The Economic Complexity of the Roman Empire

Matteo Mazzamurro, Petra Heřmánková, Michele Coscia, Tom Brughmans · 2025

Read The Economic Complexity of the Roman Empire by Matteo Mazzamurro, Petra Heřmánková, Michele Coscia, Tom Brughmans (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19892.txt.

Introduction

Matteo Mazzamurro, Petra Hermankova, Michele Coscia, and Tom Brughmans apply a modern economics tool to the ancient world in this two thousand twenty-five paper. Economic complexity estimates an economy's productive capabilities from what it makes, and predicts future growth. How complexity evolves over very long spans is unknown. The authors measure it for Roman provinces using inscriptions: short texts on durable material that mention occupations, tied to the places the inscribed objects were found.

Across the empire's first four centuries, the most economically complex provinces overlap remarkably, and statistically significantly, with the most complex countries of today. The authors offer no explanation for this persistence across two millennia. They read it as evidence that productive capabilities, once built, are extraordinarily durable, and correspondingly hard to build from scratch. The study links archaeology, network science, and development economics in one dataset.

Catalog record

CREATORMatteo Mazzamurro, Petra Heřmánková, Michele Coscia, Tom Brughmans
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19892

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Economic Complexity of the Roman Empire Matteo Mazzamurro, Petra Heřmánková, Michele Coscia, Tom Brughmans Abstract Economic complexity is a powerful tool to estimate the productive capabilities and future growth of modern economies. Little is known of how economic complexity evolves over long periods in history. In this paper, we use archaeological evidence from the Roman Empire in the form of short texts preserved on a durable material (i.e. inscriptions) to estimate the economic complexity of the various provinces of the empire. By connecting the occupations listed in the text of inscriptions with the location in which the inscribed objects were found we can estimate that the most complex areas during the first four centuries of the Roman Empire have a remarkable and statistically significant overlap with the most complex countries today. While we lack an explanation for the reason of the preservation of economic complexity through the ages, this evidence provides a suggestion about how difficult the development of economic capabilities might be. keywords archaeology, economic complexity, Roman empire, network science, digital humanities Introduction Economic complexity has emerged in the literature as a way to estimate a country’s productive knowledge [ 1 , 2 ] . Normally estimated as the Economic Complexity Index (ECI) – of which there are multiple alternative definitions [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] – it has gained relevance because it is able to predict not only economic growth [ 6 ] , but also development trajectories – which economic activities will appear where next [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . Other applications involve discussing income inequality [ 10 ] , the green transition [ 11 ] , and more [ 12 ] . Given how much of our society’s current and future challenges can be informed by economic complexity, we should devote some attention to understanding how we can affect it – specifically how it evolves. While most of the cited works – and more [ 13 ] – study ECI changes in the short and medium term, no one has had the opportunity to do so on long historical time scales. In this paper, we propose to take a long term – millennia-wide – look at economic complexity. By exploiting archaeological data on the Roman Empire, we can create the most accurate picture to date about its occupational and economic structure. In turn, this picture is instrumental in allowing us to estimate the economic complexity of the empire’s provinces, identifying which areas of the empire contributed most to its complexity. Finally, we can connect the ancient economic complexity to the modern one. The Roman Empire was a continental polity, which spanned 36 modern countries. We have an ECI estimation for each of these modern countries based on contemporary trade data and we can correlate it with the ECI based on archaeological data. This work is an interdisciplinary effort, putting together network science and archaeology – a novel approach that has been gaining increasing attention in the past years [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] . The performance of the economy of the Mediterranean world under Roman imperial rule has been studied through the quantitative analysis integrating archaeological evidence, such as pottery, coins, and most recently, inscriptions, with economic analysis [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] . We build on previous work that reconstructed the occupational profile of the Roman Empire from inscriptions [ 22 ] . We use the largest digital dataset of Latin inscriptions with over 500,000 records as our main source of evidence [ 23 , 24 ] . These inscriptions contain mentions of ancient occupations, as well as spatiotemporal data to build the occupational profile of the Roman Empire. After producing the most accurate to date picture of the occupations-based economic structure of the Roman Empire and estimating the ECI of each province, we find that there is a weak but marginally significant ECI correlation for modern countries, between the index as calculated with archaeological data in Roman imperial times and its version with modern trade data – data recorded around two millennia later. While we are unable to discern whether this correlation is due to long-term effects of economic complexity or to exogenous factors such as geographical positioning or natural resources [ 25 ] , this result hints at potential implications for development policies. Regardless of the causes, relative economic complexity rankings appear to be enduring, meaning that – without a conscious and possibly global effort – the income disparities between developed and developing countries might linger indefinitely, as these might be fostered by enduring differences in economic complexity [ 26 ] . Results Occupational Structure We analyze the digitized textual content of more than 525,870 Latin inscriptions created during the Roman Empire. Most inscriptions date to the first four centuries CE [ 23 ] , a period that this study focuses on as it covers most of the duration of the Latin-speaking western Roman Empire. Inscriptions are short texts surviving on an object made from a durable material and were created for a variety of purposes: to mark someone’s grave and provide details of their life, to celebrate their life achievements and bestow honours, to regulate, to inform, but also to materialize an insult, or joke, or to invoke magical powers. Upon computer-assisted reading of these texts, we discovered 8,475 inscriptions that mention at least one occupation (from one to 30 mentions of occupations in a single inscription). Of these, 37% ( 3,116 ) are funerary inscriptions, reporting on the deceased person’s profession [ 27 ] , and 11,4% are honorific texts ( 952 ) typically listing the life achievements of the honourand, including their occupation, known as the cursus honorum [ 28 ] . Most inscriptions have a known findspot identified with latitude and longitude coordinates, which allows us to precisely geolocate 10,353 occurrences of 512 unique occupations throughout the Empire – under the assumption that mobility during the Roman Empire was less frequent than nowadays [ 29 ] . Detailed evaluation of ancient mobility using epigraphic sources has shown that most people migrated locally, with only a small group of highly mobile individuals [ 30 ] . We provide more information about the raw data in the Materials & Methods section. Figure 1: (Log) Number of occupations (x axis) in a given province (y axis). (a) Raw counts from inscriptions; (b) bias-corrected counts. The darker the red hue the more occupations were in a given province – color map consistent across the two figures. The rows and the columns are sorted by their respective sums. We count the number of occurrences of a given occupation per Roman province. We use the Roman province borders from ca. 200 CE digitised by The Ancient World Mapping Centre [ 31 ] and edited by Adam Pažout in 2023). We exclude provinces east of the Euphrates which were only occupied for a very short period, and therefore, we assume, they did not contribute to the overall economic complexity of the Roman Empire. All boundaries were clipped to modern coastlines. Inclusion of Italian regiones enhances granularity of the results in the Italian peninsula. Unfortunately, a similar finer division is not entirely possible

Read the complete text