Channel Estimation and Data Detection in DS-Spread Channels: A Unified Framework, Novel Algorithms, and Waveform Comparison
Niladri Halder, Chandra R. Murthy · 2025
Read Channel Estimation and Data Detection in DS-Spread Channels: A Unified Framework, Novel Algorithms, and Waveform Comparison by Niladri Halder, Chandra R. Murthy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21373.txt.
Introduction
Niladri Halder and Chandra Murthy present a 2025 study on hearing data through underwater sound channels. Underwater links smear signals in both delay and scale, which blurs the data. A receiver must first learn the channel, then read the bits. The pair build one frame that does both jobs for four kinds of signal design.
Their frame states one shared input-output rule for all four designs, so the contest stays fair. They add fresh methods: a learning loop that refines channel guesses, a soft decoder that rates each bit, and a scheme that reuses read data as extra guide posts. Tests show the methods sharpen both channel learning and data reading. Among the designs, one led with a simple equalizer, while a common design trailed. The work aids sonar and subsea links.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Niladri Halder, Chandra R. Murthy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 100 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21373
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Channel Estimation and Data Detection in DS-Spread Channels: A Unified Framework, Novel Algorithms, and Waveform Comparison Niladri Halder, Chandra R. Murthy Abstract We present a unified receiver processing framework for communication over delay-scale (DS)-spread channels that arise in underwater acoustic (UWA) communications that addresses both channel estimation (CE) and data detection for different modulation waveforms, namely OFDM, OTFS, OCDM, and ODSS, through a common input–output relation. Using this framework, we conduct a fair and comprehensive comparative study of these waveforms under DS-spread UWA channels and similar receiver complexities. We also develop a novel iterative variational Bayesian (VB) off-grid CE algorithm to estimate the delay and scale parameters of the channel paths, via two approaches: a first-order approximation scheme (FVB) and a second-order approximation scheme (SVB). We propose a low-complexity variational soft symbol detection (VSSD) algorithm that outputs soft symbols and log-likelihood ratios for the data bits, and a data-aided iterative CE and data detection (ICED) scheme that utilizes detected data symbols as virtual pilots to further improve the CE and data detection accuracy. Our numerical results reveal the efficacy of the proposed algorithms for CE and data detection. In terms of relative performance of different waveforms, in uncoded communications, (a) with a low-complexity subcarrier-by-subcarrier equalizer, ODSS offers the best performance, followed by OCDM and OTFS, while OFDM performs the worst, and (b) with the VSSD algorithm, OTFS, OCDM, and ODSS perform similarly, and they outperform OFDM. With coded communications, interestingly, all waveforms offer nearly the same BER when the VSSD receiver is employed. Hence, we conclude that when the receiver complexity is constrained, waveform choice matters, especially under harsh channel conditions, whereas with more sophisticated receiver algorithms, these differences disappear. I Introduction In the recent literature, a variety of waveforms with associated transceiver architectures have been proposed as candidates for 6G cellular, WiFi, and underwater acoustic communications, with each tailored to specific channel characteristics such as delay spread, delay-Doppler (DD) spread, and delay-scale (DS) spread channels [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . These studies typically consider a waveform-dependent transceiver structure, different channel models, receive-processing techniques, etc, leaving the following core question unanswered: do these performance differences arise from an inherent difference in the way the waveforms interact with the underlying channel, or do they mainly arise from the differences in the receiver processing (channel estimation and data detection) techniques used while evaluating the performance? Addressing this question requires a consistent receiver design that can be applied across all waveforms, and this motivates a second goal of this work: to develop a unified receiver processing framework that is agnostic to the underlying waveform and encompasses channel estimation, equalization, and soft-symbol detection. Developing such a framework is necessary for comparing different waveforms on a level playing field and thereby