Optimal Finite-Time Thermodynamics of Effective Two-Level Systems
Alberto Rolandi · 2025
Read Optimal Finite-Time Thermodynamics of Effective Two-Level Systems by Alberto Rolandi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19341.txt.
Introduction
Alberto Rolandi works out in 2025 the best heat to work plans for small two state systems run in finite time. Tiny systems jiggle a lot, so less waste and more work take fine control. Real two state systems come from lumping fine parts, which can hide quantum acts below.
Rolandi lifts a known frame to all drive speeds and to lumped systems with quantum roots. Best plans hinge on how much lumping the two state form needs. Speed caps for any change on such a system fall out of the same math. The work ties lump size to heat cost in a clear way.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alberto Rolandi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19341
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Optimal Finite-Time Thermodynamics of Effective Two-Level Systems Alberto Rolandi Abstract The optimization of the conversion of thermal energy into work and the minimization of dissipation for nano- and mesoscopic systems is a complex challenge because of the important role fluctuations play on the dynamics of small systems. We generalize the work of Esposito et al. EPL 89, 20003 (2010) to optimize at all driving speeds the control needed to extract the maximum amount of work from any effective two-level systems. These emerge when one coarse-grains degrees of freedom, which is often unavoidable to obtain “real-world” two-level systems. In particular, we allow even for the system to have underlying quantum dynamics, as long as these allow for a coarse-graining that leads to a Markovian master equation. We analyze the finite-time thermodynamics of these systems and find the thermodynamically optimal protocols, which depend on the size of the coarse-graining needed to obtain a two-level system. Furthermore, we use these results to derive speed-limits for any transformation performed on an effective two-level system. I. Introduction The optimization of the work cost of physical tasks is a paradigmatic topic in thermodynamics, dating back to the very inception of the field Carnot 1824 . Beyond its self-evident applicative aspects ranging from macroscopic to microscopic scales Carnot 1824 ; Fermi 1956 ; Myers et al. 2022 ; McMahon 2023 , this question also probes the fundamental thermodynamic cost of irreversibility Nernst 1906 ; Kox 2006 ; Benenti et al. 2017 ; Campbell et al. 2025 . The finite-time optimization of work has been extensively studied in systems close to equilibrium Schmiedl and Seifert 2007 ; Salamon and Berry 1983 ; Sivak and Crooks 2012 ; Holubec and Ryabov 2016 ; Dechant and Sakurai 2019 ; Deffner and Bonança 2020 ; Van Vu and Hasegawa 2021 ; Andresen and Salamon 2022 ; Rolandi et al. 2023a ; Van Vu and Saito 2023 ; Campbell et al. 2025 ; Rolandi and Perarnau-Llobet 2023 . Yet, small systems–such as biological molecules or nanoscale devices–can easily be taken far from their equilibrium state, where they show large fluctuations in their behavior. In these regimes, fluctuation theorems Jarzynski 1997 ; Crooks 1999 provide a very powerful machinery to study systems far from equilibrium in the stochastic setting. Still, many open questions remain, particularly when quantum dynamics cannot be neglected Schmiedl and Seifert 2007 ; Esposito et al. 2010a ; Aurell et al. 2011 ; Benenti et al. 2017 ; Miller et al. 2019 ; Bäumer et al. 2019 ; Ye et al. 2022 ; Erdman et al. 2023 ; Campbell et al. 2025 ; Bonança and Deffner 2018 . Two-level systems play an central role in the study of thermodynamic optimization in the mesoscopic regime as they reduce the problem to its most fundamental components Allahverdyan et al. 2013 ; Abiuso and Perarnau-Llobet 2020 ; Denzler and Lutz 2021 . However, most often the optimization problem remains still too complex to solve it in full generality. In this work, we adopt an optimal control framework to generalize the pioneering work of Ref. Esposito et al. 2010b to effective two level systems, where each level may be arbitrarily degenerate. This generalization allows for the