A Theory of Information, Variation, and Artificial Intelligence

Bijean Ghafouri · 2025

Read A Theory of Information, Variation, and Artificial Intelligence by Bijean Ghafouri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19264.txt.

Introduction

Bijean Ghafouri argues that artificial intelligence squeezes the variety of human expression while also seeding new ideas, in work from 2025. Generative tools are spreading across science, culture, and office work. Output variety is the raw stock of discovery, so a squeeze matters.

He names two forces. Models compress variation by design, and users deepen the squeeze by deferring to the output. Yet shared forms travel cheaply across fields, which can spark fresh recombinations elsewhere. Together, the forces trace a U over time: variety dips, then rebounds, but only if people curate rather than defer. Testable forecasts follow from the frame. Without active care, he warns, the rebound may never come.

Catalog record

CREATORBijean Ghafouri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19264

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Theory of Information, Variation, and Artificial Intelligence Bijean Ghafouri Abstract A growing body of empirical work suggests that the widespread adoption of generative AI produces a significant homogenizing effect on information, creativity, and cultural production. I first develop a novel theoretical framework to explain this phenomenon. I argue that a dynamic of AI - derivative epistemology, in which individuals increasingly defer to AI outputs, allows a centralized AI Prism to function, a technical mechanism whose architecture is designed to reduce variance and converge on the statistical mean. This provides a causal explanation for the generative monocultures observed in recent studies. However, I contend this represents only the first stage of a more complex and dialectical process. The paper’s central and paradoxical thesis is that the very homogenization that flattens knowledge within specialized domains simultaneously renders that knowledge into consistent modules that can be recombined across them, a process foundational to innovation and creativity. However, this recombinant potential is not automatic, but rather conditional. This paper argues that these opposing forces, homogenizing defaults versus recombinant possibilities, are governed by the nature of human engagement with the technology. The ultimate effect of generative AI is conditional on whether individuals act as passive consumers deferring to the AI’s statistical outputs, or as active curators who critically interrogate, re-contextualize, and recombine them. The paper concludes by outlining the cognitive and institutional scaffolds required to resolve this tension, arguing they are the decisive variable that determines whether generative AI becomes an instrument of innovation or homogenization. I propose to consider the question, "What will AI do to information?" ( Turing 1950 ). A rapidly growing body of empirical work has begun to document the effects of generative artificial intelligence on the nature of information. A clear, if unsettling, consensus is now emerging from this research. Across a wide variety of domains, including academic writing, professional communication, creative ideation, and visual art, the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs) produces a well - documented homogenizing effect ( Anderson et al. 2024 ; Doshi & Hauser 2024 ; Padmakumar & He 2023 ; Leppänen et al. 2025 ; Zhou & Lee 2024 ). This research consistently shows that while the use of AI can increase the productivity of individuals, it simultaneously works to narrow the diversity of the ideas and information they produce. The dominant and distressing conclusion in the literature is that AI functions as an engine of informational, creative, and stylistic convergence ( Qiu et al. 2025 ; Leppänen et al. 2025 ). While these empirical findings are robust, the literature still lacks a theory to explain why this homogenization occurs. My first goal in this paper is therefore to offer such an explanation. I argue that the homogenizing effect is the direct result of a dynamic I term AI-derivative epistemology. This is a mode of inquiry in which individuals increasingly outsource their cognitive and evidentiary work to an AI model ( Thiele 2025a ), treating its single, synthesized output as a primary source of truth ( Messeri & Crockett 2024 ). This learned dependency, I will show, allows the model to function as a prism, i.e. a centralized instrument whose internal statistical mechanics are designed to compress variation and converge on the mean ( Wu et al. 2024 ). The AI Prism , powered by our epistemic deference to it, is the causal engine that produces the generative monocultures and reduced informational variance observed in the empirical literature. The variance of information is a critical, yet often overlooked, feature of a healthy knowledge ecosystem. Variance functions as a form of epistemic capital in a knowledge ecosystem. Variance, in this context, refers to the range and distribution of perspectives, styles, conceptual frames, and problem formulations available within a collective knowledge environment. A system with higher variance contains a greater number of distinct informational “building blocks,” increasing its resilience to shocks, its adaptability to novel problems, and its capacity to generate unexpected solutions. This assumption draws on a large body of work from cultural evolution, collective intelligence, and innovation studies. Cultural-evolutionary theory shows that societies with larger and more interconnected “collective brains” tend to sustain a greater diversity of cultural variants, which in turn supports technological complexity and adaptive flexibility ( Henrich 2004 ; Muthukrishna & Henrich 2016 ). Similarly, research in organizational science finds that groups with greater cognitive diversity outperform homogeneous groups on complex problem-solving tasks precisely because their members bring non-overlapping solutions to the search space ( Hong & Page 2004 ). In both domains, the more varied the available elements, the richer the set of possible recombinations. To conceptualize the technology’s dual effect, this paper paints generative AI as a digital compost ( Rettberg 2024 ). Like compost, AI consumes a multitude of distinct inputs, i.e. the entire corpus of digitized culture, and reduces them to a common, seemingly undifferentiated whole. This first motion appears to be a simple act of informational homogenization. However, the result is not dormant. It is a latent medium, one that can either be left to compact into an infertile monoculture or be actively cultivated as a fertile ground for new growth. Thus, generative AI is best understood as a kind of digital compost. When regularly turned with fresh inputs, it decomposes prior cultural matter into nutrient-rich fragments for recombination. Left untouched, it compacts into an infertile land. Variance also underwrites creativity in the narrow sense. Empirical work on high-impact scientific and artistic production shows that breakthrough outputs tend to combine a conventional core with a small but crucial set of anomalous or “outlier” elements ( Uzzi et al. 2013 ). These anomalies are only discoverable if they remain present in the informational environment. When variance declines, whether through social conformity, monopolization of production channels, or algorithmic convergence, the probability of encountering such high-leverage anomalies falls accordingly. For these reasons, variance is not merely a descriptive property of information, but a normative one. The reduction of variance is an assumed epistemic cost, even when accompanied by gains in efficiency or accessibility. The homogenizing tendencies of the AI Prism are therefore evaluated in this paper not only in terms of their productivity effects, but also in terms of their impact on the variance profile of the collective knowledge ecosystem. The account I have offered thus far, however, remains incomplete. A near-universal assumption in the current literature is that the homogenizing effects of generative AI carry only negative normative implications for information and creativity. In this paper, I advance a countervailing and paradoxical thesis, building on foundational work on the division of cognitive labor and recombinant innovation ( Muthukrishna & Henrich 2016 ; Uzzi et al. 2013 ). I argue that the primary function of AI, i.e. to flatten local hills of specialized information by rendering it into standardized, homogeneous knowledge modules, simultaneously and counterintuitively serves to throw new bridges across previously disconnected information valleys. The very process of local homogenization that creates these consistent modules is what paradoxically increases the likelihood of high-impact and cross-domain recombination. This creates the conditions for an overall increase in global informational variance, even as the variance within any single domain may decline. This creates the central tension this paper seeks

Read the complete text