answering the core question mentioned above. In this paper, we present a comprehensive comparative study of the performance of several key waveforms, considering both estimated channel state information at the receiver (ECSIR) and perfect channel state information at the receiver (PCSIR), in the context of delay-scale spread channels that arise in underwater acoustic (UWA) communications. We focus on UWA channels because these channels present the harshest conditions for communications: multipath with large delay spread leading to frequency-selectivity and a spread in the time-scaling of the multipath components due to severe Doppler effects, leading to time-selectivity. Most radio frequency (RF) wireless communication channels satisfy the narrowband criteria, 1 1 1 The narrowband criteria are: 1. The signaling bandwidth is much smaller than its center frequency; 2. The ratio of the relative speed of the transmitter and receiver to the signal velocity in the medium is much smaller than the time-bandwidth product of the signal. and the relative motion between source, receiver, or scatterers results in a constant frequency shift, also known as Doppler shift , of the signals. One of the prominent ways to model these narrowband channels is the DD-spread representation [ 3 ] , where each tap of the multipath channel is characterized by a distinct complex gain, propagation delay, and Doppler shift. However, the linear time-varying channels present in UWA communications do not satisfy the narrowband assumptions. Then, the effect of Doppler is to time-scale the transmitted signal [ 4 ] . As a result, these wideband channels are better characterized by a DS-spread representation [ 9 ] , where each tap of the multipath channel is characterized by a distinct complex gain, propagation delay, and time-scale parameter. Time-scale effects in UWA channels pose significant challenges for data detection, as conventional receivers, such as subcarrier-by-subcarrier processing in orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) systems, tend to perform poorly. Orthogonal time frequency space (OTFS) [ 6 ] and orthogonal chirp division multiplexing (OCDM) [ 7 ] have been introduced in the literature to address the limitations of OFDM in DD-spread channels. Orthogonal delay-scale space (ODSS) [ 8 ] is a recently proposed waveform specifically designed for DS-spread channels. Given these advancements, it is pertinent to examine the relative performance of these waveforms under different channel estimation (CE) and data detection methods. In [ 10 ] , a detailed study of the challenges associated with OFDM in UWA communications is presented. The BER of OCDM compared to OFDM in shallow water acoustic channels is evaluated in [ 11 , 12 ] , utilizing a channel decoder that processes soft symbols derived from a minimum mean square error (MMSE) equalizer. A comparison of OFDM, OTFS and OCDM in UWA uncoded communications under both PCSIR and ECSIR using MMSE equalizers is presented in [ 13 , 14 ] . The main conclusion was that, in uncoded communications and with MMSE receivers, OTFS and OCDM outperform OFDM, but the performance gap reduces in the presence of channel estimation errors. Further, [ 15 ] proposes a low-complexity MMSE turbo equalization technique for UWA OTFS systems. In [ 16 ] , a learned denoising-based sparse adaptive channel estimation method is presented in the DD domain, and [ 17 ] addresses the peak-to-average power ratio issue by proposing a DD domain MMSE turbo equalizer tailored for single-carrier UWA communications in rapidly time-varying channels. Joint carrier frequency offset estimation gridless channel estimation in OFDM systems is addressed in [ 18 ] . In [ 19 ] , a parametric bilinear generalized approximate message passing-based algorithm to jointly estimate channels and data under nonuniform Doppler shifts in single-carrier systems is developed. However, all these works assume that the UWA channel is narrowband, which does not fully capture its characteristics. UWA channels are inherently wideband and are more accurately modeled as DS-spread channels, as discussed in [ 4 , 9 ] . Moreover, the relative performance of different waveforms also depends on the receiver processing (e.g., the channel estimation algorithm, channel coding, etc) employed. In this work, we consider all these aspects and present a comprehensive comparative study. The estimation of DS-spread channels has been actively studied in the literature. In [ 20 ] , the time-scale is estimated by analyzing the peaks of the matched filter outputs, which is extended to multicarrier systems and validated through experimental studies in [ 21 ] . Both works use a linear frequency modulation (LFM) signal as preamble