Far from equilibrium attractors in phase space

Michał Spaliński · 2025

Read Far from equilibrium attractors in phase space by Michał Spaliński (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-21039.txt.

Introduction

Spalinski studies how hot, fast flows settle to a shared path long before they calm down, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. Such early shared paths are called attractors. They were first found with the help of special variables that split the equations apart. That trick works for just a few systems, so most systems could not be checked.

Spalinski takes a new route that needs no split at all. He uses a kink in the equations at very early time. That kink comes from the boost symmetry of the flow itself. It sets the start state that defines the shared path for all starts. He tests the idea on a case with no split and still finds the path. The method should apply to many more flows.

Catalog record

CREATORMichał Spaliński
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-21039

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Far from equilibrium attractors in phase space Michał Spaliński Abstract We clarify the connection between attractor solutions known from studies of Bjorken flow in conformal models of relativistic fluid dynamics and the more general description of attractors as submanifolds in phase space. We show how to determine sections of the attractor on slices of constant proper time, and point out that in conformal models one may choose a parametrisation of the extended phase space such that the intersection of the attractor with a slice of constant proper time is the same on all slices. In consequence, it is possible to project these intersections and one finds that the result reproduces the attractor solution. This projection allows for an expressive picture of hydrodynamisation, but the attractor can be equally well described without taking advantage of this convenience. An immediate implication of these observations is that conformal symmetry does not play a significant role in the emergence of early-time attraction. We illustrate this by describing the hydrodynamic attractor in a simple model where conformal symmetry is broken by the equation of state. Our findings can be applied to studies of hydrodynamic attractors in more general situations, also beyond the context of quark-gluon plasma dynamics. I Introduction Hydrodynamic attractors act as a template for near-equilibrium behaviour, capturing universal features which can be parametrised using the gradient expansion. It has however been noted that in some model systems these attractors extend into the far from equilibrium regime, providing a fascinating opportunity to study emergent universality in nonequilibrium phenomena. In this paper we provide an approach to exploring attractors across diverse fields, such as high energy physics, cold atom systems and cosmology. The most prominent example of a far from equilibrium attractor appears in the context of quark-gluon plasma (QGP) dynamics, where Mueller-Israel-Stewart theory Muller:1967zza ; Israel:1979wp ; Israel:1976tn (MIS) is a key element of the phenomenological description of heavy ion collisions Busza:2018rrf . These simulations involve flows well outside the domain of applicability of hydrodynamics at early stages, when the energy-momentum tensor is very anisotropic. Their success in describing experimental data suggests a degree of universality emerging while the system is still very far from equilibrium Heller:2015dha , so that this universality cannot be attributed to hydrodynamics. A key issue is the origin of this attractor and the question why does MIS theory seem to be able to mimic it, given the hugely more complex dynamics of QCD. Within kinetic theory one can convincingly argue that the early-time regime is characterised by free-streaming, while the emergence of hydrodynamic behaviour at late times signals the dominance of interactions Blaizot:2017ucy ; Blaizot:2019scw . More generally, it is clear that the answer lies in the assumptions which define Bjorken flow Bjorken:1982qr — longitudinal boost invariance and homogeneity in the transverse plane. Of these, the crucial dynamical assumption is boost invariance, which — as emphasised by Bjorken — is a characteristic property of particle production in QCD at high energies. When boost invariance is imposed on MIS theory, it receives this key dynamical information which is instrumental in the emergence of early-time attraction. The importance of boost invariance in connection with early-time attraction was highlighted in the recent paper Chen:2024pez where it was found that breaking boost-invariance in the initial conditions tends to wash out the early-time attraction — this is in contrast to relaxing the condition of transverse homogeneity An:2023yfq (see also Refs. Kurkela:2019set ; Ambrus:2021sjg ; Ambrus:2021fej ; Ambrus:2022koq ). Very different examples of hydrodynamic attractors were recently described in the context of nonrelativistic physics, where they were identified in a Fermi gas close to unitarity with a time-dependent scattering length Fujii:2024yce ; Mazeliauskas:2025jyi ; Heller:2025yxm . In these cases, early-time attraction may appear because the system under consideration is externally driven in a specific manner. At a mathematical level, this drive provides a mechanism similar to the boost invariance of particle production in QCD. It thus becomes timely and important to develop methods of identifying attractors which can be effective in diverse settings. Experimental programs in the field of cold atomic gases may provide direct access to hydrodynamic attractors and in this way they might also indirectly contribute to the understanding of QGP dynamics. The existence of a hydrodynamic attractor far from equilibrium was originally put forward in Ref. Heller:2015dha in the context of conformal MIS theory and has been developed in various ways and generalised to other settings (for reviews see Refs. Florkowski:2017olj ; Soloviev:2021lhs ; Jankowski:2023fdz ; Spalinski:2022cgj ). These studies took advantage of technical simplifications due to conformal symmetry in an essential way. To explore attractors in the wide range of circumstances where they may occur, one cannot rely on such simplifications. A more general approach is to recognise that attractors should be viewed as submanifolds of phase space, as was put forth in Ref. Heller:2020anv , along with an attempt to define the attractor purely locally, without appealing to late or early time limits. This approach is very general, but it invites questions about its relation to the idea of an attractor solution. Moreover, the known examples where far from equilibrium attraction occurs are characterised by potentially singular behaviour at early times, and the attractor can be identified mathematically by imposing regularity conditions on the nonequilibrium degrees of freedom. In view of this, here we extend and elaborate on the approach used in Ref. An:2023yfq , where the attractor surface in phase space is defined using regularity conditions at asymptotically small times. The basic question addressed in this paper is the relationship between the phase space point of view and the concept of the attractor solution in the sense of Ref. Heller:2015dha . Clarifying this relationship leads to a cohesive and effective framework allowing the direct study of attractors in general settings. Our point of departure is the observation that a natural description of the attractor can be obtained by means of its sections on constant proper time slices. In Section II below it will be shown that they can easily be calculated; in particular, in the hydrodynamic regime these curves can be obtained analytically in parametric form — a simple fact which has so far eluded attention. The key point is that in general, sections of the attractor evolve from slice to slice; however in the special case of conformal models it is possible to choose a parametrisation of phase space such that these sections are the same on all slices. This allows one to project the sections, and the result coincides with the original concept of an attractor solution put forward in Ref. Heller:2015dha . At the same time, this simplification turns out to be just an economy of description which does not play a fundamental role in the emergence of early-time attraction. The choice of variables used to parametrise phase space is purely a matter of convenience, and the attractor can be studied equally well in any parameterisation. An obvious but important corollary is that it is completely straightforward to look for hydrodynamic attractors in nonconformal models using this approach, even though such models do not admit a parameterisation which leads to sections of the attractor which would be the same on each time slice. As an illustration,

Read the complete text