Analysis of quantities determining the critical inverse temperature in the annealed Potts model with Pareto vertex weights

A.J.E.M. Janssen · 2025

Read Analysis of quantities determining the critical inverse temperature in the annealed Potts model with Pareto vertex weights by A.J.E.M. Janssen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21409.txt.

Introduction

Janssen analyzes the quantities that fix the critical temperature in a magnet-like model on a random network in this 2025 paper. The network's nodes carry weights drawn from a heavy-tailed law. The model is the annealed Potts model, with several states per node.

A single key quantity sets the temperature where order appears, as earlier work showed through a graphical argument. Janssen rewrites the defining equations for that quantity and two companion quantities in a cleaner form. He then proves a strict ordering among the three and gives simple upper bounds for each. Sharper bounds and the large-state behavior follow, and the bounds become exact in the uniform-weight limit.

Catalog record

CREATORA.J.E.M. Janssen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21409

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Analysis of quantities determining the critical inverse temperature in the annealed Potts model with Pareto vertex weights A.J.E.M. Janssen Abstract Abstract. We consider in this work the crucial quantity t_{c} that determines the critical inverse temperature \beta_{c} in the q -state Potts model on sparse rank-1 random graphs where the vertices are equipped with a Pareto weight densty (\tau-1)\,w^{-\tau}\,{\cal X}_{[1,\infty)}(w) . It is shown in [ 1 ] that this t_{c} is the unique positive zero of a function {\cal K} that is obtained by an appropriate combination of the stationarity condition and the criticality condition for the case the external field B equals 0 and that q\geq 3 and \tau\geq 4 , see [ 1 ] , Theorem 1.14 and Theorem 1.21 and their proofs in [ 1 ] , Section 7.1 and Section 7.3. From the proof of [ 1 ] , Theorem 1.14, it is seen that {\cal K}^{\prime} and {\cal K}^{\prime\prime} also have a unique positive zero, t_{c}^{\prime} and t_{c}^{\prime\prime} , respectively, and t_{c}^{\prime}=t_{b} and t_{c}^{\prime\prime}=t_{\ast} , where t_{b} and t_{\ast} are the unique positive zeros of {\cal F}_{0}(t)-t\,{\cal F}_{0}^{\prime}(t) and {\cal F}_{0}^{\prime\prime}(t) , respectively. Here, {\cal F}_{0}(t)={{E}}\,[W(e^{tW}-1)/({{E}}\,[W]\,(e^{tW}+q-1))] , and t_{c} , t_{b} and t_{\ast} play a key role in the graphical analysis of [ 1 ] , Section 5.1 and Figure 1. Furthermore, \gamma_{c}=\exp(\beta_{c})-1 and t_{c} are related according to \gamma_{c}=t_{c}/{\cal F}_{0}(t_{c}) . We analyse t_{c} , t_{c}^{\prime} and t_{c}^{\prime\prime} for general real \tau\geq 4 and general real q>2 by an appropriate formulation of their defining equations {\cal K}(t_{c})={\cal K}^{\prime}(t_{c}^{\prime})={\cal K}^{\prime\prime}(t_{c}^{\prime\prime})=0 . Thus we find, along with the inequality 0<t_{c}^{\prime\prime}<t_{c}^{\prime}<t_{c}<\infty , the simple upper bounds t_{c}<2\,{\rm ln}(q-1) , t_{c}^{\prime}<\frac{3}{2}\,{\rm ln}(q-1) , t_{c}^{\prime\prime}<{\rm ln}(q-1) , as well as certain sharpenings of these simple bounds and counterparts about the large- q behaviour of t_{c} , t_{c} and t_{c}^{\prime\prime} . We show that these (sharpened) bounds are sharp in the sense that they hold with equality for the limiting case \tau\rightarrow\infty (homogeneous case). These results have consequences for \gamma_{c} and \beta_{c} via the equation \gamma_{c}=t_{c}/{\cal F}_{0}(t_{c}) . While the large- q behaviour of t_{c} , t_{c}^{\prime} and t_{c}^{\prime\prime} is qualitatively the same for all \tau\geq 4 , such a thing does not hold for the behaviour when q\downarrow 2 . It appears that one has to distinguish between the cases \tau=4 , 4<\tau<5 , \tau=5 and \tau>5 with decay behaviour as q\downarrow 2 ranging from exponentially small in q-2 to linear in q-2 . 