Probing evolution of Long GRB properties through their cosmic formation history This work benefited from the following software: Mathematica ( Mathematica ) , Scipy ( 2020SciPy-NMeth ) , Matplotlib ( Hunter:2007 ) .
Nikita S. Khatiya, Maria Giovanna Dainotti, Aditya Narendra, Dhruv S. Bal, Aleksander Ł. Lenart, Dieter H. Hartmann · 2025
Read Probing evolution of Long GRB properties through their cosmic formation history This work benefited from the following software: Mathematica ( Mathematica ) , Scipy ( 2020SciPy-NMeth ) , Matplotlib ( Hunter:2007 ) . by Nikita S. Khatiya, Maria Giovanna Dainotti, Aditya Narendra, Dhruv S. Bal, Aleksander Ł. Lenart, Dieter H. Hartmann (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-20093.txt.
Introduction
Nikita Khatiya and co-authors test whether long gamma-ray bursts change across cosmic time in a 2025 astrophysics paper. These huge stellar explosions should trace where stars form, yet at low redshift their rate rises above the star formation curve. The team gathered burst data from the Swift observatory and ground telescopes. They then asked whether the bursts' own properties drift with the age of the universe.
Three cases were compared: no change at all, a widening beam angle over time, and a simple power-law drift. The no-change case failed outright. Beam drift and power-law drift each moved closer but still fell short of a good match. Something else, perhaps a distinct faint burst class, must fill the gap.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nikita S. Khatiya, Maria Giovanna Dainotti, Aditya Narendra, Dhruv S. Bal, Aleksander Ł. Lenart, Dieter H. Hartmann |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-20093
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Probing evolution of Long GRB properties through their cosmic formation history This work benefited from the following software: Mathematica ( Mathematica ) , Scipy ( 2020SciPy-NMeth ) , Matplotlib ( Hunter:2007 ) . Nikita S. Khatiya, Maria Giovanna Dainotti, Aditya Narendra, Dhruv S. Bal, Aleksander Ł. Lenart, Dieter H. Hartmann Abstract The astrophysics of Long GRB (LGRB) progenitors as well as possible cosmological evolution in their properties still poses many open questions. Previous studies suggest that the LGRB rate density (LGRB-RD) follows the cosmic star formation rate density (SFRD) only at high- z z and attribute this to the metallicity evolution of progenitor stars. For low z z , opinions differ on whether the uptick in the LGRB-RD is due to a distinct class of low-luminosity GRBs or perhaps even a different progenitor subclass. To investigate these questions, we utilize data from the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory and ground-based observatories (redshift). To test the hypothesis that the observations can be mapped (with/without evolution) to the well-established cosmic SFRD, we consider three cases: no evolution, beaming angle evolution, and a simple power-law evolution. The comparison shows that the ‘no evolution’ case can be ruled out. Our study highlights that the beaming angle evolution or the simple power law evolution are also not sufficient to obtain a good match between the LGRB-RD and SFRD. Rather, the inclusion of multiple evolving properties of LGRBs in combination appears to be required to match the two rate densities in their entirety. I Introduction Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are transients detected at cosmological scales, with spectroscopic redshift ( z_{spec} ) observed up to \approx 8.2 ( Tanvir2009Nature ) and photometric redshift ( z_{photo} ) detected up to \approx 9.4 ( Cucchiara et al. 2011 ) . In the initial stages of GRB explosion, the relativistic jets produce high-energy photons (mainly X-rays and \gamma -rays), often called the prompt emission phase. The duration corresponding to this prompt phase can be measured by burst detectors such as Swift -Burst Alert Telescope (BAT, Barthelmy et al. 2005 ), commonly called the \mathrm{T_{90}} duration. The physical interpretation of \mathrm{T_{90}} is unclear; thus, alternative definitions of the duration of the GRB with respect to the progenitor systems have been proposed ( 2007ApJ...655L..25Z ; 2025JHEAp..45..325Z ) . Following the prompt phase, the jet decelerates and becomes capable of interacting with the circumburst medium, giving rise to emission in low-energy bands spanning almost the entire electromagnetic spectrum, often called the GRB afterglow emission phase. Observationally, these bursts come in two flavors: Short ( \mathrm{T_{90}<2s} ) and Long GRBs ( \mathrm{T_{90}>2s} ) ( 1993ApJ...413L.101K ) . The majority of observations indicate that the core collapse of massive stars results in LGRBs (e.g. 1993ApJ...405..273W ; 2003Natur.423..847H ; 2003ApJ...591L..17S ; 2006ARA&A..44..507W ; 2013ApJ...776...98X ), whereas, the merger of BH-Neutron