Internal Categoricity and the Generic Multiverse

Toby Meadows · 2025

Read Internal Categoricity and the Generic Multiverse by Toby Meadows (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21202.txt.

Introduction

Toby Meadows asks whether a multiverse foundation pins down its subject in a 2025 paper. One theory of the set-theoretic multiverse aims to defuse forcing worries. Forcing can adjoin many equally valid set universes. A rival framework argues some theories determine their subject internally. Whether the multiverse theory enjoys that determinacy is the paper's question.

Catalog record

CREATORToby Meadows
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE109 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21202

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Internal Categoricity and the Generic Multiverse Thanks: I’m very grateful to Gabe Goldberg for helping with some of the crucial claims in this paper. I would like to thank Pen Maddy for helpful conversations around the underlying philosophy. I also want to thank Joan Bagaria, Jeremy Heis and John Steel. Toby Meadows Abstract . John Steel’s theory, M ​ V MV , of the generic multiverse provides a foundation for mathematics that aims to neutralize the effects of incompleteness brought on by forcing arguments. Jouko Väänänen’s development of internal categoricity arguments provides opportunities to argue that the subject matter of some theory is, in some sense, determined. This paper investigates whether M ​ V MV is internally categorical. It is well known that second order ZFC is almost categorical. Given a pair of full models of second order ZFC , one of them will be isomorphic to a rank initial segment of the other and the rank of that initial segment will be an inaccessible cardinal. It is a pleasing uniqueness theorem that sits naturally beside the existence theorems delivered by consistency proofs. Moreover, the moths of philosophy have been drawn to its tantalizing flame since Zermelo 1976 and Kreisel 1969 . One might hope to use this result to conclusively demonstrate that a large chunk of the subject matter of set theory, including the continuum hypothesis, is definitively fixed. These hopes have largely been dashed on the rocks of circularity, however, more recently Jouko Väänänen has formulated an intriguing notion of internal categoricity that seems to avoid these problems and perhaps deliver opportunities for more promising philosophical arguments ( Väänänen 2021 ; Maddy and Väänänen 2023 ) . Internal categoricity will be the focal concept of this paper. As to this paper’s target, we consider a theory that looks to be motivated by ideas that oppose the fixity of subject matter suggested by categoricity. Since the advent of Cohen’s forcing technique and the realization that the continuum hypothesis is independent of ZFC , there has been a recurring thought that at least some of the incompleteness of ZFC is more of a feature than a bug ( Mostowski 1967 ) . This motivates the idea that there is a plurality of different universes wrought through forcing that might all be taken seriously as alternatives upon a somewhat level playing field. W. Hugh Woodin brought this idea to life, albeit in order to bury it, along with its provocative name: the generic multiverse ( Woodin 2012 ; Woodin 2011 ; Woodin 2004 ) . This is a multiverse of universes linked together by sequences of generic extensions and refinements. More recently, John Steel gave this idea a more solid foundational footing in the form of a computably axiomatizable theory, MV ( Steel 2014 ) . MV will be the main target of this paper. Putting these ideas together, we have an interesting tension. On one hand, we have an intriguing theorem template that might rigidify the subject matter of set theory; and on the other, we have a theory that appears to embrace a radically pluralistic vision of what set theory is about. To bring this contrast to a point, the categoricity arguments seem to tell us that the continuum hypothesis has a definitive answer, while the generic multiverse appears to embrace its indeterminacy. In spite of all these appearances, this paper has a simple, but – I think – surprising goal. We are going to prove that MV is internally categorical! Before we get too carried away, I’ll say something even stranger and then I’ll try to clarify the underlying picture. So first, We are also going to prove that MV is not internally categorical. Now it sounds like we have a contradiction, but the devil is in the details; and in particular, the axioms we use. Just as we have with PA and ZFC , the internal categoricity of MV can be made to hold or not hold depending on the axioms we use to generate that theory. 1 1 1 See, for example, Theorems 47 and 52 in ( Enayat and Łełyk 2024 ) . Where does this leave the philosophical preambling above? We’ll defer some discussion of that until then end, but I will say that these results nicely illustrate that internal categoricity is a subtle matter. Moreover, this subtlety warrants further investigation and MV presents an intriguing case study for that project. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 1 , we provide a brief overview of internal categoricity and some of the philosophical arguments it is entangled with. Section 2 provides an overview of Steel’s MV that includes a rough classification of MV ’s models. In Section 3 , we prove that MV is not internally categorical and then in Section 4 , we prove that an alternative axiomatization of MV is internally categorical. The paper then closes in Section 5 with some discussion of these results. 1. What is internal categoricity? We know from Dedekind that second order PA is categorical and from Zermelo and Shepherdson that second order ZFC is quasi-categorical. More formally, Theorem 1 . (1) ( Dedekind 1963 ) If \mathcal{M} and \mathcal{N} are full models of second order PA , then \mathcal{M}\cong\mathcal{N} . (2) ( Zermelo 1976 ; Shepherdson 1951 ) If \mathcal{M} and \mathcal{N} are full models of second order ZFC , then either: \mathcal{M} is isomorphic to V_{\kappa}^{\mathcal{N}} where \kappa is inaccessible in \mathcal{N} ; or \mathcal{N} is isomorphic to V_{\lambda}^{\mathcal{M}} where \lambda is inaccessible in \mathcal{M} . With regard to (1), we have an intriguing uniqueness result. To put some context around this, let’s note that for most us, it’s obviously desirable that, despite the weaknesses of first order logic in pinning down structures, there should be just one intended model of arithmetic (up to isomorphism). 2 2 2 As we progress further in this paper, I’ll frequently omit the phrase “up to isomorphism” in the hopes that this will keep the words flowing smoothly and that the reader will charitably discern my true intentions. It seems natural then to wonder if Dedekind’s result provides evidence that this is the case. There is a lot of philosophy to unpack in such a conjecture, but fortunately this has been thoroughly discussed before ( Kreisel 1969 ; Parsons 1990 ; Button and Walsh 2016 ; Maddy and Väänänen 2023 ) . As such, we’ll satisfy ourselves by briefly considering just one compelling objection, which I’ll motivate with a question: “If I were worried about whether there was a unique intended model of arithmetic, then surely I should be even more worried about full second order models of PA which presuppose that it makes sense to talk about the unique powerset of the natural numbers?” It has been suggested many times that the conjecture above makes use of a kind of circular reasoning ( Weston 1976 ; Hamkins 2012 ; Meadows 2013 ; Koellner 2013 ; Maddy and Väänänen 2023 ) . In order justify our thought that there is a unique model of arithmetic, we appeal to the uniqueness of a much more complex structure. As such, the idea that Dedekind’s result provides evidence for our intuitions

Read the complete text