AI and Agile Software Development: A Research Roadmap from the XP2025 Workshop
Zheying Zhang, Tomas Herda, Victoria Pichler, Pekka Abrahamsson, Geir K. Hanssen, Joshua Kerievsky, Alex Polyakov, Mohit Chandna, Marius Irgens, Kai-Kristian Kemell, Ayman Asad Khan, Crystal Kwok, Evan Leybourn, Munish Malik, Dorota Mleczko, Morteza Moalagh, Christopher Morales, Yuliia Pieskova, Dan · 2025
Read AI and Agile Software Development: A Research Roadmap from the XP2025 Workshop by Zheying Zhang, Tomas Herda, Victoria Pichler, Pekka Abrahamsson, Geir K. Hanssen, Joshua Kerievsky, Alex Polyakov, Mohit Chandna, Marius Irgens, Kai-Kristian Kemell, Ayman Asad Khan, Crystal Kwok, Evan Leybourn, Munish Malik, Dorota Mleczko, Morteza Moalagh, Christopher Morales, Yuliia Pieskova, Dan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-20563.txt.
Introduction
Agile software teams are adopting generative AI tools quickly, but they run into friction: scattered tools, weak governance, poor data, and skills gaps. This report gathers the findings of a full-day workshop at XP2025 in Switzerland, where more than 30 researchers and practitioners met. Through structured group sessions, the participants named shared pain points, including low AI literacy and weak prompt skills. They then traced the causes behind these problems and the concerns that cut across them.
By the end of the day, the group had built a shared research roadmap together. It mixes short-term actions that teams can apply now with longer-term research questions. The roadmap aims to guide future studies and to support a responsible, human-centered use of AI in agile work. The authors present it as a starting agenda for the field rather than a final answer.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zheying Zhang, Tomas Herda, Victoria Pichler, Pekka Abrahamsson, Geir K. Hanssen, Joshua Kerievsky, Alex Polyakov, Mohit Chandna, Marius Irgens, Kai-Kristian Kemell, Ayman Asad Khan, Crystal Kwok, Evan Leybourn, Munish Malik, Dorota Mleczko, Morteza Moalagh, Christopher Morales, Yuliia Pieskova, Dan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-20563
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
AI and Agile Software Development: A Research Roadmap from the XP2025 Workshop Zheying Zhang, Tomas Herda, Victoria Pichler, Pekka Abrahamsson, Geir K. Hanssen, Joshua Kerievsky, Alex Polyakov, Mohit Chandna, Marius Irgens, Kai-Kristian Kemell, Ayman Asad Khan, Crystal Kwok, Evan Leybourn, Munish Malik, Dorota Mleczko, Morteza Moalagh, Christopher Morales, Yuliia Pieskova, Daniel Planötscher, Mika Saari, Anastasiia Tkalich, Karl Josef Gstettner, Xiaofeng Wang Abstract This paper synthesizes the key findings from a full-day XP2025 workshop on ”AI and Agile: From Frustration to Success”, held in Brugg-Windisch, Switzerland [ 1 ] . The workshop brought together over 30 interdisciplinary academic researchers and industry practitioners to tackle the concrete challenges and emerging opportunities at the intersection of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) and agile software development. Through structured, interactive breakout sessions, participants identified shared pain points like tool fragmentation, governance, data quality, and critical skills gaps in AI literacy and prompt engineering. These issues were further analyzed, revealing underlying causes and cross-cutting concerns. The workshop concluded by collaboratively co-creating a multi-thematic research roadmap, articulating both short-term, implementable actions and visionary, long-term research directions. This cohesive agenda aims to guide future investigation and drive the responsible, human-centered integration of GenAI into agile practices. 1 Introduction and Evolution of AI and Agile 1.1 Introducing the XP2025 Workshop This paper presents a research roadmap synthesized from the ”AI and Agile Software Development: From Frustration to Success” workshop, a full-day event held at the XP2025 conference in Brugg-Windisch, Switzerland [ 1 , 2 ] . As the third consecutive AI and Agile event at XP, the workshop attracted over 30 participants from research and practice who shared a common interest in integrating artificial intelligence into agile ways of working. While a growing body of literature explores this synergy [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] , a significant gap persists between theoretical possibilities and the practical experiences of agile teams, whose insights are essential for guiding effective research. The organizers set four objectives: to investigate the adoption of AI in Agile practices; to facilitate the exchange of practical experiences, including both challenges and successes; to develop a forward-looking research roadmap collaboratively; and to demonstrate the application of AI tools by integrating them into the workshop discussion. A competitive call for contributions resulted in 17 submissions , from which two keynotes, three research papers, and three industrial experience talks were accepted for presentation. The committee itself formed an academia-industry coalition, reflecting the collaborative theme of the workshop. A notable feature of the workshop was its deliberate use of AI-powered tools to enhance and document the proceedings. For instance, an AI-generated theme song was