Modelling birdsong transmission with methods from molecular sequence analysis

Anthony Kwong, Mark Muldoon · 2025

Read Modelling birdsong transmission with methods from molecular sequence analysis by Anthony Kwong, Mark Muldoon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-20833.txt.

Introduction

Anthony Kwong and Mark Muldoon model birdsong learning with tools from gene analysis in a 2025 paper. Young male songbirds copy songs from older tutors, much as sequences mutate down a line. The team built a Markov model of that copying by direct analogy.

A particle method fit the model to Java sparrow songs gathered by an earlier research group. The model predicted poorly on several natural questions about song passing. The authors blame the sparrows' faithful copying and their short songs, which starve the model of signal. The honest miss maps where sequence tools fit culture, and where they do not.

Catalog record

CREATORAnthony Kwong, Mark Muldoon
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-20833

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modelling birdsong transmission with methods from molecular sequence analysis Anthony Kwong, Mark Muldoon Abstract In many species of songbirds, juvenile males learn their songs from adult male tutors. In this paper we formulate a novel Markov model for birdsong transmission developed by analogy with models used in biological sequence analysis. We fit the model using the recently developed Interacting Particle Langevin Algorithm (IPLA) of Akyildiz et al. 2025 and analyse a collection of songs from Java sparrows ( Lonchura oryzivora ) originally recorded and studied by Masayo Soma and her collaborators ( Soma 2011 ; Lewis et al. 2021 ; Lewis et al. 2023 ) . The model proves to have limited predictive power for a number of natural problems associated with song transmission in Java sparrows and we propose reasons for this, including the well-established faithfulness of song-learning and the comparative brevity of Java sparrow songs. Keywords birdsong \cdot social learning \cdot maximum marginal likelihood estimation \cdot bridge sampling \cdot stochastic gradient ascent 1 Introduction In many species of songbirds, juvenile males learn their songs from adult male tutors. In this paper we ask whether tutor-to-pupil song transmission can be studied by analogy with molecular sequence evolution. Where songs consist of a sequence of notes, genomes are sequences of nucleotides. Like nucleotides, notes can change from one type to another due to learning errors (i.e. point mutations). Individual notes or even song segments can be inserted, deleted, or duplicated, just like nucleotides and motifs in genomes. Hence, tools from molecular phylogenetics may provide a foundation for modelling birdsong transmission. However, there are important differences between genomes and birdsong. For example, individuals have a single genome, but a bird may sing many different songs. Although there are only four nucleotide bases, birds can sing many different note types. Moreover, molecular phylogenetics is an advanced field where estimates of mutation rates and substitution matrices are available, while birdsong transmission is an emerging subject where such tools are not yet available. These differences necessitate the development of novel statistical approaches. 1.1 Java sparrow songs Java sparrows ( Lonchura oryzivora ) are a highly vocal estrildid finch native to the island of Java, Indonesia ( Kagawa & Soma 2013 ). Male birds typically sing between 2 and 8 note types and their songs often include repetitive syllables, trills, and non-trill notes. Previous studies have established that male juveniles ( pupils ) learn their songs from their so-called social fathers, whom we will call tutors in this paper. ( Soma 2011 ). Learning fidelity is high: pupils learn their tutors’ note repertoires, note sequences (song structure) and temporal features ( Lewis et al. 2021 ; Lewis et al. 2023 ). The strong effect of social learning provides the rationale for creating a data-driven, model for the transmission of note sequences. 1.2 Overview of the data We study a dataset published in ( Lewis et al. 2021 ) consisting of whole song recordings from a captive population of Java sparrows, reared by the Soma lab at the University of Hokkaido. The birds have been selectively tutored, so that almost all pupil-tutor relationships are known. Recordings were made in a soundproof chamber with each bird singing in isolation and all recordings for a given bird were made within a single week (time point). For each bird, when more than 10 full song recordings were available from a single time point, 10 were randomly selected for inclusion. If fewer than 10 recordings were available at all time points, all songs from one time point were used, prioritising recordings made when the bird was approximately 2–5 years old. Full details of the data collection procedures are provided in Lewis, Soma et al. (2021). In total, there are 676 songs recorded from 73 individuals (mean 9.3 songs per individual, range 3 to 10), including 58 pupil-tutor pairs. The birds came from 10 different social lineages, named with arbitrary colours by the Soma lab. A social lineage is a chain of birds all of whose members can trace their songs back to the same founder: see Figure 1 . Lineages varied from 1 to 4 generations in length. Figure 1: Song-transmission lineages represented in the data from ( Lewis et al. 2021 ). Nodes are labelled with numerical bird IDs, while directed edges point from tutor to pupil. Lineages are socially connected groups of birds linked through song transmission: nodes for birds in the same lineage are shown in same colour. Birds 267, 243, 5 and 171 do not have any pupils and their tutors were unknown, so Soma assigned them to lineages based on source location. For example, birds 5 and 171 were purchased from the same pet store as bird 170. Figure 2: Example spectrogram of one song, sung by JS0002 from the Java sparrow dataset ( Lewis et al. 2021 ). Every vertical strip in the diagram holds a heatmap representing the power spectrum for a 512-sample ( \approx 0.0116 secs) temporal interval. The darker regions in the blue bar toward the bottom of the plot indicate the intervals from which the individual notes were extracted. Figure 2 is a visual representation of one song in the Java sparrow dataset. The coloured waves are the individual sound elements (i.e. notes) which are separated by intervals of near-silence. Lewis et al. 2021 inspected such spectrograms and excised notes using the software tool Koe ( Fukuzawa et al. 2020 ). They then manually classified the notes based on their shape and spectral features: a full discussion of the note classification procedure is provided in Lewis et al. 2021 . In total, Lewis et al. classified 22,972 notes into 16 note classes: see Figure 3 for typical examples of the note types. There is now software to computationally excise and classify notes with high reliability using tools such as TweetyNet ( Cohen et al. 2022 ). By excising and classifying the notes, Lewis et al. converted each song into a note sequence. We generated multiple sequence alignments of note sequences from tutors and pupils using profile hidden Markov models ( Kwong et al. 2025 : in preparation). Figure 3: Example spectrograms of the 16 note classes identified by Lewis et al. 2021 in the Java sparrow dataset. Note that the scale used to draw the heatmap varies from note to note. 1.3 Reduction of songs to count data Figure 4 illustrates the kind of data that we analyze. It consists of a set of aligned note sequences from a tutor and a pupil. We restricted attention to those columns of the alignment where both birds have notes in at least half of their songs (as opposed to gap characters). Next, we reduced the alignment to a pair of matrices of counts: x_{ij} Number of times tutor sang note i in position j of the alignment y_{ij} Number of times pupil sang note i in position j of the alignment For example, we write {\boldsymbol{x}}_{j}=(x_{1j},\dots,x_{dj}) to indicate the vector of the tutor’s counts at the j -th aligned position and {\boldsymbol{y}}_{j} for the pupil’s counts. We will do the same thing for all pupil-tutor pairs and so the index j will run across all aligned positions, both within the alignment for

Read the complete text