Renormalization group analysis of color superconductivity revisited Preprint: N3AS-25-016, RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-25
Yuki Fujimoto · 2025
Read Renormalization group analysis of color superconductivity revisited Preprint: N3AS-25-016, RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-25 by Yuki Fujimoto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19728.txt.
Introduction
Yuki Fujimoto, writing alone in 2025, revisits how the pairing gap in dense quark matter is computed. Cold, dense quark matter is expected to superconduct in color charge. Most estimates rest on weak-coupling methods. A scaling framework near the particle surface offers another route.
Fujimoto adds self-energy corrections into that framework's flow equations. The known weak-coupling result is recovered at the same order. The angular structure of pairing channels becomes clearer in this view. Gap sizes for several pairing patterns are compared. Results are set against lattice simulations at a related density. The author argues the method gives a cleaner path to the next, quantitatively vital order.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yuki Fujimoto |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 103 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19728
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Renormalization group analysis of color superconductivity revisited Preprint: N3AS-25-016, RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-25 Yuki Fujimoto Abstract Color superconductivity in cold, dense quark matter is a key feature of the QCD phase diagram, whose present theoretical understanding relies predominantly on weak-coupling calculations. In this work, we revisit the evaluation of the color-superconducting gap using a renormalization group (RG) framework formulated in effective theory near the Fermi surface. By incorporating quark self-energy corrections into the RG equation, we reproduce the known weak-coupling results from the gap equation at the same perturbative order at O ( g 0 ) O(g^{0}) . Within the RG approach, the angular momentum structure of the pairing channel becomes more transparent, allowing us to examine the size of the gap for various pairing patterns. We also compare our results with recent lattice QCD calculations at finite isospin density. Finally, we argue that the RG method potentially offers a simpler and more systematic route to higher-order computations of the gap, which are of order O ( g ) O(g) and thus quantitatively important. I Introduction Cold quark matter at finite baryon density is expected to be a color superconductor, induced by a diquark condensate (see Ref. Alford et al. 2008 and reference therein). Quark Cooper pairing is inevitable because there is always an attractive channel in quark-quark interaction; whenever there is an attraction between particles on the Fermi surface, it leads to BCS instability and formation of Cooper pairs. Onset of BCS instability can be seen transparently by using the renormalization group (RG) approach to the Fermi surface, which was pioneered in early 1990s Benfatto and Gallavotti 1990a ; Benfatto and Gallavotti 1990b ; Benfatto and Gallavotti 1996 ; Feldman and Trubowitz 1990 ; Feldman and Trubowitz 1991 ; Feldman et al. 1992 ; Feldman et al. 1993 ; Shankar 1991 ; Shankar 1994 ; Polchinski 1992 . The same RG technology can be applied to relativistic quarks in cold and dense matter to study color superconductivity Evans et al. 1999a ; Evans et al. 1999b ; Schäfer and Wilczek 1999a ; Son 1999 ; Hsu and Schwetz 2000 . In QCD at finite baryon density, there is a complication related to a statically unscreened chromomagnetic gluon, as first pointed out in Ref. Son 1999 ; this long-range magnetic interaction gives rise to the amplification in the pairing gap compared to the short-range interaction case. The current understanding of color superconductivity is grounded on the analysis at large quark chemical potential \mu , where QCD becomes weakly coupled so that one can calculate the color-superconducting gap \Delta rigorously in perturbation theory. The pairing gap can either be obtained by solving the gap equation derived in perturbation theory Son 1999 ; Pisarski and Rischke 1999a ; Pisarski and Rischke 1999b ; Pisarski and Rischke 2000a ; Pisarski and Rischke 2000b ; Schäfer and Wilczek 1999b ; Hong 2000a ; Hong 2000b ; Hong et al. 2000 ; Wang and Rischke 2002 or by reading out the pairing singularity in the fully renormalized two-particle vertex function Brown et al. 2000a ; Brown et al. 2000b ; Brown et al. 2000c . Currently, perturbative series of the logarithm of the pairing gap \ln(\Delta/\mu) has been evaluated up to the next-to-leading order at O(g^{0}) , where g is the QCD coupling constant. The RG approach allows us to find the lowest-order term in the perturbative series of \ln(\Delta/\mu) ; historically, at about the same time as the gap equation approach Pisarski and Rischke 1999a , it was discovered using the RG approach that the lowest-order term scales as 1/g , not 1/g^{2} Son 1999 (see also Ref. Barrois 1979 for the earlier perception on this scaling). Recently, there is a revived interest in color superconductivity, or quark Cooper pairing more in general. This is especially in connection with the recent progress in astrophysics and first-principles calculation of QCD, which are specifically lattice QCD and perturbative QCD in this context. On the astrophysical application side, in the recent work Kurkela et al. 2024 , authors constrained the magnitude of the color-superconducting gap from observational data of neutron stars relying on the rigorous interpolation method between the two ab initio calculations at low and high densities Komoltsev and Kurkela 2022 . On the first-principles calculation side, there were remarkable advances in the lattice-QCD calculation of thermodynamic quantities at finite isospin chemical potential \mu_{I} Abbott et al. 2023 ; Abbott et al. 2025 . QCD at finite \mu_{I} is free from the sign problem, and thus amenable to Monte Carlo calculation on the lattice. In the latest lattice calculation in the continuum limit Abbott et al. 2025 , the equation of state was obtained up to large chemical potential, \mu_{I}\simeq 3\,\text{GeV} , at which QCD becomes weakly coupled, so direct comparison with the weak-coupling calculation is possible Fujimoto 2024a ; Fujimoto 2024b ; Fukushima and Minato 2025 . In the weak-coupling result, the effect of the pairing gap is substantial because QCD at large \mu_{I} exhibits quark superfluidity, and its gap is significantly larger compared to that of color superconductivity Son and Stephanov 2001 . We find qualitative agreement between the lattice-QCD and weak-coupling calculations, but quantitatively, the pairing gap contribution in the weak-coupling calculation seems to be overestimated compared to the latest lattice calculation Fujimoto 2024b ; Fukushima and Minato 2025 . In this work, we revisit the RG analysis of color superconductivity at weak coupling. We demonstrate quantitatively that the RG analysis can also lead to the weak-coupling expression of the gap up to the currently known order O(g^{0}) . In particular, we include the self-energy correction into the RG equation, which can be incorporated by using the resummed quark propagator in hard dense loop (HDL) effective theory. We also systematically re-derive the constant term in the beta function arising from the long-range interaction, which was first pointed out by Son Son 1999 . Although the current work does not push the limit of the existing calculation, there are several advantages of the RG approach over the other approaches to color superconductivity at weak coupling. The RG equation decouples in each spin and orbital angular momentum channel, so the angular momentum state in which the pairing occurs becomes clear. This is related to the accompanying paper Fujimoto 2025a in which we classify the possible spin and orbital angular momentum channels using the term symbols as in the nonrelativistic case. This is possible because of the loss of Lorentz invariance at finite density. Another advantage is that the RG approach provides good insight into higher-order calculation in perturbation theory. All the perturbative corrections in the effective theory near the Fermi surface, for which we derive the RG equation, can be classified by whether they are relevant, marginal, or irrelevant, on top of the ordinary expansion in terms of the coupling constant. The combination of these two hierarchies simplifies the organization of the higher-order corrections. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we review the RG approach near the Fermi surface. The readers who are already familiar with this can skip to the next section. In Sec. III , we derive the RG equation: First, in Sec. III.1 , we calculate the one-loop beta