implementation of this optimization procedure into a wide variety of nano- and mesoscopic two-level systems, for arbitrary driving speeds. In realistic settings, such “two-level” systems often arise by coarse-graining multiple degenerate states into a single effective energy level. The resulting system has thermodynamic and dynamical properties that are significantly different from those of the microscopic case where there are no degeneracies. Therefore these differences must be taken into account when studying the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of these effective systems. A simple example of such a system is a quantum dot where the two logical states are defined via electronic occupation: the empty state is non-degenerate, while the occupied state exhibits twofold degeneracy due to the spin of the electron Aggarwal et al. 2025 . Furthermore, these different properties that effective two-level systems exhibit can also be desirable. For instance, they emerge naturally as the energy structure that maximizes the sensitivity of thermometers Correa et al. 2015 ; Mehboudi and Miller 2022 ; Abiuso et al. 2024 and as the thermodynamic optimum for collective effects Rolandi et al. 2023a . Here we consider scenarios where one can extract ( W<0 ) or inject ( W>0 ) some amount of work W from/into the system by changing the energy gap E between the two coarse-grained levels in some finite amount of time \tau , while it interacts with a thermal reservoir. The amount of work can be split into a reversible and irreversible contribution W=\Delta F_{neq}+W_{diss} . \Delta F_{neq} is the non-equilibrium free energy difference, and depends exclusively on the initial and final conditions of the state and Hamiltonian. Whereas W_{diss} is the dissipated energy, which depends on the way the energy gap is changed and the state trajectory throughout the process. By the second law of thermodynamics, W_{diss}\geq 0 , with equality in the reversible limit. For fixed boundary conditions, the task of minimizing the work cost is equivalent to minimizing the dissipated energy. In general this is a hard objective because of the high degree of complexity in the dynamics of open quantum systems. Multiple approaches exist to obtain analytical results. For example, one can make assumptions on the driving speed of the Hamiltonian: either that the system does not have the time to evolve during the process Erdman et al. 2019 ; Cavina et al. 2021 ; Blaber et al. 2021 ; Rolandi et al. 2023b , or that it remains close to its steady state Scandi and Perarnau-Llobet 2019 ; Scandi et al. 2020 ; Abiuso et al. 2020 ; Mehboudi and Miller 2022 ; Rolandi et al. 2023b ; Lacerda et al. 2025 ; Scandi et al. 2025 . Other approaches, such as optimal transport theory Pietzonka and Seifert 2018 ; Van Vu and Saito 2023 ; Beatty 2025 ; Koyuk et al. 2018 and thermodynamic control Esposito et al. 2010b ; Bonança and Deffner 2018 ; Deffner and Bonança 2020 ; Aggarwal et al. 2025 allow us to also obtain analytical results by making different sets of assumptions. Here, similarly to Esposito et al. 2010b ; Aggarwal et al. 2025 , we restrict the system dynamics to a family of master equations, allowing us to obtain exact results on the optimal driving of E(t) without any assumption on the driving speed. II. Framework We consider an open (finite-dimensional) quantum system in contact with a thermal bath, where its energetic structure is equivalent to that of a two-level system \hat{H}(t)=E_{e}(t)\hat{\Pi}_{e}+E_{g}(t)\hat{\Pi}_{g} , where \hat{\Pi}_{e} is a rank n projector and \hat{\Pi}_{g} is a rank m projector, with \hat{\Pi}_{g}\hat{\Pi}_{e}=\hat{\Pi}_{e}\hat{\Pi}_{g}=0 . These projectors define what we refer to as the excited sector \mathcal{H}_{e} and the ground sector \mathcal{H}_{g} , so that we can decompose the Hilbert space of the system as a direct sum \mathcal{H}=\mathcal{H}_{g}\oplus\mathcal{H}_{e} . Defining the energy gap as E(t):=E_{e}(t)-E_{g}(t) and denoting the state of the system at time t as \hat{\rho}(t) , we can express the expected work cost of a transformation as W=\int_{0}^{\tau}\!dt~\dot{E}(t){\rm Tr}[\hat{\Pi}_{e}\hat{\rho}(t)]~. (1) We want restrict our attention to cases where each sector