Single pion-production and pion propagation in Achilles Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-25-0473-T

Joshua Isaacson, William Jay, Alessandro Lovato, Pedro Machado, Alexis Nikolakopoulos, Noemi Rocco, Noah Steinberg · 2025

Read Single pion-production and pion propagation in Achilles Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-25-0473-T by Joshua Isaacson, William Jay, Alessandro Lovato, Pedro Machado, Alexis Nikolakopoulos, Noemi Rocco, Noah Steinberg (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19213.txt.

Introduction

When a neutrino strikes a nucleus, the debris tells the story, and simulators must predict every fragment. Joshua Isaacson and co-authors extend a leading event simulator, Achilles, to cover single pion production in full detail. The interaction vertex uses a state-of-the-art coupled-channels model with realistic descriptions of the struck nucleus. The escaping pion then rattles through the leftover nucleus in a simulated cascade.

Every piece of the chain uses consistent physics, from the first strike to pion absorption. The team validates against pion scattering data and against electron and neutrino measurements from major experiments. Neutrino oscillation programs live or die by such simulations: the signal is a handful of particles, and misunderstanding one pion can bend the inferred physics.

Catalog record

CREATORJoshua Isaacson, William Jay, Alessandro Lovato, Pedro Machado, Alexis Nikolakopoulos, Noemi Rocco, Noah Steinberg
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19213

