Identifiability, Sensitivity, and Genetic Algorithms in Bacterial Biofilm Selection Models
Stephen Williams, Daravuth Cheam, Michele K. Nishiguchi, Suzanne S. Sindi, Shilpa Khatri, Erica M. Rutter · 2025
Read Identifiability, Sensitivity, and Genetic Algorithms in Bacterial Biofilm Selection Models by Stephen Williams, Daravuth Cheam, Michele K. Nishiguchi, Suzanne S. Sindi, Shilpa Khatri, Erica M. Rutter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-20219.txt.
Introduction
Stephen Williams and five co-authors study how to model bacterial biofilms, the dense mats bacteria build for shelter, in a 2025 arXiv paper. In the wild, hunger and hunters push bacteria to form or shed these mats, and types that mat faster can win out over time. Past models rarely asked how much data it takes to pin their numbers down.
The team adapts a population model with predator stress and tests it on fake data whose truth is known. A search method borrowed from evolution then draws up the best plan for gathering real data. Their checks show some model parts can be dropped without loss. A second, split model tracks types with unlike top speeds for mat building, and shows which numbers steer how fast one type takes over.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Stephen Williams, Daravuth Cheam, Michele K. Nishiguchi, Suzanne S. Sindi, Shilpa Khatri, Erica M. Rutter |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-20219
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Identifiability, Sensitivity, and Genetic Algorithms in Bacterial Biofilm Selection Models Stephen Williams, Daravuth Cheam, Michele K. Nishiguchi, Suzanne S. Sindi, Shilpa Khatri, Erica M. Rutter Abstract Bacteria often develop distinct phenotypes to adapt to environmental stress. In particular, they can produce biofilms, dense communities of bacteria that live in a complex extracellular matrix. Bacterial biofilms provide a safe haven from environmental conditions by distributing metabolic workload and allowing them to perform complex multicellular processes. While previous studies have investigated how bacterial biofilms are regulated under laboratory conditions, they have not considered (1) the data requirements necessary to estimate model parameters and (2) how bacteria respond to recurring stressors in their natural habitats. To address (1), we adapted a mechanistic population model to explore the dynamics of biofilm formation in the presence of predator stress, using synthetic data. We used a Maximum Likelihood Estimation framework to measure crucial parameters underpinning the biofilm formation dynamics. We used genetic algorithms to propose an optimal data collection schedule that minimised parameter identifiability confidence interval widths. Our sensitivity analysis revealed that we could simplify the binding dynamics and eliminate biofilm detachment. To address (2), we proposed a structured version of our model to capture the long-term behaviour and evolutionary selection. In our extended model, the subpopulations feature different maximal rates of biofilm formation. We compared the selection under different predator types and amounts and identified key parameters that affected the speed of selection via sensitivity analysis. Keywords : Parameter Identifiability, Optimal Experimental Design 1 Introduction Many bacteria are cosmopolitan, but can survive under extreme conditions such as high or low temperature, humidity, salinity, and pH ( Wang et al. 2015 ; Merino et al. 2019 ; Kochhar et al. 2022 ) . Bacteria have evolved to employ several key strategies to maintain the flexibility needed to address such various environmental challenges ( Coker 2023 ; Marzban & Tesei 2025 ; Somayaji et al. 2022 ) . One such strategy is to adopt distinct ecotypes, observable differences between members of the same species in response to their environment. One type of adaptive response is the ability to form biofilms in response to both abiotic and biotic conditions. Biofilms are communities of bacteria spread throughout an extracellular matrix, composed of secreted substances, particularly polysaccharides, proteins, and DNA ( Flemming et al. 2016 ; Flemming & Wingender 2010 ) . Biofilm formation can confer various forms of resilience to its occupants by creating spatially favourable distributions. This enables the bacteria to collectively share metabolic workload, and benefit from cooperative behaviours like quorum sensing ( Zhang et al. 2024 ; Li & Tian 2012 ) . Free-living or planktonic bacteria move via diffusion or active swimming and readily adhere to surfaces or each other. These adhered bacteria become centres for more bacteria to attach, forming microcolonies that grow into