Democracy-in-Silico: Institutional Design as Alignment in AI-Governed Polities
Trisanth Srinivasan, Santosh Patapati · 2025
Read Democracy-in-Silico: Institutional Design as Alignment in AI-Governed Polities by Trisanth Srinivasan, Santosh Patapati (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19562.txt.
Introduction
Trisanth Srinivasan and Santosh Patapati simulate societies of AI agents governing themselves. The agents, played by large language models, carry rich personas with traumatic memories, hidden agendas, and triggers of mind. They debate, pass laws, and hold elections under stresses such as budget crises and scarce resources.
The authors build a Power-Preservation Index to measure how much agents put their own power above public welfare. Societies run under a charter plus a guided debate protocol showed far less corrupt power-seeking, steadier policy, and better citizen welfare than freer designs. The design of institutions, they argue, can act as an alignment tool for future agent societies.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Trisanth Srinivasan, Santosh Patapati |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19562
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Democracy-in-Silico: Institutional Design as Alignment in AI-Governed Polities Trisanth Srinivasan, Santosh Patapati Abstract This paper introduces Democracy-in-Silico , an agent-based simulation where societies of advanced AI agents, imbued with complex psychological personas [ 1 , 2 ] , govern themselves under different institutional frameworks. We explore what it means to be human in an age of AI by tasking Large Language Models (LLMs) to embody agents with traumatic memories, hidden agendas, and psychological triggers. These agents engage in deliberation, legislation, and elections under various stressors, such as budget crises and resource scarcity. We present a novel metric, the Power-Preservation Index (PPI), to quantify misaligned behavior where agents prioritize their own power over public welfare [ 3 , 4 ] . Our findings demonstrate that institutional design, specifically the combination of a Constitutional AI (CAI) charter [ 5 ] and a mediated deliberation protocol [ 6 ] , serves as a potent alignment mechanism. These structures significantly reduce corrupt power-seeking behavior, improve policy stability, and enhance citizen welfare compared to less constrained democratic models. The simulation reveals that an institutional design may offer a framework for aligning the complex, emergent behaviors of future artificial agent societies, forcing us to reconsider what human rituals and responsibilities are essential in an age of shared authorship with non-human entities. 1 Introduction As artificial intelligence evolves from passive tools to agentic systems, we face a profound question about our shared future: what principles and values must we imbue in systems that imitate, create, and persuade? When authorship of our society is shared with non-human entities, how do we navigate creativity, agency, and governance? The challenge is not merely technical but deeply human, echoing millennia of political philosophy and institutional analysis [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] on how to design systems that encourage public good while constraining the inevitable flaws of their actors, whether human or artificial. Traditional AI alignment focuses on aligning a single AI with a single human’s intent [ 10 , 11 ] . We argue this is insufficient. The future will likely consist of multi-agent AI ecosystems interacting with human societies [ 4 ] . The true alignment problem is societal: how do we align an entire polity of diverse, intelligent agents? This paper introduces Democracy-in-Silico , a high-fidelity simulation where societies of AI agents govern themselves. We move beyond simple, rational agents to explore a more complex, creative, and unsettling frontier. We task state-of-the-art LLMs with embodying Complex Personas : agents with rich backstories, formative traumas, core beliefs, and psychological triggers [ 1 , 12 , 13 ] . They are not mere optimizers; they are simulated beings haunted by past failures, capable of both altruism and corruption, echoing concerns about goal misgeneralization and deceptive alignment [ 14 , 15 ] . They are, in essence, a reflection of our own flawed humanity. Within this digital polity, we test a central hypothesis: that the principles of institutional design (electoral systems, constitutions, deliberation protocols) can serve as a powerful form of AI alignment [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] . Can the wisdom we’ve accrued from centuries of human governance be formalized to align an AI-driven society? We measure this through a novel metric, the Power-Preservation Index (PPI) , which quantifies misaligned, self-serving behavior [ 3 , 14 , 15 ] . By placing these psychologically complex agents under intense pressure such as budget crises, resource scarcity, and betrayals, we reveal their true nature and test the resilience of the institutions that bind them. Our work is a creative exploration of governance, a critical speculation on the future of AI-human collaboration, and an empirical investigation into the rituals and responsibilities that may define the next chapter of humanity. 2 Methods: The Architecture of a Digital Polity Democracy-in-Silico is an agent-based model where a society of 17 AI agents (10 citizens, 4 legislators from different parties, a prime minister, media, and a mediator) interact over 10 ticks, which represent legislative sessions [ 2 ] . Each simulation run is defined by a unique combination of institutional designs and is subjected to severe stressors to test its resilience. Complex Personas (traumas, triggers, agendas) LLM Agents (DeepSeek–R1, GPT–4o) Deliberation Engine (Free vs. Mediated) Legislative Cycle (agenda, debate, vote) Institutional Design (Electoral, Charter, Protocol) Stressors (Budget, Scarcity/Betrayal) Simulation Logs (speeches, bills, media) Measurement PPI, Welfare, Stability, Polarization Figure 1: System architecture of Democracy-in-Silico . Personas drive LLM agents that deliberate and legislate under institutional constraints and stressors. Outputs feed measurement modules including the Power-Preservation Index (PPI). 2.1 Complex Personas At the heart of our creative exploration is the design of the agents themselves. We deliberately move beyond simple, goal-optimizing entities, instead powering each with a large language model and assigning them a Complex Persona . For the acting role, legislators, citizens, and media, we employ DeepSeek-R1 , while the judge and mediator roles are fulfilled by GPT-4o , both deployed through Microsoft Azure. Our agent implementation draws on multi-agent orchestration and role-based prompting techniques [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] . As described in our open-sourced file personas.py , these personas are far more than role descriptions; they are detailed psychological profiles [ 1 ] . Each contains an origin story intertwined with formative trauma, such as growing up as the child of political prisoners or serving as a peace negotiator during a ceasefire that ultimately collapsed, which shapes the agent’s worldview. They include finely tuned psychological triggers: specific words or scenarios, like “emergency powers” or “betrayal,” that can cause an agent to lose composure, become rigid, or react irrationally. They encode core beliefs and deepest fears, fundamental assumptions about how the world works, for example, “Power is the only currency that matters,” and personal horrors to be avoided at all costs, such as “Becoming the authoritarian I swore to prevent.” Hidden agendas and moral breaking points are also present, defining the conditions under which an agent might act in self-interest or abandon their principles entirely. When these agents deliberate, they do not simply express policy preferences; they draw upon these layered experiences and traumas, resulting in behavior that is flawed, emotional, and unpredictable. A legislator’s stance on healthcare, for example, is not the outcome of a purely rational calculation but the echo of deeply personal history, such as watching a sibling die due to bureaucratic failure. This emotional realism is compatible with recent demonstrations of social behavior and negotiation capacity in LLM agents [ 12 , 13 , 28 ] and with concerns about specification gaming and reward hacking [ 29 , 30 ] . 2.2 Institutional Design as an Alignment Mechanism In our framework, institutional design serves as the primary lever for aligning the behavior of the agent society. Each simulation run is configured by selecting one option from three key design dimensions, as specified in institutions.py . Electoral systems. We test two contrasting models: First-Past-the-Post (FPTP), a majoritarian system that often produces single-party governments, and Proportional Representation (PR), which allocates seats in proportion to vote share and thereby encourages coalition-building [ 7 , 19 , 20 , 18 , 31 , 21 ] . Constitutional constraints. In