Approximate calculation of multidimensional first passage times
James F. Lutsko · 2025
Read Approximate calculation of multidimensional first passage times by James F. Lutsko (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21607.txt.
Introduction
James Lutsko tackles a classic timing puzzle in a 2025 paper: how long a wandering particle takes to cross a barrier. In one dimension the answer is known and exact. In many dimensions, with forces pulling on the particle, no clean answer exists. Lutsko builds a chain of simpler formulas, starting from one bold shortcut and easing it step by step.
The last link in the chain lands on a famous old result by Langer. The middle links keep more of the truth, though. Tested against computer runs in two dimensions, the new formulas catch the odd way crossing time bends with barrier height. The oldest formula loses that bend. In the high-barrier limit, all versions merge, as they should. The paper gives barrier science a set of tools that trade effort for truth in a clear order.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | James F. Lutsko |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21607
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Approximate calculation of multidimensional first passage times James F. Lutsko Abstract The general, multidimensional barrier crossing problem for diffusive processes under the action of conservative forces is studied with the goal of developing tractable approximations. Particular attention is given to the effect of different statistical interpretations of the stochastic differential equation and to the relation between the approximations and the known, exact solutions to the one-dimensional problem. Beginning with a reasonable, but heuristic, simplifying assumption, a one-dimensional solution to the problem is developed. This is then simplified by introducing further approximations resulting in a sequence of increasingly simple expressions culminating in the classic result of Langer(Ann. Phys. 54, 258 (1969)) and others. The various approximations are tested on two dimensional problems by comparison to simulation results and it is found that the one-dimensional approximations capture most of the non-Arrhenius dependence on the energy barrier which is lost in the Langer approximation while still converging to the latter in the large-barrier limit. I Introduction Stochastic barrier crossing is a fundamental paradigm in physics that abstracts a wide range of physical processes such as nucleation of first order phase transitions, protein folding, chemical reactions Hänggi et al. 1990 ; Gardiner 2004 . Stochastic models can be developed systematically using tools from statistical physics such as projection operators Grabert 1982 ; Zubarev and Morozov 1983 ; Duran-Olivencia et al. 2017 and multiscale analysis Jarzynski 1993 ; Bendahmane et al. 2024 , or constructed using a combination of physical insight about the specific processes and heuristics such as the fluctuation-dissipation relation (e.g. Landau’s introduction of fluctuating hydrodynamics Landau and Lifshitz 1957 ). The mean first passage time (MFPT) for barrier crossing, or equivalently the escape rate or transition rate, is often the most important physical quantity for practical applications. For models involving a single stochastic variable, exact expressions for these quantities are easily derived as discussed below. Some exact results also exist for sufficiently symmetric multi-dimensional processes Godec and Metzler 2016 and as well as some general asymptotic results Grebenkov et al. 2018 . However, the general multidimensional case remains challenging. Indeed, aside from direct or indirect simulation of the barrier crossing process, the most widely used approach to extract rates from multidimensional models is the classic theory of Langer Langer 1969 ; Langer and Turski 1973 which yields an approximate formula valid in conditions corresponding (roughly) to a large minimal energy barrier and energy surfaces that can be approximated as quadratic functions in the proximity of the critical point. Exact The goal of this paper is to explore the domain between the exact one dimensional results and the classic multi-dimensional approximation. In many physical problems it is natural to imagine that there is a well-defined quasi-one dimensional pathway that dominates the transition process. The scalar variable characterizing position along this pathway goes by various names such as the reaction coordinate or the order parameter and it is often assumed that the process can be essentially understood as a one-dimensional problem in terms of this variable. This intuition has been formalized in recent years particularly in the work of Berezhkovskii and Szabo Berezhkovskii and Szabo 2004 ; Berezhkovskii and Szabo 2013 in which the order parameter is identified as the commitor function, which is the probability that a trajectory starting at a given point will reach one basin of attraction before another. Berezhkovskii and Szabo show that this leads to an exact mapping of the multidimensional problem to a one-dimensional equation, at the expense of having to know the solution of the original problem to define the order parameter. They go on to show that natural assumptions of a separation of timescales between the order parameter an all other variables leads to the classic multi-dimensional result. In the present work, similar ideas are used but with a somewhat different perspective. The goal here is to