Stringent Upper Bounds on Atmospheric Mass Loss from Three Neptune-Sized Planets in the TOI-4010 System Facilities: ADS, NASA Exoplanet Archive, Keck II/NIRSPEC AIOLOS ( Schulik & Booth 2023 ) , arviz ( Kumar et al. 2019 ) , astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al.
Morgan Saidel, Shreyas Vissapragada, Michael Zhang, Heather A. Knutson, Matthäus Schulik, Jorge Fernández Fernández, Michelle Kunimoto, Peter J. Wheatley, Jessica Spake · 2025
Read Stringent Upper Bounds on Atmospheric Mass Loss from Three Neptune-Sized Planets in the TOI-4010 System Facilities: ADS, NASA Exoplanet Archive, Keck II/NIRSPEC AIOLOS ( Schulik & Booth 2023 ) , arviz ( Kumar et al. 2019 ) , astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. by Morgan Saidel, Shreyas Vissapragada, Michael Zhang, Heather A. Knutson, Matthäus Schulik, Jorge Fernández Fernández, Michelle Kunimoto, Peter J. Wheatley, Jessica Spake (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21166.txt.
Introduction
Morgan Saidel and co-authors set strict upper bounds on air loss from three Neptune sized planets in one system. Their paper from 2025 uses the TOI-4010 system, whose planets sit in the desert, ridge, and savanna zones of planet spacing. One system means all three shared near the same star light past, which sidesteps big flux doubts.
A Keck telescope tool measured helium glow depth as each planet crossed its star. No escape was found. Upper caps on excess helium uptake were about one point two, zero point eight, and zero point nine percent. Wind model fits turned those into mass loss caps near a set power of ten grams per second. The null results clash with one class of escape models.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Morgan Saidel, Shreyas Vissapragada, Michael Zhang, Heather A. Knutson, Matthäus Schulik, Jorge Fernández Fernández, Michelle Kunimoto, Peter J. Wheatley, Jessica Spake |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21166
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Stringent Upper Bounds on Atmospheric Mass Loss from Three Neptune-Sized Planets in the TOI-4010 System Facilities: ADS, NASA Exoplanet Archive, Keck II/NIRSPEC AIOLOS ( Schulik & Booth 2023 ) , arviz ( Kumar et al. 2019 ) , astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , emcee ( Foreman-Mackey et al. 2013 ) , matplotlib ( Hunter 2007 ) , numpy ( Harris et al. 2020 ) , photoevolver ( Fernández Fernández et al. 2023 ) , p-winds ( Dos Santos et al. 2022 ) , pyTPCI ( Rosener et al. 2025 ) , scipy ( Virtanen et al. 2020 ) Morgan Saidel, Shreyas Vissapragada, Michael Zhang, Heather A. Knutson, Matthäus Schulik, Jorge Fernández Fernández, Michelle Kunimoto, Peter J. Wheatley, Jessica Spake Abstract Photoevaporative models predict that the lower edge of the Neptune desert is sculpted by atmospheric mass loss. However, the stellar high energy fluxes that power hydrodynamic escape and set predicted mass loss rates can be uncertain by multiple orders of magnitude. These uncertainties can be bypassed by studying mass loss for planets within the same system, as they have effectively undergone scaled versions of the same irradiation history. The TOI-4010 system is an ideal test case for mass loss models, as it contains three Neptune-sized planets with planet b located in the ‘Neptune desert’, planet c in the ‘Neptune ridge’, and planet d in the ‘Neptune savanna’. Using Keck/NIRSPEC, we measured the metastable helium transit depths of all three planets in order to search for evidence of atmospheric escape. We place upper bounds on the excess helium absorption of 1.23%, 0.81%, and 0.87% at 95% confidence for TOI-4010 b, c and d respectively. We fit our transmission spectra with Parker wind models and find that this corresponds to 95th-percentile upper limits of 10 10.17 10^{10.17} g s -1 , 10 10.53 10^{10.53} g s -1 , and 10 10.50 10^{10.50} g s -1 on the mass loss rates of TOI-4010 b, c, and d respectively. Our non-detections are inconsistent with expectations from one-dimensional hydrodynamic models for solar composition atmospheres. We consider potential reductions in signal from a decreased host star XUV luminosity, planetary magnetic fields, enhanced atmospheric metallicities, and fractionation, and explore the implications of our measurements for the past evaporation histories of all three planets. I Introduction Planets on close-in orbits can lose significant portions of their atmospheres to