Collaborating with GenAI: Incentives and Replacements
Boaz Taitler, Omer Ben-Porat · 2025
Read Collaborating with GenAI: Incentives and Replacements by Boaz Taitler, Omer Ben-Porat (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-20213.txt.
Introduction
Boaz Taitler and Omer Ben-Porat model how generative AI changes teamwork when a manager can use it to replace people, in this 2025 arXiv paper. Workers on a shared project can lean on the technology to do more, or to coast. A manager, meanwhile, picks who stays on the team, with the AI filling in for everyone else.
Their math yields sharp warnings. The AI can push workers to give no effort at all, even when the AI is nearly useless. Picking the best team turns out to be a hard computing problem, though the authors give an efficient method for near-linear cases. They also show that dropping a low-value worker can start a cascade that tanks the whole project. Computer trials back up the theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Boaz Taitler, Omer Ben-Porat |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-20213
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Collaborating with GenAI: Incentives and Replacements Boaz Taitler, Omer Ben-Porat Abstract The rise of Generative AI (GenAI) is reshaping how workers contribute to shared projects. While workers can use GenAI to boost productivity or reduce effort, managers may use it to replace some workers entirely. We present a theoretical framework to analyze how GenAI affects collaboration in such settings. In our model, the manager selects a team to work on a shared task, with GenAI substituting for unselected workers. Each worker selects how much effort to exert, and incurs a cost that increases with the level of effort. We show that GenAI can lead workers to exert no effort, even if GenAI is almost ineffective. We further show that the manager’s optimization problem is NP-complete, and provide an efficient algorithm for the special class of (almost-) linear instances. Our analysis shows that even workers with low individual value may play a critical role in sustaining overall output, and excluding such workers can trigger a cascade. Finally, we conduct extensive simulations to illustrate our theoretical findings. 1 Introduction Generative AI has transformed how individuals approach their work, allowing workers to create and refine content with significantly less time and effort. The growing availability of powerful generative AI tools at minimal cost has made them widely accessible and increasingly embedded in everyday tasks. As a result, workers often rely on these tools either to assist them or to complete parts of the work on their behalf. This development raises an important question: how much effort are workers still contributing, and how much of the work is effectively being handled by AI? When applied to a new task, generative AI can serve two distinct roles. First, it can augment a worker’s effort, enabling them to contribute more effectively than they would unaided. Second, it can substitute for parts of the worker’s labor, allowing them to engage less or even not at all with certain aspects of the task. This distinction has implications for concerns about misuse and over-reliance. In educational settings, for example, students may use generative AI to complete assignments without engaging with the material itself [ 31 , 12 ] . In hiring, excessive reliance on AI-driven tools has been linked to the amplification of existing biases [ 7 ] . Consider a scenario where a manager must assemble a team to work on a shared project, with the outcome to be divided among the workers and the manager. If AI can surpass a worker’s output, or if the worker chooses to rely primarily on AI without investing meaningful effort, the manager may prefer to replace that worker with AI, retaining a larger share of the benefit. Growing attention highlights how AI is beginning to replace human workers, with early cases of layoffs linked to generative AI [ 39 , 35 , 32 ] . These developments raise growing concerns about how the availability of generative AI is reshaping incentives around effort, inclusion, and replacement. Although there is a growing body of work on the capabilities and performance of generative tools, much less is known about how access to these tools affects workers’ incentives to exert effort, or how replacing a worker with AI impacts the overall outcome and the behavior of remaining workers. This prompts two critical questions: Will individuals continue to invest effort when they can offload tasks to AI? And should those coordinating group efforts replace some workers with generative AI, and if so, whom? Our contribution Our contribution is twofold. The first is conceptual: we present a stylized model that captures team interplay with generative AI. There are two types of participants in our game. The first type represents workers working on a project that generates revenue, or contributors collaborating on a shared product. We refer to this type more generally as players. Each player chooses how much effort to invest, incurring a corresponding cost, and whether to use generative AI to assist with their work. The players collaborate on a shared task that produces a collective benefit, which is then divided among them. Importantly, the productivity of each player increases the total benefit, thereby improving the outcome for all participants. The other participant type is the manager, who selects a subset of players to work on the task. The manager receives a portion of the shared benefit and may also utilize generative AI to perform the tasks of players who are not selected. Motivated by the widespread availability of powerful commercial tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini offered under free or low-cost plans, we assume that generative AI is freely accessible to both the manager and the players. Our second contribution is technical. We begin by comparing player behavior under two settings: one in which players cannot use generative AI, and another in which they are required to use it. This comparison shows that in equilibrium, generative AI can incentivize players to exert no effort, even when GenAI’s effectiveness is negligible. We then turn to the computational challenge of identifying the optimal coalition from the manager’s perspective. We show that this problem is NP-complete and provide an efficient algorithm for the special case where the collective benefit is nearly linear in the players’ contributions. We next analyze the stability of the optimal coalition and show that it is brittle: it may include players whose marginal contribution is nearly zero, yet whose removal is detrimental. Finally, we conduct simulations to analyze the properties of optimal coalitions. We demonstrate that coalitions tend to be either large or small, but rarely medium. 1.1 Related Work Our work is inspired by the emerging body of research at the intersection of foundation models and game theory [ 30 , 21 , 10 , 14 ] . This literature examines the impact of generative AI on user welfare and utility in the context of competition [ 38 , 19 ] , content diversity [ 30 ] , and applications inspired by social choice theory [ 5 ] and mechanism design [ 10 , 36 ] . From a conceptual perspective, our work relates to the literature on coalition formation [ 1 ] , which encompasses both strategic considerations for forming stable coalitions [ 4 , 37 ] and algorithmic approaches to learning optimal coalitions [ 9 , 33 ] . Related themes also appear in the literature on credit assignment and resource allocation among agents [ 11 , 2 , 6 ] . Our work is also related to the literature on public goods games [ 22 , 20 ] , which model scenarios where multiple players contribute to a shared cause while incurring a personal cost. This line of work includes studies on strategic behavior and free-riding [ 8 ] , computational aspects of equilibrium computation [ 13 ] , and incentive mechanisms to promote altruistic behavior [ 42 ] . Delegation games [ 26 , 34 ] , where a human delegates decision-making authority to an AI agent, is also close in spirit. Also related is the line of work on deferring tasks to AI [ 16 , 25 , 18 , 17 , 27 ] , which is often linked to concerns about AI alignment and robustness to human