analyze the general problem and to develop a sequence of approximate solutions, each simpler and less precise than the previous one, culminating in the classic result of Langer. Having done so, the various levels of approximation are then tested on various two-dimensional barrier-crossing problems and compared to “exact” simulations. The next Section formulates the problem in the language of the mean first passage time (MFPT) and recalls the relation between the MFPT and the Fokker-Planck equation. Everything is developed for the general case of state-dependent noise and the complications connected to this (e.g. the statistical interpretation) are discussed. Section III continues the theoretical development first by briefly reviewing the exactly solvable one-dimensional problem and then with the main approximations explored here. Section IV presents the results of some numerical experiments in two dimensions in which the various levels of approximations are compared to simulations. For the examples discussed here, it is found that the most general one-dimensional approximation gives a surprisingly good estimate of the MFPT. The final Section summarizes the conclusions of this work. II Formal development II.1 Diffusive stochastic model Our starting point is a conservative diffusive stochastic dynamics of the general form \frac{d}{dt}\widehat{x}^{I}=g^{IJ}\left(\widehat{x}\right)\left.\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{J}}\beta F\left(x\right)\right|_{\widehat{\mathbf{x}}}+q_{\left(a\right)}^{I}\left(\widehat{x}\right)\widehat{\xi}_{\left(a\right)}\left(t\right) (1) where \widehat{x}^{I} , I=1,...,N are the time-dependent stochastic variables which are collectively denoted as \widehat{x} (to simplify the notation the time dependence is suppressed). The quantities \widehat{\xi}_{\left(a\right)}(t) are white, Gaussian noise delta-correlated in time so that \left\langle\widehat{\xi}_{\left(a\right)}\left(t\right)\right\rangle=0 and \left\langle\widehat{\xi}_{\left(a\right)}\left(t_{1}\right)\widehat{\xi}_{\left(b\right)}\left(t_{2}\right)\right\rangle=\delta_{\left(ab\right)}\delta\left(t_{1}-t_{2}\right) . The number of noise terms may or may not be the same as the number of variables and so is indexed differently with lower-case Roman characters as 1\leq a\leq M where M . The Einstein summation convention is used according to which all repeated indices are summed unless explicitly stated. To simplify the notation, the definitions \displaystyle F_{I}^{\prime}\left(y\right) \displaystyle\equiv\left.\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{I}}\beta F\left(x\right)\right|_{y} (2) \displaystyle F_{IJ}^{\prime\prime}\left(y\right) \displaystyle\equiv\left.\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial x^{I}\partial x^{J}}\beta F\left(x\right)\right|_{y} and \det F^{\prime\prime}\left(x\right) for the determinant of the second derivative matrix will be used. Thus, more compactly, \frac{d}{dt}\widehat{x}^{I}=g^{IJ}\left(\widehat{x}\right)F_{I}^{\prime}\left(\widehat{x}\right)+q_{\left(a\right)}^{I}\left(\widehat{x}\right)\widehat{\xi}_{\left(a\right)}\left(t\right) (3) The first term on the right is the deterministic part of the dynamics and the second models the stochastic forces. The matrix g^{IJ}\left(x\right) goes by various names such as the kinetic coefficients or the diffusion matrix and in general depends on the state of the system (i.e. on the instantaneous values of the stochastic variables). The deterministic dynamics is driven by the gradient of a potential or free energy (the notation suggests the latter but either is possible). In the following, the existence of a fluctuation-dissipation relation of the form g^{IJ}\left(x\right)=q_{\left(a\right)}^{I}\left(x\right)q_{\left(a\right)}^{J}\left(x\right) will always be assumed. Because the prefactor of the Gaussian noise is state-dependent, the stochastic differential equation is not fully specified until a statistical interpretation is given Gardiner 2004 ; Sokolov 2010 as discussed next. The probability that the stochastic variables have a specific value at time t , within some small volume dx around the point x , is denoted P\left(x;t\right)dx and it follows from the stochastic differential equation that the probability density satisfies the Fokker-Plank equation Gardiner 2004 \frac{\partial}{\partial t}P\left(x;t\right)=\mathcal{L}P\left(x;t\right) (4) with \mathcal{L}=\left\{\begin{array}[c]{c}-\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{I}}\left(g^{IJ}\left(x\right)F_{J}^{\prime}\left(x\right)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{J}}g^{IJ}\left(x\right)\right),\;\;\text{(Ito)}\\ -\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{I}}\left(g^{IJ}\left(x\right)F_{J}^{\prime}\left(x\right)+q_{\left(a\right)}^{I}\left(x\right)\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{J}}q_{\left(a\right)}^{J}\left(x\right)\right),\;\;\text{(Strat)}\\ -\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{I}}\left(g^{IJ}\left(x\right)F_{J}^{\prime}\left(x\right)+g^{IJ}\left(x\right)\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{J}}\right).\;\;\text{(anti-Ito)}\end{array}\right. (5) The particular form depends on the interpretation of the stochastic dynamics given by Eq.( 1 ) with the Ito interpretation favored in mathematical developments and the Stratonovich, and anti-Ito (also known in the literature as the Hänggi–Klimontovich) interpretations, favored in physical applications (see, e.g. Sokolov Sokolov 2010 for