created to capture the event’s collaborative spirit, and a custom GPT was developed and populated with all accepted papers, keynotes, and session outputs to serve as a persistent and interactive knowledge base. These resources 1 1 1 Final Workshop Program: https://conf.researchr.org/home/xp-2025/aiandagile-2025 Official Workshop Website: gpt-lab.eu Custom Conference GPT: chatgpt.com AI-Generated Workshop Song: suno.com Workshop Opening Talk: https://youtu.be/xigzwCzttV4 Workshop Highlights Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TmQwxuRAOIk , along with video recordings and the official program and workshop website, provide a comprehensive and lasting record of the discussions. The workshop thus served not only as a forum for discussing AI’s role in agile but also as a live demonstration of its potential. 1.2 Evolution of Agile and the Emergence of AI-powered Tooling Since its formalization in the Agile Manifesto (2001) [ 15 ] , the agile movement fundamentally reshaped the software engineering landscape. Its principles prioritized individuals and interactions, customer collaboration, and the ability to respond to change over rigid processes and comprehensive documentation. Agile frameworks such as Scrum, eXtreme Programming (XP), and methods like Kanban became industry standards, fostering iterative development, continuous feedback, and a focus on delivering value. For nearly two decades, the evolution in this space was driven by process refinement and human-centric collaboration practices. Early technical enablers such as continuous integration (2000s) [ 16 ] and DevOps pipelines (2010s) [ 17 ] automated build, test, and deployment loops, reinforcing agility through faster feedback. Concurrently, AI techniques matured along three overlapping waves: • 2005-2015 – Predictive analytics and classic ML [ 18 , 19 ] : Early defect-prediction models and recommendation engines appeared in issue tracking and backlog grooming tools. • 2016-2020 – Deep learning for code and text : Sequence-to-sequence networks powered code-completion, test-generation, and backlog-item classification. The launch of GitHub Copilot (2021) [ 20 ] and ChatGPT (late 2022) marked a paradigm shift. Suddenly, AI was no longer a peripheral analyst but an active, conversational partner directly embedded in the developer’s workflow signaling a tipping point in mainstream developer exposure to large language models (LLMs). • 2021-present – Foundation models and multi-agent orchestration : Modern foundation and reasoning models can generate user stories, draft pull-request descriptions, and critique each other’s outputs. These capabilities highlight the growing sophistication of AI-generated content, while underscoring the continued importance of keeping humans in the loop to ensure relevance, accuracy, and alignment with human intent. Both Joshua Kerievsky [ 21 ] and Alex Polyakov [ 22 ] , keynote speakers at XP2025, explored how Agile practices can evolve in the age of GenAI. Kerievsky argued that the core practices of XP - such as pair programming, test-driven development, and collective ownership - provide the essential structure and quality control needed to steer and validate AI-generated outputs, turning a potentially erratic tool into a reliable collaborator. Similarly, Polyakov emphasized that AI tooling is most effective when designed not merely to automate existing frameworks but to address deeper team challenges around communication, clarity, and decision-making. This, he noted, can foster the right behaviours to enhance adaptability. Together, these insights frame a central challenge for the community: how to thoughtfully integrate the immense power of GenAI into the proven, human-centered philosophies of agile development. 1.3 Motivation for this Research Roadmap This paper builds on the discussion initiated during the XP2024 Industry and Practice Track on AI and Agile 2 2 2 XP2024 AI and Agile - Industry and Practice Track . While the 2024 track presented experiences from early adopters, the XP2025 workshop exposed broader. The identified community-wide research gaps emphasize the need for a structured research response. Three gaps dominated the roadmap session. They are • Fragmented tooling : “Too many tools, unclear which to use” received the highest number of votes during the frustration prioritization exercise. Teams face overlapping feature sets, inconsistent user interfaces and proprietary model endpoints that hinder end-to-end flow. • Governance and privacy uncertainty : Participants expressed concern about data-protection boundaries and intellectual-property ownership when AI models ingest sprint artifacts. These anxieties delay or derail organizational adoption. • Skills and literacy gaps : A pervasive lack of prompting know-how, together with early abandonment after poor first trials, leaves many teams unable to translate AI potential into value. These gaps jeopardize core agile principles of sustainable pace, transparency and customer-driven value. Fragmented tooling disrupts flow and increases cognitive load, undermining a sustainable pace. Governance and privacy uncertainties reduce transparency in how AI models are applied and create barriers to open team collaboration. Skills and literacy gaps prevent effective use of AI to deliver incremental