star (NS) or NS-NS systems results in Short GRBs (SGRBs) (e.g. 1992ApJ...395L..83N ; 1992ApJ...392L...9D ; 2007PhR...442..166N ; 2017ApJ...846L...5G ; 2017ApJ...848L..14G ; Abbott et al. 2017 ). However, the exact mechanism that drives the prompt emission and its duration is not well understood. Localization of LGRBs has shown that many of them occur in star-forming regions ( 2006Natur.441..463F ; Blanchard et al. 2016 ; 2017MNRAS.467.1795L ) while SGRBs are found in elliptical galaxies, i.e. regions with less active star formation ( 2005Natur.437..851G ) . There are exceptions to this scenario presented in the following studies: Cenko et al. 2008 ; Berger 2010 ; 2012ApJ...758...92L ; 2016ApJ...821..132L . In general, these different progenitor locations of SGRBs and LGRBs enable us to understand their connection with the SFR in the Universe. Due to the short lifetime of massive stars ( \lessapprox 40 Myr), it is expected that LGRBs follow cosmic SFRD closely in time ( 2008ApJ...673L.119K ; 2022A&A...666A..14S ) , whereas SGRBs have delayed SFRD due to the time required to undergo mergers ( 2006A&A...453..823G ; 2016A&A...594A..84G ) . Multiple studies have extensively explored LGRB-RD and its comparison with SFRD. A quick tabular summary of the same is provided in Table 3 of the Appendix. We provide a synopsis of their findings in three parts: LGRBs are SFR tracers at all z , and the discrepancy of LGRB-RD with respect to SFRD at high-z and low-z, respectively. Firstly, the LGRBs as SFR tracers have been studied by 2006ApJ...642..371K ; Pescalli:2015yva , and 2006ApJ...651..142H till z\sim 6. This match has been explained by the collapsar origin of LGRBs. The LGRB-RD at high z is considered to be a biased tracer of star formation but with a shallower decline compared to SFRD ( 2002ApJ...574..554L ; 2004ApJ...609..935Y ; 2007JCAP...07..003G ; 2008ApJ...673L.119K ; Butler et al. 2010 ; 2010MNRAS.406.1944W ) . These studies conclude that LGRB-RD matches well with SFRD at lower redshifts, particularly below z \sim 2. However, the comparatively higher LGRB-RD at high- z has been explained by metallicity dependence and evolving initial mass function (IMF). Lastly, the low- z excess in LGRB-RD compared to SFRD was shown for the first time by 2015ApJS..218...13Y for z < 1. Hints of this excess, along with low-luminosity bursts, were previously seen in 2008MNRAS.388.1487L . 2015ApJ...806...44P ; 2017ApJ...850..161T ; 2019MNRAS.488.5823L ; 2021ApJ...908...83T ; 2022MNRAS.513.1078D found similar excess at the low- z end of the LGRB-RD. Possible reasons to address this excess are unclear GRB classification such as contamination of low luminosity GRBs (LLGRBs), sample and instrument threshold selection effects. Thus, to address these different perspectives about the mismatch and understand other selection effects important in mapping the cosmic star formation to cosmic LGRB formation, we are studying the LGRB-RD and its implications with SFRD. This study uses LGRBs with z estimates obtained from various space and ground-based observatories. This study advances the work of 2013ApJ...774..157D related to the luminosity function (LF) of LGRB with X-ray plateaus. We build on this study by updating the LF with a more recent sample of LGRB with X-ray plateaus. Additionally, for the first time, we explore the LGRB-RD for this sample and its comparison to SFRD.The reason for selecting LGRBs with only X-ray plateau features is the homogeneity of the sample, the reduced scatter in correlations compared to established within the prompt emission ( 2015ApJ...806...44P ; 2024ApJ...963L..12P ) , and to compare the previous LGRB-RD results for the LGRBs with optical plateau emission ( 2024ApJ...967L..30D ) . Moreover, we also derive LGRB-RD from SFRD using the Drake equation-like approach ( 2016ApJ...823..154G ) and finally, compare the LGRB-RD from the two approaches. Recent James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations of z > 9 galaxies have shown modification in the SFRD at higher z values ( 2024ApJ...976L..16M ; 2024MNRAS.533.3222D ) . More observations of high- z galaxies and GRBs will facilitate a better comparison between LGRB-RD and SFRD at high- z . In this study, we do not consider the modification in SFRD from the recent JWST observations but compare LGRB-RD with previous SFRD models in the literature (e.g., 2006ApJ...651..142H ; 2014ARA&A..52..415M ). Our analysis proceeds as follows. \lx@sectionsign II provides details of our sample selection. \lx@sectionsign III covers the methods used to study LGRB-LF and LGRB-RD. The main results are presented in \lx@sectionsign IV and \lx@sectionsign V . Finally, \lx@sectionsign VI gives our implications and conclusion. Throughout this analysis we use the cosmic concordance cosmology: \mathrm{H_{0}} = 70 \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}\ Mpc^{-1}}