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Single pion-production and pion propagation in Achilles Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-25-0473-T Preprint: MSUHEP-25-018 Joshua Isaacson, William Jay, Alessandro Lovato, Pedro Machado, Alexis Nikolakopoulos, Noemi Rocco, Noah Steinberg Abstract We extend the applicability of Achilles (A CHIcagoLand Lepton Event Simulator) by incorporating the single-pion production mechanism in a fully exclusive fashion. The electroweak interaction vertex is modeled by combining the state-of-the-art Dynamical Coupled-Channels approach with realistic hole spectral functions, which account for correlations in both the initial target state and the residual spectator system. Final-state interactions are treated using a semi-classical intranuclear cascade that leverages nuclear configurations to determine the correlated spatial distribution of protons and neutrons. The meson-baryon scattering amplitudes used in the cascade are computed within the Dynamical Coupled-Channels framework, consistent with the electroweak vertex. To model pion absorption, we employ the optical potential approach of Oset and Salcedo. As an alternative approach, we explicitly model the production and propagation of resonances which mediate pion-nucleon scattering and pion absorption. We validate our approach against pion-nucleon and pion-nucleus scattering data, and present comparisons with electron- and neutrino–nucleus measurements from e4 ν \nu , T2K, MINER ν \nu A, and MicroBooNE. I Introduction Accurately modeling neutrino–nucleus scattering in the resonance-production region is critical for the success of accelerator-based neutrino oscillation programs. This region is particularly important for Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) Abi et al. 2020 , as the incoming neutrino flux spans energies from 1 to 10 GeV. A precise understanding of resonance production is also essential for experiments with lower-energy fluxes, such as the planned Hyper-Kamiokande (HK) Abe et al. 2018a , since pions produced in neutrino interactions can be reabsorbed within the nucleus, causing such events to be misidentified as quasi-elastic. This effect is especially relevant when comparing predictions from nuclear ab initio methods to flux-folded cross sections, as these misidentified events must be excluded from the measured cross section Lovato et al. 2020 ; Acharya et al. 2025 . Capitalizing on liquid-argon detectors—such as those used in the Short Baseline Neutrino (SBN) program Alvarez Garrote 2025 and DUNE—requires modeling neutrino–nucleus scattering in an exclusive manner. A complete quantum-mechanical treatment of the complex nuclear dynamics involved in this process will remain unfeasible in the foreseeable future, despite ongoing progress using quantum computers to simulate simplified scenarios Roggero et al. 2020 ; Weiss et al. 2024 . Neutrino event generators make the problem tractable by separating the electroweak interaction vertex—treated at the quantum-mechanical level—from the subsequent intranuclear cascade (INC), which models the semi-classical propagation of hadrons through the nuclear medium Andreopoulos et al. 2010 ; Golan et al. 2012a ; Mosel 2016 ; Hayato and Pickering 2021 . This work focuses on single-pion production on nuclei, a multi-scale problem that involves both hadronic and nuclear excitations in a region where quantum chromodynamics is strongly coupled. In addition, the momenta at play are much larger than the pion mass, which places it outside the radius of convergence of chiral effective field theory in this regime. Thus, the model developed by Hernández, Nieves, and Valverde (HNV) Hernandez et al. 2007 , which evaluates the non-resonant background amplitudes from a leading-order chiral Lagrangian, is limited at intermediate energies. To extend its applicability, particularly in the \Delta region, the authors of Ref. Alvarez-Ruso et al. 2016 have partially unitarized the model by imposing Watson’s theorem to the dominant vector and axial multipoles. Two of the most widely used event generators, NEUT and GENIE, rely on the Rein–Sehgal model Rein and Sehgal 1981 and its Berger–Sehgal extension Berger and Sehgal 2007 . These frameworks simulate pion production through the incoherent excitation of multiple nucleon resonances—primarily the \Delta(1232) , but also higher-mass N^{*} and \Delta states—followed by their decay into a nucleon and a pion. The Berger–Sehgal model improves upon the original formalism by accounting for the charged lepton mass and refining the pion angular distributions. Vector transition form factors are constrained by electroproduction data, while axial contributions are typically modeled with a dipole form and tuned to historical neutrino–deuteron data Wilkinson et al. 2014 . NuWro has long included only the \Delta(1232) explicitly and treated higher invariant mass production via a smooth interpolation to a Deep-Inelastic-Scattering (DIS)-based hadronization model, invoking quark-hadron duality Golan et al. 2012b . More recently, NuWro has adopted the Ghent hybrid model Yan et al. 2024 . In the low-energy region, the resonant and non-resonant contributions are those of the HNV model. At higher energies, the description of the non-resonant background is instead based on Regge phenomenology González-Jiménez et al. 2017 ; Guidal et al. 1997 . In this work, we implement in Achilles the Dynamical Coupled-Channels (DCC) model Kamano et al. 2013a ; Nakamura et al. 2015a ; Kamano et al. 2016 ; Döring et al. 2025 to compute the single-pion production amplitudes. The DCC approach provides a unified, unitary description of meson–baryon scattering and electroweak pion production by solving coupled integral equations for multiple reaction channels. This framework enables a consistent treatment of both resonant and non-resonant contributions, including their interference, across a broad range of energies and final states. We note that the recent implementation of the DCC model in NEUT Yamauchi et al. 2024 is fully inclusive. Therefore, it computes the hadronic response via the structure functions, and is therefore limited to providing only lepton kinematics, without access to the hadronic final state. In contrast, our implementation retains the full dynamical information of the DCC amplitudes, allowing for the exclusive modeling of the hadronic final state, including pion and nucleon kinematics. To account for correlations in the initial target state and the residual spectator system, we employ realistic hole spectral functions of 12 C Rocco et al. 2019a and 40 Ar Nikolakopoulos et al. 2024 nuclei. After the primary interaction, all produced hadrons are propagated through the nuclear medium using an INC that accounts for scattering, absorption, and charge exchange. To gauge the sensitivity to a range of in-medium effects, we implement and test two different cascade modes depending on whether the \Delta and higher nucleon resonances are propagating degrees of freedom. In the first approach, the relevant meson–baryon cross sections are computed from the standard decomposition of the scattering matrix into partial-wave amplitudes. Crucially, to ensure consistency with the electroweak interaction vertex, these amplitudes are computed within the Dynamical Coupled-Channels (DCC) framework. In addition to meson–baryon scattering, where a meson remains in the final state, absorption processes play a significant role in the INC. Here, we implement an approach commonly used in neutrino event generators, based on the optical potential model of Oset and Salcedo Salcedo et al. 1988 , in which mesons are absorbed via the imaginary part of their self-energy in nuclear matter. Crucially in this approach, nucleon resonances are not propagating degrees of freedom. In the second approach, we follow the approach taken by GiBUU Buss et al. 2012 and INCL Cugnon et al. 1996 where we treat the \Delta resonance as a dynamical degree of freedom that propagates throughout the nuclear medium. This approach provides a more microscopic description of three-body processes involved in pion absorption (e.g., \pi N\leftrightarrow\Delta,\Delta N\leftrightarrow NN ), and accurately accounts for the relatively long lifetime of the \Delta resonance, compared to typical intranuclear propagation timescales. This provides a

Read the complete text