1 Introduction In [ 1 ] a comprehensive study has been made of the annealed ferromagnetic q -state Potts model on sparse rank-1 random graphs, where vertices are equipped with a vertex weight and where the probability of an edge is proportional to the product of the weights. Under a rather general condition on the weight distribution, phase transition is first order, with a unique discontinuity of the order parameter, see [ 1 ] , Abstract and Section 1. Let \beta>0 denote the inverse temperature, and let \gamma=e^{\beta}-1 (in [ 1 ] one writes \beta^{\prime} instead of \gamma , but in the present work the prime ′ has been reserved to indicate differentiation). Assume that the external field B equals 0 and that {{E}}\,[W^{2}]<\infty ( W is the random weight variable). Consider the function {\cal F}_{0}(t)={{E}}\,\Bigl[\frac{W}{{{E}}\,[W]}~\frac{e^{tW}-1}{e^{tW}+q-1}\Bigr]~,~~~~~~t\geq 0~. (1) The function {\cal F}_{0}(t) is non-negative, strictly increasing and {\cal F}_{0}(t)\rightarrow 1 , t\rightarrow\infty . Assume that {\cal F}_{0}^{\prime\prime}(t) is first positive and then negative, so that {\cal F}_{0}(t) has a unique inflection point t_{\ast}>0 with {\cal F}_{0}^{\prime\prime}(t_{\ast})=0 and {\cal F}_{0}^{\prime\prime}(t)>0 , 0\leq t<t_{\ast} , and {\cal F}_{0}^{\prime\prime}(t)<0 , t>t_{\ast} . Also consider the annealed pressure p(t,\beta)={{E}}\,[{\rm ln}(e^{tW}+q-1)]-{{E}}\,[W]\,\frac{\gamma}{2q}\,\Bigl((q-1)\Bigl(\frac{t}{\gamma}\Bigr)^{2}+2\,\frac{t}{\gamma}-1\Bigr)~. (2) Under the above condition on {\cal F}_{0} , there is a unique pair (t_{c},\gamma_{c}) with t_{c}>0 , \gamma_{c}>0 such that simultaneously the stationarity condition {\cal F}_{0}(t)=\frac{t}{\gamma} (3) and the criticality condition p(t,\gamma)=p(0,\gamma) (4) is satisfied by (t,\gamma)=(t_{c},\gamma_{c}) . The criticality condition can be written as \frac{1}{{{E}}\,[W]}\,{{E}}\,\Bigl[{\rm ln}\Bigl(\frac{e^{tW}+q-1}{q}\Bigr)\Bigr]-\frac{q-1}{2q}\,t\cdot\frac{t}{\gamma}-\frac{t}{q}=0~. (5) In Theorem 1.14 of [ 1 ] about the critical inverse temperature \beta_{c}={\rm ln}(1+\gamma_{c}) , there is considered the function {\cal K}(t)=\frac{1}{{{E}}\,[W]}\,{{E}}\,\Bigl[{\rm ln}\Bigl(\frac{e^{tW}+q-1}{q}\Bigr)\Bigr]-\frac{q-1}{2q}\,t\,{\cal F}_{0}(t)-\frac{t}{q}~,~~~~~~t\geq 0~, (6) so that \gamma is eliminated from the left-hand side of ( 5 ) by using ( 3 ). By [ 1 ] , Theorem 1.14, t_{c} is the unique t>0 such that {\cal K}(t)=0 , and \beta_{c}={\rm ln}\Bigl(1+\frac{t_{c}}{{\cal F}_{0}(t_{c})}\Bigr)~. (7) The proof of [ 1 ] , Theorem 1.14 furthermore shows that {\cal K}^{\prime}(t)=\frac{q-1}{2q}\,[{\cal F}_{0}(t)-t\,{\cal F}_{0}^{\prime}(t)]~,~~~~~~t\geq 0~, (8) {\cal K}^{\prime\prime}(t)={-}\,\frac{q-1}{2q}\,t\,{\cal F}_{0}^{\prime\prime}(t)~,~~~~~~t\geq 0~. (9) According to [ 1 ] , Section 5.1, for the case B=0 , there are unique numbers t_{\ast} , t_{b}>0 such that {\cal F}_{0}^{\prime\prime}(t_{\ast})=0~,~~~~~~{\cal F}_{0}(t_{b})-t_{b}\,{\cal F}_{0}^{\prime}(t_{b})=0~. (10) Denoting the unique positive zeros of {\cal K} , {\cal