Framed defects in ABJ(M)

Marco S. Bianchi, Luigi Castiglioni, Silvia Penati, Marcia Tenser, Diego Trancanelli · 2025

Read Framed defects in ABJ(M) by Marco S. Bianchi, Luigi Castiglioni, Silvia Penati, Marcia Tenser, Diego Trancanelli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21068.txt.

Introduction

Marco Bianchi, Luigi Castiglioni, Silvia Penati, Marcia Tenser, and Diego Trancanelli wrote a 2025 physics paper on a family of quantum field theories called ABJ(M). Their topic is a kind of defect, a loop drawn in the theory that acts like a probe. Such loops have a framing choice, a detail in how the loop is thickened, which can change the answers it gives.

The team compute how framing affects the loop's values and the behavior of points placed on it. They prove a neat identity linking the defect's stress to a quantity that must vanish in a symmetric theory. That identity ties framing to deep questions about scale and symmetry breaking. They also propose what framing means in the theory's string-based mirror picture.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco S. Bianchi, Luigi Castiglioni, Silvia Penati, Marcia Tenser, Diego Trancanelli
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE89 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21068

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Framed defects in ABJ(M) Marco S. Bianchi, Luigi Castiglioni, Silvia Penati, Marcia Tenser, Diego Trancanelli Abstract We investigate the role of framing in a family of 1 / 24 1/24 BPS Wilson loops in ABJ(M) theory, which define flows of supersymmetric defect field theories, interpolating between the 1 / 6 1/6 BPS and the 1 / 2 1/2 BPS superconformal fixed points. We analyze in perturbation theory how framing affects both the expectation values of these operators and the correlation functions of local insertions on the defect, as well as its interplay with RG flow and the g g -theorem. We obtain a non-trivial identity between the one-point function of the defect stress tensor and a 𝒬 {\mathcal{Q}} -exact correlator, which establishes a direct link between scale invariance, superconformal invariance and framing, and clarifies the deep connection between scale and cohomological anomalies. Finally, we propose a holographic interpretation of framing at strong coupling, identifying it with a coupling to the background B B -field in the dual string theory. 1 Introduction Supersymmetric Wilson loops define superconformal defect field theories, introducing one-dimensional extended objects that preserve part of the ambient supersymmetry and conformal invariance. As such, they offer a powerful framework to probe non-perturbative dynamics, symmetry breaking, and renormalization group flows in quantum field theories. In three-dimensional Chern-Simons-matter theories, particularly in ABJ(M) theory, supersymmetric Wilson loops are especially interesting due to their rich structure and deep connections to supersymmetric localization, integrability, and the AdS/CFT correspondence Drukker:2019bev . They provide a fertile ground for exact computations and for exploring the interplay between geometry, topology, and quantum dynamics in gauge/string duality. Among the various supersymmetric loop operators in ABJ(M) theory, a particularly rich family is provided by the 1/24 BPS Wilson loops Castiglioni:2022yes . These depend on a set of complex parameters and interpolate continuously between known 1/6 BPS and 1/2 BPS configurations, capturing a network of defect RG flows and unifying several previously studied operators within a single framework. The interpolating Wilson loops are cohomologically equivalent, differing by a {\cal Q} -exact deformation under a shared supercharge {\cal Q} . This equivalence suggests that their expectation values should coincide at the quantum level, provided supersymmetry is preserved throughout the regularization and renormalization procedure. However, a well-known subtlety arises in the context of Chern-Simons theory: the necessity of introducing framing to regularize short-distance singularities in the Wilson loop, while preserving their topological nature Witten:1988hf . This procedure, which effectively displaces the integration contour to a nearby non-intersecting loop, introduces a framing dependence in the expectation value, manifesting as a topological phase proportional to the linking number between the original and displaced contours. In the presence of matter fields, as in ABJ(M) theory, the framing dependence becomes more intricate. Unlike the one-loop exactness of framing phases in pure Chern-Simons theory, here higher-loop corrections can arise, and the resulting dependence may differ between