also be due to structural shortage of energy due to the specific weather conditions at that time. Shortages can be related to the synoptic-scale state of the atmosphere ( van der Wiel et al. 2019a ; Bloomfield et al. 2019a ; Duinen et al. 2025b ; Wuijts et al. 2023a ; Duinen et al. 2025c ) . For instance, weather driven shortages can be related to dunkelflautes ( Van der Wiel et al. 2019a ; Kittel & Schill 2024a ; Biewald et al. 2025a ) . A dunkelflaute is a period of little sun and little wind. Insightful knowledge could be gained by better understanding the synoptic-scale atmospheric circulation patterns, their natural variability and the impact of climate change on them. One tool for analysing these patterns is the framework of Weather Regimes (WR). Weather Regimes are classifications of the meteorological variability into quasi-stationary, persistent and recurrent large-scale circulation patterns of the atmosphere ( Michelangeli et al. 1995a ) . Here we will focus on WRs in the Euro-Atlantic sector. Because the weather in the winter period in Europe is more persistent, European Weather Regimes are often defined for the (extended) winter period ( Michelangeli et al. 1995a ; Neal et al. 2016a ; Falkena et al. 2020a ) , although year-round definitions exist ( Grams et al. 2017a ) . The framework of WR’s is a well-established technique within meteorology. Its roots dating back to the 1940’s, when the German weather service developed a classification system for synoptic circulation patterns over Europe ( 2 ) . These were used to understand the synoptic variability of the atmosphere, so they are not necessarily persistent patterns. Then, since the 1990’s several methods to cluster large scale patterns have been used to study circulation patterns and their impacts ( Vautard 1990a ; Mo & Ghil 1987a ; Molteni et al. 1990a ) . Discussions about the ideal number of regimes have been extensive, as this has to be set a priori ( Falkena et al. 2020a ; Michelangeli et al. 1995a ; Christiansen 2007a ) . However, the same treatment has not been extended to other settings within the WR classification methods, such as the resolution of the grid, the period of the data and the investigated region. Weather Regimes are now also used to investigate the impact of meteorology within the energy sector. These circulation patterns over Europe influence the generation of renewables and the energy demand in Europe, through their relation to wind and temperature anomalies. There are indicators of a direct relation between certain Weather Regimes and periods of low potential renewable energy generation with high demand. Especially a Scandinavian blocking pattern has been linked frequently to winter-time energy shortages in central-Europe ( van der Wiel et al. 2019a ; Bloomfield et al. 2019a ; Wuijts et al. 2023a ) . Furthermore, we need to understand the impact of climate change that are relevant for future energy generation, especially because society moving towards the use of renewables. WR’s can be used as a tool for this. ( Van Vliet et al. 2012a ; Craig et al. 2022a ; McKenna et al. 2022a ; Internation Energy Agency 2023a ) . While Dorrington et al. 2022a show that the Atlantic jet-stream indicates that there is a trend towards less persistent blocking regimes in Europe under climate change, these results uses hybrid geopotential-jet regimes and this definition is rarely used in energy system impact assessments. While the framework of WR’s has now taken root within the energy sector, the method often used for this is not challenged. WR definitions are not often compared to each other. The classic definition ( Michelangeli et al. 1995a ) is used without challenge while for applications, like the energy sector where they are used to steer large public investments, it is useful to understand uncertainties of each method. To properly integrate climate projections into energy system applications of WR’s, understanding the energy-meteorological uncertainty is required ( Craig et al. 2022a ; Most et al. 2022a ; Stoop 2024a ) . In these applications the uncertainty of the impact model itself is often overlooked. In our case, the propagated uncertainties caused by how the Weather Regimes are defined, when they are implemented into impact models ( Shepherd 2019a ) . In this paper we investigate the stability of WR definitions. Specifically