mature biofilms through further attachment and internal replication. Researchers have examined the formation process using experiments ( Merritt et al. 2006 ) , numerical simulations using hydrodynamic theory ( Zhao & Wang 2017 ) , ordinary and partial differential equation models ( Trubenová et al. 2022 ; D’Acunto et al. 2021 ) , and agent-based modelling ( Nagarajan et al. 2022 ) . These studies can provide valuable insights for several applications, including the prevention of biofouling ( Elumalai et al. 2024 ; Liu et al. 2024 ; Flemming 2020 ) , infections in medical devices ( Høiby et al. 2010 ) , and applications to bioremediation ( Muhammad et al. 2020 ) . By understanding biofilm formation dynamics under environmental stress, we also gain a crucial understanding of the wider ecological role of bacteria ( Cohen et al. 2019 ; Cohen et al. 2020 ; Hall-Stoodley et al. 2004 ) . Differential equation models, where dynamics reflect expected in vivo behaviours, offer one way to model biofilm formation dynamics ( Bottomley & Eberl 2024 ; Garde et al. 2020 ) . In our study, we use these models to gain a deeper understanding of biofilm formation, particularly under external stressors. Our study addresses the types and amounts of data required to parameterise such models, as well as how existing forms of models can be adapted to capture long-term effects that are maintained through selection. Initially, we will focus on the model presented in ( Seiler et al. 2017 ) , which utilises a set of differential equations to model a biofilm formation experiment under predation. The mathematical dynamics governing each population within such models follow established behaviours ( Murray 2002 ) . While these models are intuitively appealing due to their mechanistic interactions, they also make strong assumptions and introduce numerous potentially unknown parameters ( Gunawardena 2014 ; Villaverde et al. 2023 ) . As such, understanding how to measure these parameters and quantify their uncertainties is imperative ( Kirk et al. 2013 ; Simpson et al. 2024 ) . Therefore, we will determine a practical experimental setup that optimises the measurability of the parameters underlying our model. Additionally, this study enables us to explore how varying external stressors for such systems can lead to adaptations within the population through selection. The methodologies applied in this study allow us to develop a long-term model from a short-term model to study selection dynamics. Our first aim is to evaluate this model using structural identifiability, practical identifiability, and sensitivity analysis, and use that information to propose an optimal data collection schedule ( Banks et al. 2014 ) . Assuming that the model parameters can be categorised into a priori known and unknown categories, we determine the values and associated uncertainties of the unknown parameters. We validate the inverse problem on synthetic datasets generated from a known baseline parameter set, a common approach in such studies ( Bürger et al. 2023 ; Liu et al. 2024a ) . The resulting re-estimated parameters and their confidence intervals are calculated from the synthetic dataset. Using relative practical identifiability, we use a genetic algorithm to propose optimal data sampling schedules. Further, we employ sensitivity analysis to determine which parameters drove significant differences in population dynamics. Finally, informed by the sensitivity and identifiability analysis results, we propose a simpler model that produces similar dynamics. Our second aim is to model bacterial adaptation in a controlled setting. Researchers often use long-term evolutionary experiments (LTEE) to study these phenomena ( Lenski 2017 ; Lenski 2023 ) . LTEE involves the culture of numerous, initially identical, bacterial populations. Periodically subcultured populations in the LTEE allow the bacteria to proliferate continuously, resulting in many generations. By exposing subsets of these isolated cultures to fixed stressors, their development is guided by those selection pressures. The bacteria, in turn, will evolve different dynamics to offset the stressors. In a differential equation model, adaptation across generations can be thought of as bacteria changing the values of their fixed model parameters, or through generic functions that interpolate between conditions ( Lewkiewicz et al. 2022 ) . Assuming our model’s inverse problem is well-posed, experimental data could be used to perform the inverse problem at different generations of the LTEE, and then measure the various parameter values. However, how these parameter values change in this scenario is spontaneous, and there is no measurement of how