the bosonic and fermionic sectors of the Wilson loop Bianchi:2016yzj . Importantly, it has been argued Kapustin:2009kz that only the choice of framing equal to one preserves supersymmetry at the quantum level and cancels the so-called cohomological anomaly Griguolo_2013a . This implies that localization results, which rely on exact supersymmetry, compute expectation values precisely at this framing Kapustin:2009kz ; Marino:2009jd ; Drukker:2010nc . The primary goal of this paper is to analyze the role of framing in interpolating Wilson loops and its consequences for defect RG flows in ABJ(M) theory. Building on the perturbative evaluation of framed diagrams of Bianchi:2024sod , we perform a two-loop perturbative evaluation of the 1/24 BPS Wilson loop at generic framing and for arbitrary values of the interpolating parameters. Our results confirm that when framing is equal to one, the expectation value becomes independent of the parameters, as predicted by cohomological equivalence and supersymmetric localization. This provides a robust check of the cancellation of supersymmetry anomalies at this special framing and reinforces the identification of localization with framing one computations. When framing is different from one the Wilson loop expectation value depends non-trivially on the interpolating parameters, as well as on framing. Recalling that the logarithm of the expectation value can be interpreted as the partition function of the defect, a natural question arises whether a Wilson loop defined at two different values of framing corresponds to two different defect theories. In other words, is framing an extra parameter that should be included to define the quantum moduli space of line defects in three dimensions? In order to address this question, we explore the influence of framing on physical observables localized on the defect. We study two-point correlation functions of operators on the Wilson loop and show that framing dependence persists away from the 1/2 BPS point, where instead it cancels non-trivially. We also compute the one-point function of the defect stress tensor and demonstrate that it vanishes only at framing one, where supersymmetry is restored. As a by-product, we obtain a Ward identity which links the expectation value of the defect stress tensor and a Q -exact correlator on the defect - see equations ( 4.18 ) and ( 4.24 ). These results establish a direct link between scale invariance, superconformal invariance and framing, and clarify the deep connection between scale and cohomological anomalies. Therefore, we can conclude that framing is indeed extra data, discriminating between theories with very different quantum properties. We then consider the implications of framing for the g -theorem in defect CFTs Cuomo:2021rkm . In particular, we analyze the behavior of the defect entropy along the RG flow and show empirically that it may decrease, stay constant or increase, depending on the framing number being less, equal or larger than 1. This indicates that at generic framing these defects do not obey the g -theorem of Cuomo:2021rkm . We track this violation down to the emergence of extra terms in key Ward identities used for the derivation of the theorem, triggered by framing. Specifically, framing entails a non-trivial variation of the normal bundle of the defect under the action of the superconformal transformations considered in Cuomo:2021rkm . Finally, we propose a holographic interpretation of framing in the strong coupling regime, identifying it with the coupling of the dual string worldsheet to the background Kalb-Ramond B field in the \text{AdS}_{4}\times\mathbb{CP}^{3} geometry. As in localization, this coupling naturally selects framing number equal to one, aligning with the expectation that the string solution probes supersymmetry preservation in a deeply quantum regime of the dual operators, requiring the absence of anomalies. Altogether, our work elucidates the fundamental role of framing in the quantum dynamics of ABJ(M) Wilson loops, clarifies its interplay with supersymmetry and RG flows, and opens new avenues for understanding its effects in both field theory and string theory contexts. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. After section 2 where we briefly review BPS Wilson loops and framing in ABJ(M) theory, in section 3 we compute the most general 1/24 BPS Wilson loop at generic framing and for any value of the parameters. Up to two loops, we clarify the effects of framing on the loop integrals and discuss framing exponentiation. Examples of correlation functions on framed defects are computed in section 4 , where a particularly interesting relation between the

Read the complete text