photoevaporative mass loss ( Owen 2019 , e.g.,) . It is thought that atmospheric mass loss may carve out part of the ‘Neptune desert’ (see Figure 1 ), which is defined by a lack of sub-Neptune to Neptune-sized planets on close-in orbits ( Szabó & Kiss 2011 ; Beaugé & Nesvorný 2013 ; Lundkvist et al. 2016 ) . Both theoretical ( Owen & Lai 2018 ; Ionov et al. 2018 ) and observational work ( Vissapragada et al. 2022 ; Guilluy et al. 2023 ) suggest that the higher gravities of planets near the upper edge of the Neptune desert make them effectively invulnerable to photoevaporation. As a result, it has been proposed that the shape of the upper edge is created by tidal disruption of planets that came too close to the star during high eccentricity migration ( Owen & Lai 2018 ) . The same theoretical models predict that the lower boundary of the desert is likely sculpted by atmospheric escape, and planets in this region are thought to have either formed in situ or migrated inward via interactions with the protoplanetary gas disk ( Batygin et al. 2016 ; Bailey & Batygin 2018 ; Ida & Lin 2008 ) . Our current story for the lower edge of the Neptune desert is based on predicted mass loss rates from population-level photoevaporative models, which can be uncertain by multiple orders of magnitude. These uncertainties come from poorly-constrained system properties that control mass loss, including the stellar Extreme Ultra-Violet (EUV) and X-ray (together XUV) radiation flux ( Tu et al. 2015 , e.g.,) , stellar wind properties ( Carolan et al. 2020 ; Mitani et al. 2022 ; MacLeod & Oklopčić 2022 ; Rumenskikh et al. 2023 ) , the presence or absence of strong planetary magnetic fields ( Schreyer et al. 2023 ) , and planetary atmospheric compositions ( Zhang et al. 2022b , e.g.,) . In energy-limited mass loss models, the total amount of mass lost is directly tied to the EUV and X-ray output of the host star. Most of this mass loss is thought to occur within the first \sim 100 Myrs - 1 Gyr of the star’s lifetime, when its UV and X-ray output is highest ( Güdel 2004 ; King et al. 2018 ) . However, King & Wheatley 2021 found that significant EUV irradiation of exoplanet atmospheres can occur on Gyr timescales, indicating that EUV-driven mass loss is not necessarily dominated by the high-energy activity early in the star’s lifetime, and can instead be important on Gyr timescales. Since different stars will have different time-integrated high energy fluxes, it can be difficult to compare mass loss histories for planets in different systems. However, in a multi-planet system all planets experienced the same irradiation history scaled by orbital distance, effectively removing this as a source of uncertainty, although the overall uncertainty on the system-wide scaling of XUV fluxes remains ( Owen & Campos Estrada 2020 ) . To date, there have been four published sets of mass loss measurements for multiple planets in the same system, including GJ 9827 b and d ( Carleo et al. 2021 ) , HD 63433 b and c ( Zhang et al. 2022a ) , TOI-776 b and c Loyd et al. 2025 , and TOI-836 b and c ( Zhang et al. 2025 ) . All of the planets in these systems have radii less than 3 R ⊕ , and therefore host relatively low-mass (a few percent of the total planet mass at most) envelopes with a wide range of possible compositions. Atmospheric escape observations in these systems have typically focused on whether or not the planet can retain its primordial atmosphere. These studies have found signatures of atmospheric escape from lower density mini-Neptunes ( Zhang et al. 2022a ; Loyd et al. 2025 ; Zhang et al. 2025 , 1.5-3 R ⊕ ) , and non-detections for super-Earths with higher bulk densities ( Carleo et al. 2021 ; Zhang et al. 2022a ; Zhang et al. 2025 , radii \lesssim 1.7 R ⊕ ) . These observations provide additional support for the hypothesis that atmospheric escape can strip the primordial hydrogen/helium envelopes of mini-Neptunes, leaving behind their rocky cores ( Lopez & Fortney 2013 ; Owen & Wu 2017 , e.g.,) . In this study, we instead aim to use multi-planet systems to explore the origin of the Neptune desert. The TOI-4010 system ( Kunimoto et al. 2023 ) provides an ideal test case for this purpose, as this system consists of three Neptune-sized planets orbiting a K dwarf host. All three planets are located near the lower edge of the Neptune desert (see Figure 1 ), with TOI-4010 b (3.02 R_{\oplus} , P=1.35 days) located inside