Breaking Universality in the Lower Order Terms in the 1-level and 2-level Density of Holomorphic Cusp Newforms

Lawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti · 2025

Read Breaking Universality in the Lower Order Terms in the 1-level and 2-level Density of Holomorphic Cusp Newforms by Lawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21691.txt.

Introduction

Lawrence Dillon and co-authors refine a math prediction about the zeros of L-functions in a 2025 paper. A major conjecture says the spacing of low zeros in a family of these functions mirrors the spacing of eigenvalues in a random matrix group. The first small correction to that limit is where families start to differ.

Working with families of holomorphic cusp forms, the team sharpens past results on one and two level densities. They compute the correction exactly and show it departs from a universal profile built from basic data alone. The gap rests on a single arithmetic value drawn from the small prime factors of the level. Two families with the same shape can thus differ in a clear, nonzero way.

Catalog record

CREATORLawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE164 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21691

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Breaking Universality in the Lower Order Terms in the 1-level and 2-level Density of Holomorphic Cusp Newforms Thanks: Date : August 10, 2026. Acknowledgments: This research was supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. DMS-2241623, as well as Columbia University, Princeton University, the University of Michigan, the University of Washington, Williams College, and Yale University. Lawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti Abstract . The Katz-Sarnak density conjecture states that, as the analytic conductor R → ∞ R\to\infty , the distribution of the normalized low-lying zeros (those near the central point s = 1 / 2 s=1/2 ) converges to the scaling limits of eigenvalues clustered near 1 of subgroups of U ⁡ ( N ) U(N) . There is extensive evidence supporting this conjecture for many families, including the family of holomorphic cusp newforms. Interestingly, there are very few choices for the main term of the limiting behavior. In 2009, S. J. Miller computed lower-order terms for the 1-level density of families of elliptic curve L L -functions and compared to cuspidal newforms of prime level; while the main terms agreed, the lower order terms depended on the arithmetic of the family. We extend his work by identifying family-dependent lower-order correction terms in the weighted 1-level and 2-level densities of holomorphic cusp newforms up to O ⁡ ( 1 / log 4 ⁡ R ) O\left(1/\log^{4}R\right) error, sharpening Miller’s O ⁡ ( 1 / log 3 ⁡ R ) O\left(1/\log^{3}R\right) error. We consider cases where the level is prime or when the level is a product of two, not necessarily distinct, primes. We show that the rates at which the prime factors of the level tend to infinity lead to different lower-order terms, breaking the universality of the main behavior. 1. Introduction The Katz-Sarnak conjecture states that as we take the limit as the analytic conductor goes to infinity for families of L -functions, the zeros lying near the central point agree with the scaling limits of eigenvalues near 1 of a classical compact group ( [ KS99 ] , [ KS99a ] , [ Hej94 ] , [ Mon73 ] , [ Odl87 ] , [ Odl01 ] , [ RS96 ] ). Supporting evidence for the conjecture has been gathered for various families, by studying moments of L -functions ( [ CF00 ] , [ Con+05 ] , [ KS00 ] , [ KS00a ] , [ KS03 ] ) as well as by investigating the n -level density for suitable test functions ( [ DM06 ] , [ FI03 ] , [ Gül05 ] , [ HR03 ] , [ HM07 ] , [ Mil04 ] , [ ÖS99 ] , [ RR07 ] , [ Roy01 ] , [ Rub01 ] , [ You06 ] ). Specifically, given an L -function L(s,f) associated with a holomorphic cusp newform f\in H^{*}_{k}(N) of level N and weight k , we assume the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis (GRH). 1 1 1 We do not need the GRH to define any of the statistics described below. However, assuming the GRH allows us to relate the n -level density with the spacing between the zeros. Thus, all non-trivial zeros of L(s,f) are of the form \rho_{f}=1/2+i\gamma_{f} . We then enumerate zeros by their imaginary part 0\leq\gamma_{f}^{(1)}\leq\gamma_{f}^{(2)}\leq\ldots with \gamma_{f}^{(-j)}=-\gamma_{f}^{(j)} by symmetry. We define the n -level density by (1.1) D_{n}(f;\Phi)\ :=\ \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}j_{1},\ldots,j_{n}\\ j_{i}\neq\pm j_{k}\end{subarray}}\phi_{1}\left(\gamma^{(j_{1})}_{f}\frac{\log(R)}{2\pi}\right)\cdots\phi_{n}\left(\gamma^{(j_{n})}_{f}\frac{\log(R)}{2\pi}\right), where 2 2 2 In general, we do not need the test function \Phi to be a product of coordinate-wise test functions. \Phi(x_{1},\ldots,x_{n})=\phi_{1}(x_{1})\cdot\phi_{2}(x_{2})\cdots\phi_{n}(x_{n}) is a Schwartz test function and R is the analytic