K}^{\prime} and {\cal K}^{\prime\prime} by t_{c} , t_{c}^{\prime} and t_{c}^{\prime\prime} respectively, we thus see that t_{c}=t_{c}\,,~~t_{c}^{\prime}=t_{b}\,,~~t_{c}^{\prime\prime}=t_{\ast}~;~~~~~~0<t_{c}^{\prime\prime}<t_{c}^{\prime}<t_{c}<\infty~, (11) where we also refer to [ 1 ] , Figure 1. Furthermore, we have {\cal K}(0)={\cal K}^{\prime}(0)={\cal K}^{\prime\prime}(0)=0 while {\cal K}(t) is negative for small positive t and positive for large positive t . Therefore, {\cal K} , {\cal K}^{\prime} and {\cal K}^{\prime\prime} are first negative and then positive, and for all t>0 we have t<t_{c}\Leftrightarrow{\cal K}(t)<0~;~~~~~~t>t_{c}\Leftrightarrow{\cal K}(t)>0~, (12) t<t_{c}^{\prime}\Leftrightarrow{\cal K}^{\prime}(t)<0~;~~~~~~t>t_{c}^{\prime}\Leftrightarrow{\cal K}^{\prime}(t)>0~, (13) t<t_{c}^{\prime\prime}\Leftrightarrow{\cal K}^{\prime\prime}(t)<0~;~~~~~~t>t_{c}^{\prime\prime}\Leftrightarrow{\cal K}^{\prime\prime}(t)>0~. (14) 2 Main results We are interested in bounds and approximations of t_{c} , t_{c}^{\prime} and t_{c}^{\prime\prime} in the particular case that W has Pareto density f_{W}(w)=(\tau-1)\,w^{-\tau}\,{\cal X}_{[1,\infty)}(w)~,~~~~~~w\geq 0, (15) with \tau\geq 4 . The restriction \tau\geq 4 ensures that {\cal F}_{0} in ( 1 ) and {\cal K} in ( 6 ) have for all q>2 a unique, positive inflection point t_{\ast}=t_{c}^{\prime\prime} , see [ 1 ] , Theorem 1.21. In [ 2 ] , a similar effort has been done for t_{c} in the case that W has an exponential density f_{W}(w)=\exp({-}w)\,{\cal X}_{[0,\infty)}(w) , w\geq 0 . It appears that the results we obtain in the present work are, compared with those obtained in [ 2 ] , more transparent, complete and appealing and hardly require numerical efforts. In Section 3 , we shall show that for t\geq 0 , q>2 , \tau\geq 4 {\cal K}(t)=\frac{\tau-2}{\tau-1}\,{\rm ln}\Bigl(\frac{e^{t}+q-1}{q}\Bigr)+\Bigl(\frac{1}{\tau-1}-\frac{q+1}{2q}\Bigr)t+\frac{(\tau-2)(\tau-3)}{2(\tau-1)}\,t(q-1)\,D~, (16) {\cal K}^{\prime}(t)=\tfrac{1}{2}\,(q-1)\Bigl(\frac{1}{q}-\frac{\tau-2}{e^{t}+q-1}+(\tau-2)(\tau-3)\,D\Bigr)~, (17) {\cal K}^{\prime\prime}(t)=\frac{(q-1)(\tau-2)}{2t}\,\Bigl(\frac{t\,e^{t}}{(e^{t}+q-1)^{2}}-\frac{\tau-3}{e^{t}+q-1}+(\tau-2)(\tau-3)\,D\Bigr)~, (18) where D=\int\limits_{1}^{\infty}\,\frac{w^{-\tau+1}\,dw}{e^{tw}+q-1}~. (19) It happens to be a very convenient fact that in ( 16 ), ( 17 ) and ( 18 ) the same integral D appears. In Section 4 , we shall show that for all \tau\geq 4 and q>2 t_{c}<2\,{\rm ln}(q-1)~,~~~~~~t_{c}^{\prime}<\tfrac{3}{2}\,{\rm ln}(q-1)~,~~~~~~~t_{c}^{\prime\prime}<{\rm ln}(q-1)~, (20) where we recall that t_{c}^{\prime\prime}=t_{\ast}<t_{c}^{\prime}=t_{b}<t_{c}~, (21) see [ 1 ] , Figure 1. The proof of ( 20 ) uses the criteria in ( 12 ), ( 13 ) and ( 14 ), the representations ( 16 ), ( 17 ) and ( 18 ) of {\cal K} , {\cal K}^{\prime} and {\cal K}^{\prime\prime} and a convexity property of the function (e^{tw}+q-1)^{-1} , see ( 19 ), as a function of w\geq 1 . In Section 5 , we shall improve the bounds on t_{c} and t_{c}^{\prime} as follows. We have for \tau\geq 4 and q>2 t_{c}<2\,\frac{\tau-2}{\tau-1}\,{\rm ln}(q-1)~. (22) The proof of this uses the observation that \frac{{\cal K}(2\,{\rm ln}(q-1))}{{\cal K}^{\prime}(2\,{\rm ln}(q-1))}=\frac{2\,{\rm ln}(q-1)}{\tau-1}~, (23) so that by t_{c}<2\,{\rm ln}(q-1) and convexity of {\cal K}(t) in t\geq t_{c} t_{c}<2\,{\rm ln}(q-1)-\frac{{\cal K}(2\,{\rm ln}(q-1))}{{\cal K}^{\prime}(2\,{\rm ln}(q-1))}~, (24) the right-hand side

Read the complete text