Correcting model error bias in estimations of neuronal dynamics from time series observations
Ian Williams, Joseph D. Taylor, Alain Nogaret · 2025
Read Correcting model error bias in estimations of neuronal dynamics from time series observations by Ian Williams, Joseph D. Taylor, Alain Nogaret (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19948.txt.
Introduction
Ian Williams and co-authors fix bias in brain cell models built from voltage records in a 2025 paper. Models fitted to data can replay a neurons firing, but hidden channel flows stay hard to reach. Stand-in models use wrong rules, so their hidden flows drift from truth.
The team couples a classic channel model with a learning reservoir that patches its output. Trained on a reference cells voltage and drive current, the hybrid learns the gap. Of six layouts tried, one best rebuilt both the voltage trace and the hidden channel flows. The trick may one day help read true cell traits from records alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ian Williams, Joseph D. Taylor, Alain Nogaret |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19948
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Correcting model error bias in estimations of neuronal dynamics from time series observations Ian Williams, Joseph D. Taylor, Alain Nogaret Abstract Neuron models built from experimental data have successfully predicted observed voltage oscillations within and beyond training range. A tantalising prospect is the possibility of estimating the unobserved dynamics of ion channels which is largely inaccessible to experiment, from membrane voltage recordings. The main roadblock here is our lack of knowledge of the equations governing biological neurons which forces us to rely on surrogate models and parameter estimates biassed by model error. Error correction algorithms are therefore needed to infer both observed and unobserved dynamics, and ultimately the actual parameters of a biological neuron. Here we use a recurrent neural network to correct the outputs of a surrogate Hodgkin-Huxley (HH) model. The reservoir-surrogate HH model hybrid was trained on the voltage oscillations of a reference HH model and its driving current waveform. Out of the six reservoir-surrogate model architectures investigated, we identify one that most accurately recovers the reference membrane voltage and ion channel dynamics. The reservoir was thus effective in correcting model error in an externally driven nonlinear oscillator and in reconstructing the dynamics of both observed and unobserved state variables from the reference model mimicking an actual neuron. Introduction Building models from data is important for constructing digital twins of complex or chaotic dynamical systems such as neuroelectronic circuits [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] or the weather [ 4 ] , and inferring information hidden from experiment. Takens’ embedding theorem [ 5 ] underpins the idea that a model can be fully reconstructed from the information contained in observations of a dynamical system over a finite time interval [ 6 ] . As a result, a number of statistical [ 7 , 8 ] and gradient descent methods [ 9 , 10 ] have been developed that have successfully re-synchronized systems of nonlinear equations to time series data to estimate model parameters in biology [ 1 , 9 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] , chemistry [ 14 ] , or model initial conditions in weather forecasting [ 4 ] . A challenge specific to neuroscience is the lack of knowledge about the precise equations of neurons and networks [ 15 , 11 ] . As a result, synchronizing a surrogate nonlinear model to data often yields multi-valued parameters that fail to represent the underlying biological processes they are meant to describe [ 16 , 17 ] . Training models to accurately describe the dynamics of underlying processes calls for correcting model error. Model-free approaches [ 18 , 19 ] that rely on recurrent neural networks have provided an alternative approach to successfully predicting the oscillations of chaotic systems. Recently Pathak et al. [ 20 ] have shown that embedding a model within a recurrent neural network can further extend the prediction window of chaotic oscillations. The embedded model is used to generate an initial approximate prediction that the reservoir is trained to correct. This hybrid computing approach successfully compensated for the error in the Lorenz oscillator model showing that it outperforms the accuracy of either the model or the reservoir used in isolation. This analysis was extended to other chaotic oscillators by Duncan and Räth [ 21 ] , demonstrating that the hybrid approach performs well across a range of self-sustaining oscillators. An important class of related systems are nonlinear oscillators driven by an external force. For example, the oscillations of HH neurons [ 22 ] and networks are often driven by the current protocol of a current clamp or synaptic inputs. It remains an open question whether hybrid approaches can effectively correct the errors of surrogate neuron models, and whether they are suitable for predicting the dynamics of both observed and unobserved state variables. For example, the state of a biological neuron is described by the knowledge of its membrane voltage and the state of its ionic gates at any given time. The membrane voltage however is the only variable that may be measured. This means that information on the dynamics of ionic gates must be inferred indirectly from delayed measurements of the membrane voltage [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] . The embedding procedure, which reconstructs the state vector from delayed voltage measurements, maximizes information transfer from data to model when both observability [ 26 ] and identifiability [ 27 ] criteria are satisfied and the dimension of the embedding space is at least twice the dimension of the state vector [ 5 , 28 , 29 ] . Applying model error correction in this setting therefore imposes additional constraints on the recurrent networks used for hybrid modelling, in particular their capacity to retain information over a sequence of delayed measurements greater than the dimension of the state vector. Here we adapt the hybrid reservoir-model approach to correct error in surrogate models of a nonlinear neuronal oscillator driven by an external time dependent current. During the training phase, the reservoir-HH model hybrid was stimulated both by the reference membrane voltage and the current protocol used to elicit this voltage while the output weights were optimized. During the prediction phase, the reservoir-HH model was stimulated by the current protocol only to predict the membrane voltage oscillations within and beyond the training range. We investigated six reservoir-HH model architectures and four types of surrogate models incorporating deliberate error in their parameters to determine the best error correcting architecture. The results were validated by comparing the prediction accuracy of hybrid architectures to those of the surrogate model, and the reference data. The best reservoir-HH model architecture was found to successfully recover both the membrane voltage oscillations and the unobserved gate dynamics of the reference model. Predictions were also remarkably stable in response to rapid changes in frequency or amplitude of the forcing current. In contrast predictions of the stand-alone reservoir were often driven to saturation by fast or abrupt changes in the current drive. We discuss the contradictory expectations of a long reservoir retention time to correct error in the unobserved gate variables, against the need for a short reservoir retention time to respond to fast stimulation. The solution of combining the reservoir with a surrogate model proved effective in using their complementary kinetic. In addition, the hybrid architecture was very effective in correcting model error when multiple parameters were detuned by four-orders of magnitude from their reference value. At vanishingly small model error, the prediction accuracy of hybrid architectures was however limited by intrinsic reservoir noise. The hybrid approach demonstrates the ability to infer the complete dynamic state of a neuron from approximate conductance-based models. Methods Neuron models We consider a reference model of the form d\mathbf{x}/dt=\mathbf{F}(\mathbf{x}(t),\mathbf{p},I(t)) where \mathbf{x}(t) is the vector representing the neuron state at instant t , \mathbf{p} is the set of model parameters (see Methods), and I(t) is the current protocol driving the neuron oscillations. The state vector \mathbf{x}(t) has four components: the neuron membrane voltage V(t) which is observable, and the gate variables of the Hodgkin-Huxley model m(t) , h(t) and n(t) [ 30 ] which are unobservable. This model was used to generate a reference voltage time series V_{mem}(t) that will be used to train recurrent networks