conductor of f . We rescale the zeros near the central point by \log(R)/2\pi (in all our families of interest, \log(R)\sim\log(N) ). The Katz-Sarnak conjecture states that for a family \mathcal{F}=\bigcup\mathcal{F}_{N} of L -functions ordered by their conductors, we have (1.2) \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{\sum_{f\in\mathcal{F}_{N}}D_{n}(f;\Phi)}{|\mathcal{F}_{N}|}\ =\ \int\cdots\int\Phi(x_{1},\ldots,x_{n})W_{n,G(\mathcal{F})}(x_{1},\ldots,x_{n})dx_{1}\cdots dx_{n}, where W_{G(\mathcal{F})} represents the limiting distribution of a similar statistic for the eigenvalues of random matrices in some classical compact group as their rank goes to infinity. While the main terms in the expansions of the n -level density have been shown to agree with random matrix theory, the lower order terms break this universality and provide insight in the arithmetic properties of the family and can serve to differntiate families. For example, [ You05 ] analyzed lower order terms arising from families of elliptic curves, revealing that the number of low lying zeros is highly family-dependent (see also [ GZ23 ] , [ FM15 ] , [ FI03a ] for investigations of the lower order terms for other families of L -functions). Of particular importance to us, [ Mil09 ] demonstrated how the lower-order terms in the 1-level density can provide insight into the arithmetic properties of the family being studied by looking specificaly at one-parameter families of elliptic curves. Moreover, in his thesis [ Mil04 ] and some subsequent papers ( [ Mil05 ] , [ Mil09 ] ), S. J. Miller noticed that different one parameter families of elliptic curve L -functions have different lower order terms for the moments of their Satake parameters, and this has implications for the distribution of zeros near the central point, explaining some of the observed excess rank. The calculations are complicated by the fact that the lower-order terms for the n -level densities can be greatly impacted by the small primes. This led him to develop averaging formulas to numerically approximate all the contributions. He proved that while the main terms agree, different families had different lower-order terms. He then compared that to the lower order terms for the family of all cuspidal newforms, for simplicity of prime level N tending to infinity. We investigate how the lower-order terms of the weighted first-level and second-level density over the space of holomorphic cusp newforms, which are respectively defined by (1.3) D_{1}(H_{k}^{*}(N))\ :=\ \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{W_{R}(H_{k}^{*}(N))}\sum_{f\in H_{k}^{*}(N)}w_{R}(f)D_{1}(f;\phi), (1.4) D_{2}(H_{k}^{*}(N))\ :=\ \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{W_{R}(H_{k}^{*}(N))}\sum_{f\in H_{k}^{*}(N)}w_{R}(f)D_{2}(f;\phi_{1},\phi_{2}), where (1.5) D_{1}(f,\phi)\ :=\ \displaystyle\sum_{i}\phi\left(\frac{2\pi}{\log(R)}\gamma_{f}^{(i)}\right), (1.6) D_{2}(f;\phi_{1},\phi_{2})\ :=\ \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}i,j\\ i\neq\pm j\end{subarray}}\phi_{1}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\log(R)}\gamma_{f}^{(i)}\right)\phi_{2}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\log(R)}\gamma_{f}^{(j)}\right), vary depending on how the prime factors of the level N of the family approach infinity. By doing this, we break the universality of the main term behavior suggested by the Katz-Sarnak Conjecture. We consider four different scenarios in which the level approaches infinity. • The first case is N going to infinity through primes. • The second case is when N=q_{1}q_{2} for q_{1}\neq q_{2} two primes with q_{1} fixed and q_{2}\to\infty. • The third case is when N=q_{1}q_{2} for q_{1}\neq q_{2} two primes with q_{1}\sim N^{\delta} and q_{2}\sim N^{1-\delta} where \delta\in(0,1/2]. • Lastly, we consider the case when N=p^{2} . Here, we weight each f\in H_{k}^{*}(N) by non-negative weights w_{R}(f) and define (1.7) \displaystyle W_{R}(H_{k}^{*}(N)):=\sum_{f\in H_{k}^{*}(N)}w_{R}(f). Moreover, both of our test functions \phi_{1}(x) and \phi_{2}(y) are even Schwartz functions whose Fourier transform has compact support. We write D_{2}(f,\phi_{1},\phi_{2}) in terms of D_{1}(f,\phi_{i}) using inclusion-exclusion. (1.8) D_{2}(f;\phi_{1},\phi_{2})\ =\ D_{1}(f,\phi_{1})D_{1}(f,\phi_{2})-2D_{1}(f,\phi_{1}\phi_{2})+\frac{1-\varepsilon_{f}}{2}\phi_{1}(0)\phi_{2}(0), where \epsilon_{f}=\pm 1 depending on whether the functional equation associated with the completed L -function \Lambda(f,s) is even or odd. Then, we get (1.9) D_{2}\left(H_{k}^{*}(N)\right)\ =\ \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{W_{R}(H_{k}^{*}(N))}\sum_{f\in H_{k}^{*}(N)}w_{R}(f)\left(D_{1}(f,\phi_{1})D_{1}(f,\phi_{2})-2D_{1}(f,\phi_{1}\phi_{2})+\frac{1-\varepsilon_{f}}{2}\phi_{1}(0)\phi_{2}(0)\right). Whenever there is no ambiguity, we write the family H_{k}^{*}(N) as \mathcal{F} . We assume that the reader is familiar

Read the complete text