Evolution favours positively biased reasoning in sequential interactions with high future gains

Marco Saponara, Elias Fernández Domingos, Jorge M. Pacheco, Tom Lenaerts · 2025

Read Evolution favours positively biased reasoning in sequential interactions with high future gains by Marco Saponara, Elias Fernández Domingos, Jorge M. Pacheco, Tom Lenaerts (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-20799.txt.

Introduction

Marco Saponara, Elias Fernández Domingos, Jorge Pacheco, and Tom Lenaerts ask why bias evolves in two thousand twenty five. Humans often expect better futures than reason warrants. Evolutionary game theory tests whether such bias can be adaptive. Agents use level k reasoning in the Incremental Centipede Game.

Positive bias tilts inference toward higher but uncertain rewards. Selection favors that bias again and again in their model. Pure rational play can even go extinct in the runs. Biased agents coexist with non reasoning agents at a new balance. Longer games strengthen the pull toward positive bias.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco Saponara, Elias Fernández Domingos, Jorge M. Pacheco, Tom Lenaerts
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-20799

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evolution favours positively biased reasoning in sequential interactions with high future gains Marco Saponara, Elias Fernández Domingos, Jorge M. Pacheco, Tom Lenaerts Abstract Empirical evidence shows that human behaviour often deviates from game-theoretical rationality. For instance, humans may hold unrealistic expectations about future outcomes. As the evolutionary roots of such biases remain unclear, we investigate here how reasoning abilities and cognitive biases co-evolve using Evolutionary Game Theory. In our model, individuals in a population deploy a variety of unbiased and biased level– k k reasoning strategies to anticipate others’ behaviour in sequential interactions, represented by the Incremental Centipede Game. Positively biased reasoning strategies have a systematic inference bias towards higher but uncertain rewards, while negatively biased strategies reflect the opposite tendency. We find that selection consistently favours positively biased reasoning, with rational behaviour even going extinct. This bias co-evolves with bounded rationality, as the reasoning depth remains limited in the population. Interestingly, positively biased agents may co-exist with non-reasoning agents, thus pointing to a novel equilibrium. Longer games further promote positively biased reasoning, as they can lead to higher future rewards. The biased reasoning strategies proposed in this model may reflect cognitive phenomena like wishful thinking and defensive pessimism. This work therefore supports the claim that certain cognitive biases, despite deviating from rational judgment, constitute an adaptive feature to better cope with social dilemmas. This is the early version of a manuscript published in the Royal Society Interface journal. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2025.0153 1 Introduction A large body of experimental evidence has shown that humans can behave differently from the self-interested rational decision makers hypothesized by game-theoretical models [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . In fact, our decisions may not produce outcomes that align with classical solution concepts such as the Nash equilibrium [ 6 ] . Instead, they may contain biases, i.e., consistent deviations from a reference – rational behaviour – deemed to be correct [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . Such biases, on the one hand, influence strategic reasoning and, on the other hand, render their evolutionary roots difficult to explain [ 10 ] . Trivers’ theory of self-deception [ 11 , 12 ] argues that the evolution of cognitive biases stems from the adaptive advantages of deceiving oneself to better persuade or deceive others, thereby reducing the cognitive cost associated with dishonesty in social interactions. This capacity is closely related to the notion of Theory of Mind (ToM) [ 13 ] , which allows us to attribute mental states such as beliefs, intentions, and desires to others [ 14 ] . In fact, this early process enabled the development of a crucial feature of human social cognition that is usually defined as inter-subjectivity (i.e., an understanding of the intentionality of others), thus rendering social transgressions more likely to be detected and punished. In a recent publication [ 15 ] , we proposed an evolutionary model to study the conditions under which ToM may have evolved, finding that intermediate levels of ToM, interpreted as recursive reasoning of the sort A thinks that B thinks that A thinks that B will do X [ 16 , 13 ] , co-evolve with an optimism bias regarding the expected behaviour of other individuals in the context of mixed-motive interactions. This theoretical work also showed that the expectation of higher future rewards is essential for the appearance of ToM, and that the behaviour generated by the surviving reasoning strategies aligns well with previous experimental data [ 2 ] . Here, we go beyond the work in [ 15 ] by exploring the evolutionary dynamics of biased and unbiased reasoning strategies using the framework of Evolutionary Game Theory [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Strategic reasoning is represented, as in [ 15 ] , through the lens of level– k theory [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] , a popular approach to model bounded rationality [ 24 ] (i.e., the idea that people have limited cognitive capacity and might follow a strategy which is not perfectly rational). In this framework, the degree of rationality, or sophistication , of an individual is represented by an integer k\geq 0 , where no reasoning ( k=0 ) corresponds to an individual acting on ingrained beliefs while higher values translate into a more sophisticated reasoning capacity. The goal here is to investigate whether reasoning strategies with particular properties may be favoured by evolution. In our evolutionary model, described in section 4 , individuals are equipped with reasoning strategies whose cognitive bias within the reasoning process is modulated by a noise parameter \varepsilon . Depending on the type of reasoning process, the parameter \varepsilon perturbs the inferred action away from the deterministic best-response at each reasoning step (see section 4 for details). As a result, the outcome of the reasoning process of an agent may systematically deviate from what is expected from their reasoning level k , basing their strategic choices on a subjective interpretation of reality, possibly triggered by both external and internal factors such as the temptation for higher future rewards, as well as the anticipated behaviour of other individuals in the population. We therefore relax the underlying assumption in [ 15 ] , wherein every individual shared the same reasoning process and made mistakes in the same way. In this regard, our aim is to answer the following series of questions: 1) Under which conditions is rational behaviour replaced by different reasoning strategies; 2) Whether cognitively biased forms of reasoning are preferred to unbiased forms (with biases representing different types of systematic mistakes within each reasoning process); and 3) Whether an evolutionary robust strategy emerges or whether multiple reasoning strategies may co-exist in the population. As in [ 15 ] , the current analysis is also performed within the context of the Centipede Game [ 25 ] , a sequential game with complete and perfect information that involves two individuals 1 1 1 For extensions to 3-player Centipede Games, see [ 26 , 27 ] . who take turns, over a total of L steps, deciding between two actions ( T= Take , P= Pass ) regarding the split of a resource. Player 1 (Player 2) can play T at even (odd) steps. Playing T at a given step means ending the game and receiving a larger share of the resource than the co-player. Playing P means letting the other player decide what to do in the next step, unless the last decision node is reached, where Player 2 has to decide between two different splits (see Figure 1 for an example). The payoff structure of a Centipede Game is designed such that solving the game via the game-theoretical method of backward induction leads a rational self-interested individual to play T at every opportunity. Hence, in the unique subgame-perfect Nash equilibrium (SPE), each player chooses to end the game as early as possible 2 2 2 Remarkably, all Nash equilibria in a Centipede Game require Player 1 to end the game at the first step. . Nevertheless, several studies have shown that this equilibrium strategy is rarely observed during behavioural experiments, especially when the resource to be shared grows with each step of the

Read the complete text